Loading...
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms. Rules for Better Search
No Folders have been created
Are you sure you want to delete "My most important" ?
NOTE:




















This is a neutral professional article. The judgment is analysed in the context of its factual background, issues framed, and conclusions reached by the Court.
2026 (8) TMI 1630 - Supreme Court
Imported goods remain under customs control until their lawful clearance, warehousing or transhipment. The statutory scheme identifies both the person responsible for their custody and the consequence of pilferage occurring during that period. The central question is whether an approved customs-area custodian, including a statutory port authority, must pay customs duty when imported goods are pilfered in its custody.
The Supreme Court addressed this question in 2026 (8) TMI 1630 - Supreme Court. It upheld the validity of a notification approving a statutory port authority as custodian under Section 45(1). The Court also preserved the conclusion that demands for the period before that approval could not survive, since Section 45(3) liability depends on approval under Section 45(1).
The decision gives practical effect to the allocation of risk under the Customs Act. Section 13 relieves the importer from duty for pilferage before clearance. Section 45(3) prevents the resulting revenue loss by shifting the statutory duty burden to the approved custodian, rather than treating the importer's exemption as extinguishing the levy itself.
Section 2 of the Customs Act, 1962 defines "imported goods" as goods brought into India from a place outside India, excluding goods already cleared for home consumption. It defines "customs area" as the area of a customs station or warehouse and includes an area in which imported or export goods are ordinarily kept before clearance by customs authorities. These definitions identify the goods and the controlled location to which Section 45 applies.
Section 12 of the Customs Act, 1962 provides that customs duties are levied on goods imported into, or exported from, India, except as otherwise provided. The material exception for pilferage is Section 13: "If any imported goods are pilfered after the unloading thereof and before the proper officer has made an order for clearance for home consumption or deposit in a warehouse, the importer shall not be liable" for duty, unless the goods are restored after pilferage.
Section 23 of the Customs Act, 1962 separately addresses goods lost, otherwise than by pilferage, or destroyed before clearance for home consumption. Its opening words, "Without prejudice to the provisions of section 13", preserve the distinction between ordinary loss or destruction and pilferage. That distinction is material: Section 45(3) is specifically directed to pilferage.
Section 45 of the Customs Act, 1962 contains the operative framework. Section 45(1) states that, "Save as otherwise provided in any law for the time being in force", imported goods unloaded in a customs area shall remain in the custody of the person approved by the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner until clearance, warehousing or transhipment.
Section 45(2) applies to a person having custody either under Section 45(1) or under another law. It requires that person to keep records and send a copy to the proper officer; it also provides that goods must not be removed from the customs area or otherwise dealt with except with written permission of the proper officer or in the prescribed manner.
Section 45(3), however, is directed to the person referred to in Section 45(1). Its operative language is: "Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force", where imported goods are pilfered after unloading in a customs area while in such person's custody, that person "shall be liable to pay duty". The duty rate is the rate prevailing on the date of delivery of the arrival manifest, import manifest or import report under Section 30 of the Customs Act, 1962.
The Supreme Court treated approval under Section 45(1) as a necessary condition for the liability under Section 45(3). The words "a person referred to in sub-section (1)" are decisive. Thus, a person having factual or statutory custody cannot be required to pay duty under Section 45(3) for pilferage occurring before it was approved as the Section 45(1) custodian.
This conclusion is significant in demand proceedings. The department must identify the approval or notification, its precise scope, and its operative period. Where the alleged pilferage precedes the approval, a Section 45(3) demand cannot be sustained merely because the person otherwise exercised operational control over the customs area.
The Court rejected the proposition that a statutory authority entrusted with goods under port law is incapable of approval under Section 45(1). A "person" capable of approval includes a juristic person, including a statutory board or port authority. The Commissioner may therefore approve such a body as custodian of the notified customs area.
The authority to specify customs-area limits under Section 8 of the Customs Act, 1962 works alongside Section 45. Section 8 identifies the spatial limits of the customs area; Section 45 identifies the custodian and regulates the custody, removal and consequences of pilferage within that area.
A port authority taking charge of goods may have civil responsibility as a bailee. Under Section 148 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, bailment concerns delivery of goods for a purpose upon a contract for return or disposal as directed. The bailee's obligation under Section 151 is to take the care that an ordinarily prudent person would take of goods of similar bulk, quality and value. Under Section 152, a bailee who has taken that degree of care is ordinarily not liable for loss, destruction or deterioration; Section 161 addresses loss arising from the bailee's default in returning, delivering or tendering goods at the proper time.
The Court held that this civil, owner-facing responsibility is conceptually different from the revenue-facing liability under Section 45(3). The latter is neither compensation nor indemnification payable to the owner. It is a statutory duty to pay customs duty to the revenue where the statutory conditions are met. Any private right of recovery, indemnity or recourse available to the custodian does not detract from that primary obligation.
Section 45(1) begins with a saving clause, while Section 45(3) begins with an overriding clause. The Court harmonised the provisions by recognising that another enactment governing custody or conditional bailee responsibility does not, by itself, exclude approval under Section 45(1) or duty liability under Section 45(3). The statutory port-law regime did not impose a corresponding customs-duty liability for pilferage. Consequently, there was no conflict requiring the customs provisions to yield.
Once an approved custodian holds goods in the customs area, Section 45(3) operates notwithstanding the conditional civil-liability framework under the port statute. This construction also avoids the consequence that the importer is exempted under Section 13 while no person remains liable for the customs duty attributable to pilfered goods.
The strictness of Section 45(3) does not eliminate its factual predicates. There must be imported goods, unloading in a customs area, pilferage, approved custodianship under Section 45(1), and custody at the time of pilferage. In 2026 (4) TMI 21 - CESTAT New Delhi, the Tribunal held that a discrepancy between the import manifest description and the goods subsequently found was insufficient by itself. Where examination records did not reveal broken, replaced or tampered seals, pilferage or substitution during the custodian's custody was not proved. The duty demand and consequential penalties were therefore set aside.
That approach is consistent with Section 45(3): it imposes a defined statutory consequence for pilferage, not an irrebuttable liability for every mismatch in cargo description. Documentary evidence concerning seal integrity, examination reports, inventory records, gate movement, custody transfer and the point at which the shortage was detected is therefore central.
In 2024 (8) TMI 1565 - Delhi High Court, the Court held that goods which had entered the customs area remained "imported goods" for Section 45(3), notwithstanding confiscation-related arguments based on the concept of smuggled goods. The decision reinforces that the relevant inquiry is whether goods brought from outside India were in the custodian's charge when pilfered.
In 2024 (9) TMI 1503 - Delhi High Court, Section 45(2)(b), Section 45(3), and the custodian's regulatory responsibilities were applied to uphold duty and penalty where the record established pilferage while the goods remained in the custodian's custody. The custodian could not shift its statutory obligation to another security agency.
Similarly, 2025 (1) TMI 1328 - CESTAT New Delhi applied the principle that a custodian bears responsibility for safe custody until clearance for home consumption or warehousing. The Tribunal also held that the relevant show-cause notice was within time on the facts recorded there.
Conversely, 2022 (12) TMI 1340 - Orissa High Court declined to impose Section 45(3) duty where the record indicated loss in a natural calamity and did not establish pilferage. The decision illustrates the statutory distinction between pilferage and loss or destruction, as well as the need for evidence before characterising an unaccounted quantity as pilfered.
For customs-area custodians, the statutory exposure begins with the approval instrument. Custodians should retain the approval notification, map of the notified area, conditions of approval, and records demonstrating the date from which custody under Section 45(1) commenced. These records are critical both to establish the period of responsibility and to resist demands concerning an earlier period.
Operational compliance must track Section 45(2). Inventory reconciliation, arrival and examination records, seal-verification logs, electronic gate controls, access-control registers, CCTV preservation, incident reports and prompt reporting of shortages are not merely administrative safeguards. They are evidence relevant to whether goods were pilfered while in custody and whether the goods were removed or dealt with without permission.
The Handling of Cargo in Customs Areas Regulations, 2009 supplements these obligations. Regulation 6 of the Handling of Cargo in Customs Areas Regulations, 2009 requires a Customs Cargo Service Provider to maintain records, refrain from allowing removal without written permission, ensure safety and security of goods in its custody, and pay duty on goods pilfered after entry into the customs area. Regulation 5 further requires security and access control designed to prohibit unauthorised access, insurance, and prescribed infrastructure and manpower arrangements.
In litigation, the inquiry should be framed in sequence: Was the entity approved under Section 45(1)? Was the relevant location a customs area? Did the alleged event constitute pilferage rather than non-pilferage loss? Did it occur after unloading and while the approved custodian had custody? What is the manifest date for rate determination? The answer to each question should be supported by contemporaneous records rather than assumed from a subsequent cargo discrepancy.
Full Text: