Loading...
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms. Rules for Better Search
No Folders have been created
Are you sure you want to delete "My most important" ?
NOTE:




















This is a neutral professional article. The judgment is analysed in the context of its factual background, issues framed, and conclusions reached by the Court.
2026 (8) TMI 1189 - BOMBAY HIGH COURT
The TDS system rests on a division of statutory responsibilities. The payer or deductor withholds tax from the payee's income, remits it to the Central Government, files prescribed statements and furnishes the prescribed certificate. The deductee receives only the net amount and ordinarily has no practical control over remittance, statement filing, correct PAN reporting or portal reflection.
A difficulty arises where tax is withheld but the deductor neither deposits it nor files the TDS statement. The amount may consequently not appear in Form 26AS, and Form 16 or Form 16A may not be available. A statement-driven processing system may then deny TDS credit while processing the return and create a demand. The resulting demand can impair refunds and incorrectly portray the deductee as a defaulter despite the deduction from the income already offered to tax.
The principal ruling, 2026 (8) TMI 1189 - BOMBAY HIGH COURT, resolves this difficulty by treating proof of actual deduction as the foundational question. It holds that, once actual deduction is established and verified, the deductor's subsequent default cannot defeat TDS credit or result in recovery from the deductee. The ruling also recognises that the modern electronic process may make formal TDS certificates unavailable precisely because the deductor has defaulted in the steps necessary for their generation.
Section 190 identifies deduction or collection at source and advance payment as modes by which tax on income is payable even though regular assessment may occur later. Its material language is that tax "shall be payable by deduction or collection at source or by advance payment" in accordance with Chapter XVII.
Section 191 requires direct payment by the assessee where the Chapter makes no deduction provision or "where income-tax has not been deducted in accordance with" Chapter XVII. Read with Section 205, this provision does not make the deductee pay again where deduction has actually occurred but the deductor has failed to remit the withheld amount.
Section 198 provides that sums deducted in accordance with the relevant provisions of Chapter XVII are deemed to be income received for computation purposes. Thus, the deductee's taxable income is computed on the gross amount, rather than merely the net receipt.
Section 199(1) states that deduction made under the foregoing provisions of Chapter XVII and "paid to the Central Government" shall be treated as payment of tax on behalf of the person from whose income it was deducted. Section 199(3) authorises the Board to make rules for giving credit. In ordinary compliant cases, this accounting rule operates through deductor-furnished data and the statutory rules. It must, however, be harmonised with Section 205 where actual deduction is established but the deductor has defaulted.
Section 200(1) places the remittance obligation squarely upon the deductor: a person deducting any sum "shall pay within the prescribed time, the sum so deducted to the credit of the Central Government". Under Section 200(3), the deductor must, after payment, prepare and deliver the prescribed statement. The provision permits correction statements, but no correction statement can be delivered after six years from the end of the financial year in which the original statement was required.
Section 201(1) provides that a person required to deduct tax who does not deduct, does not pay, or after deduction fails to pay the tax, is deemed to be an assessee in default. Section 201(1A)(ii) also imposes simple interest at one and one-half per cent for every month or part of a month from the date of deduction to actual payment. These provisions demonstrate that the statutory consequence of post-deduction default is directed at the deductor.
Section 205 contains the substantive safeguard: "the assessee shall not be called upon to pay the tax himself to the extent to which tax has been deducted from that income." Its language makes actual deduction, not remittance by the deductor or availability of a certificate, the trigger for the bar against demand on the deductee.
Rule 31 prescribes Form 16 for deduction or payment under Section 192 and Form 16A for deduction under other provisions of Chapter XVII-B. The certificate must contain, among other particulars, the deductee's PAN, the deductor's TAN, challan or book-identification particulars, and receipt details of the relevant TDS statement. Form 16 is annual and is to be furnished by 15 June of the immediately following financial year; Form 16A is quarterly and is to be furnished within fifteen days from the due date for furnishing the TDS statement.
Rule 37BA(1) provides that credit for tax deducted and paid to the Central Government is to be given to the deductee on the basis of information relating to deduction furnished by the deductor. Rule 37BA(4) requires credit to be granted on the basis of deductor-furnished information and the taxpayer's return claim, "subject to verification in accordance with the risk management strategy formulated by the Board". This establishes verification as an integral feature of the credit mechanism; it does not render Form 26AS or a certificate conclusive against a taxpayer who asserts a verified, non-reflected deduction.
Section 119(1) authorises the Board to issue orders, instructions and directions for proper administration of the Act, which income-tax authorities must observe and follow. The provision cannot require an authority to make a particular assessment or dispose of a particular case in a particular manner. Its relevance is that administrative processes and portal-facing actions must remain consistent with the Act and cannot displace the Section 205 protection.
The principal ruling harmonises Sections 199 and 205. Section 199 addresses attribution and accounting of tax payment; Section 205 protects a person from being called upon to pay tax that has already been withheld from that person's income. A construction that allows denial of credit and continued recovery solely because the deductor did not remit the money would permit indirectly what Section 205 prohibits directly.
The ruling further applies the settled maxim lex non cogit ad impossibilia in substance: the law does not compel the impossible. Following deduction, the deductee cannot compel deposit, upload the deductor's statement, alter Form 26AS or independently generate the prescribed certificate. It would therefore be unjust to treat the deductor's non-performance as a condition that the deductee must satisfy.
The Supreme Court order considered in the principal ruling is significant for the approach it records: TDS credit follows where TDS has been deducted, though the amount may not have been paid by the deductor, but the factual claim requires verification. While the Supreme Court set aside directions requiring software changes, it did not disturb relief granted on the merits. The governing conclusion is accordingly not one of automatic portal-based allowance; it is entitlement upon verification of actual deduction.
Form 16 and Form 16A remain valid and important evidence where available. But in a non-deposit case, their absence cannot be treated as conclusive. The electronic sequence ordinarily requires payment, statement filing and system generation. Consequently, insistence on a certificate as the sole proof would create a closed evidentiary loop: the very default that causes the claim would also deprive the deductee of the stipulated proof.
For salary income, cogent material may include salary slips reflecting gross salary, tax deduction and net salary; the appointment letter, offer letter or employment contract coupled with bank statements reflecting net salary; employer payroll workings, year-end tax workings, cost-to-company break-ups and tax computation sheets; and contemporaneous communications seeking deposit of TDS or Form 16. Computer-generated salary slips cannot be rejected merely because they lack a signature.
For contractor payments, professional fees, rent and comparable receipts, the relevant material may include invoices or fee memos showing gross and net amounts; bank statements; payment intimations or remittance advice; ledgers maintained by either party; payer confirmations; and correspondence regarding certificates or non-deposit. The difference between gross invoice value and net receipt, when consistent with the applicable withholding structure, can be material corroboration.
For interest, dividend and similar receipts, interest advice, dividend advice, payment warrants, payer confirmations and ledgers evidencing net payment after withholding may be relied upon. Across all categories, communications with the deductor or the Department, insolvency or liquidation claims, and admissions in the deductor's books, correspondence, affidavit or other proceedings may provide useful corroboration.
Once a taxpayer produces prima facie reliable material, the Assessing Officer must conduct a real factual inquiry. The Department may obtain information from the deductor, the TDS officer having jurisdiction over the deductor, or an insolvency professional or liquidator where relevant. The absence of direct confirmation from a non-cooperative, closed or insolvent deductor is not, by itself, a ground to reject an otherwise cogent claim.
2007 (7) TMI 7 - HIGH COURT, BOMBAY treated salary slips and bank statements as adequate undisputed proof that TDS had been deducted. It held that Section 205 applies once deduction is established, regardless of non-deposit and non-issuance of Form 16. This authority is particularly relevant because it rejects the proposition that absence of the statutory certificate permits a second recovery from the employee.
2014 (8) TMI 418 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT held that Form 16 or Form 16A establishes entitlement to TDS credit even where the Department's system does not reflect the credit. It confirms that a portal mismatch does not negate primary documentary evidence and that recourse for non-deposit is against the deductor.
2023 (2) TMI 1079 - DELHI HIGH COURT separately examined the consequences of a mismatch. It held that Section 205 bars both direct recovery and indirect recovery through adjustment of a future refund. Its practical importance lies in recognising refund adjustment as an impermissible form of recovery from the deductee.
2023 (11) TMI 808 - DELHI HIGH COURT went beyond non-recovery and upheld the deductee's entitlement to credit despite non-deposit and non-reflection in Form 26AS. It reasoned that withholding from income does not permit the Revenue to shift the deductor's remittance default to the person from whose income tax was retained.
2018 (9) TMI 1635 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT treated Form 16A as documentary proof of deduction and directed grant of credit despite the employer's non-deposit. It also required restoration of amounts adjusted from later refunds, preserving the distinction between recovery from the deductor and prejudice to the deductee.
2019 (1) TMI 1612 - BOMBAY HIGH COURT affirmed a verification-based approach where supporting evidence was produced despite a Form 26AS mismatch. It is important on proof because it requires the Assessing Officer to test the evidence and grant credit on verification, rather than allowing a defective deductor record to determine the outcome.
2021 (11) TMI 682 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT held that Sections 201 and 205 together protect a deductee from recovery where the employer deducted but did not deposit TDS. Credit and restoration of amounts adjusted or recovered were directed, while preserving proceedings against the deductor.
2023 (6) TMI 1135 - DELHI HIGH COURT applied the Section 205 bar to a claim for credit and refund where the deductor's short deposit was not disputed. The ruling reinforces that withholding a refund or setting it off against such demand is an indirect recovery prohibited by the statutory bar.
2023 (2) TMI 753 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT distinguished between the accounting language of Section 199 and the protection against enforcement under Section 205, while granting TDS credit and restoration of any intervening recovery or adjustment. It preserves the Department's right to pursue the defaulting deductor.
2023 (12) TMI 34 - DELHI HIGH COURT held that the phrase "and paid" in Section 199 cannot be read in isolation from Chapter XVII. Once a payer retains money as TDS, the retained sum remains tax in character; denial of credit would improperly penalise the deductee for the deductor's default.
2000 (1) TMI 43 - GAUHATI HIGH COURT represents the narrower view that Section 199 requires deposit to the Central Government and the prescribed certificate before credit is granted. Yet it also held recovery proceedings against the deductee impermissible where deduction had occurred. The principal ruling notes this divergence but concludes, after considering the later Supreme Court order and the wider statutory scheme, that verified deduction must result in credit.
2024 (11) TMI 88 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT quashed an intimation and consequential demand where deduction was undisputed but deposit had failed. Its software-correction directions were subsequently set aside by the Supreme Court, but the individual relief on the merits was not disturbed. The principal ruling accordingly treats the decision as support for merits-based relief subject to factual verification, not as a mandate for a particular technological solution.
2015 (3) TMI 221 - ITAT MUMBAI is relevant to evidentiary burden in mismatch cases. It held that production of TDS certificates and deductor-wise particulars discharges the taxpayer's primary burden, leaving the Revenue to verify the claim and identify any infirmity. Its application is limited to the circumstances considered there, including verification of deduction and deposit, but it supports the proposition that Form 26AS is a reconciliation mechanism rather than an irrebuttable bar to credit.
A taxpayer claiming unreflected TDS should make a focused written application before the jurisdictional Assessing Officer. The application should identify the income offered to tax, the gross amount, the TDS claimed, the net amount received, the deductor, the unavailable or non-reflecting certificate, and the supporting evidence. Documentary material should be organised payment-wise and reconciled with the return of income and bank records.
Upon receipt of prima facie supporting material, the Assessing Officer is required to register and acknowledge the application, keep the corresponding demand in abeyance, and mark it appropriately as stayed, not recoverable or kept in abeyance so that coercive recovery and refund adjustment do not occur during verification. A reasoned order should be passed as expeditiously as possible and preferably within six months from receipt of the application.
The taxpayer's evidentiary case is stronger where the material forms a coherent chain: the contract or employment basis establishes gross entitlement; the invoice, payslip or advice shows withholding; the bank statement establishes the net receipt; and correspondence records timely objection to missing certificates or deposit. The claim should not rest merely on a numerical assertion of TDS.
The Department retains the right to investigate the claim and act against the deductor under the statutory machinery. The protection does not extend to fabricated, unsubstantiated or unverified claims. It operates only to the extent that actual deduction from the taxpayer's income or payment is established.
Circular No. 4/2012 also reflects the procedural importance of verification: where there is zero TDS matching, credit is to be allowed only after due verification, and in other mismatch cases credit is to be allowed after due verification. This supports an evidence-led adjudicatory process rather than mechanical denial solely because electronic matching has failed.
Full Text: