Loading...
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms. Rules for Better Search
No Folders have been created
Are you sure you want to delete "My most important" ?
NOTE:




















This commentary provides doctrinal analysis and practical insights on the legal issue discussed below. The judgment is analysed in the context of its factual background, issues framed, and conclusions reached by the Court.
2026 (7) TMI 1337 - MADRAS HIGH COURT
Refund of accumulated unutilised input tax credit under an inverted duty structure remains a tightly confined statutory remedy. The governing question is not whether the principal raw material and the finished product bear the same rate in isolation. The inquiry is whether credit has accumulated because one or more statutory inputs used for the outward supply bear a rate higher than the rate applicable to that output supply.
In 2026 (7) TMI 1337 - MADRAS HIGH COURT, the Court considered a manufacturer whose principal input and output were taxable at the same rate, while chemicals, consumables and packing materials used in manufacture attracted higher rates. The refund claims were rejected on the footing that there was no inverted duty structure because the principal input and output attracted identical rates. The Court rejected that approach, quashed the rejection orders and directed processing of the claims under the formula in Rule 89(5), after a personal hearing.
The decision is significant because it affirms that Section 54(3)(ii) does not create a "principal input" test. It requires a rate-based examination of inputs used in the business and the resulting accumulation of eligible credit. At the same time, the statutory restriction recognised by the Supreme Court remains material: in an inverted-duty claim, refund is confined to credit attributable to input goods and does not extend to input services or capital goods.
Section 2 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 supplies the essential vocabulary. Section 2(59) defines "input" as "any goods other than capital goods used or intended to be used by a supplier in the course or furtherance of business." Section 2(60) separately defines "input service" as any service used or intended to be used in the course or furtherance of business. Under Section 2(62), "input tax" includes central, State, integrated and Union territory tax charged on supplies made to a registered person, subject to the stated exclusions, while Section 2(63) defines "input tax credit" as the credit of input tax. This deliberate distinction is central to the scope of an inverted-duty refund.
The operative provision is Section 54 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. Section 54(3), subject to Section 54(10), permits a registered person to claim refund of unutilised ITC at the end of any tax period. The first proviso makes this permission restrictive: "no refund of unutilised input tax credit shall be allowed in cases other than" the stated categories. For the present purpose, clause (ii) permits refund "where the credit has accumulated on account of rate of tax on inputs being higher than the rate of tax on output supplies", excluding nil-rated or fully exempt supplies and goods or services notified for exclusion.
The temporal discipline is equally important. Section 54(1) requires an application within two years from the relevant date. For a claim under clause (ii) of the first proviso to Section 54(3), Explanation 2(e) identifies the relevant date as the due date for furnishing the return under Section 39 for the period in which the claim arises. Section 54(7) requires an order under Section 54(5) within sixty days of receipt of an application complete in all respects. Section 54(8)(b) further provides that a refund of unutilised ITC under Section 54(3) is to be paid to the applicant rather than credited to the Consumer Welfare Fund.
The statutory exception in clause (ii) must also be read with Notification No. 5/2017-Central Tax (Rate). Exercising the exclusionary power in the proviso, the notification identifies specified goods for which no refund of unutilised ITC is available where accumulation is due to a higher rate on inputs. Therefore, a claimant must establish not only rate inversion and accumulation, but also that the relevant output supply is not covered by a notified exclusion.
Rule 89 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 regulates the application and computation. Rule 89(1) requires electronic filing in FORM GST RFD-01 through the common portal. Rule 89(2)(h) specifically requires, for an inverted-duty claim, a statement of the number and date of invoices received and issued during the tax period. Rule 89(3) requires a debit to the electronic credit ledger equal to the refund claimed.
Rule 89(5) provides the governing formula:
"Maximum Refund Amount = {(Turnover of inverted rated supply of goods and services) x Net ITC / Adjusted Total Turnover} - {tax payable on such inverted rated supply of goods and services x (Net ITC/ ITC availed on inputs and input services)}."
For this formula, "Net ITC" means input tax credit availed on inputs during the relevant period, while "Adjusted Total Turnover" and "relevant period" bear the meaning assigned in Rule 89(4). The formula accordingly implements the substantive distinction between input goods, input services and capital goods.
The first controversy is whether the statutory phrase "rate of tax on inputs being higher than the rate of tax on output supplies" requires a comparison of only the dominant input with the finished product. The language does not refer to a "principal input", "major component" or "predominant raw material". It uses the plural expressions "inputs" and "output supplies". As a matter of ordinary statutory construction, an adjudicating authority cannot introduce a dominant-input condition that Parliament did not enact.
The decisive question is causation: whether eligible ITC has accumulated on account of inputs taxed at a higher rate than output supplies. A same-rate principal input may be relevant to the factual computation, but it is not conclusive where other input goods used in manufacture carry higher rates and contribute to accumulated credit.
The second issue concerns the source of refundable credit. The statutory definition confines "input" to goods other than capital goods. Consequently, the phrase in Section 54(3)(ii) cannot be enlarged to include input services merely because input-service credit may also remain unutilised in the electronic credit ledger. The rule-based definition of Net ITC adopts this same distinction. A claim must therefore segregate input goods from input services and capital goods before applying the Rule 89(5) formula.
Circular No. 135/05/2020-GST addresses several refund matters. Paragraph 3.2 states that where the input and output are the same goods but attract different rates at different points in time, the case is not covered by Section 54(3)(ii). Paragraph 3.3, however, recognises a different situation: where output supplies are made at a concessional rate and, at the same point of time, the rate on inputs exceeds that on output supplies, refund may be admissible, subject to the statutory exclusions.
The interpretative difficulty arises when paragraph 3.2 is deployed as a broad prohibition simply because a principal input and the output are alike or taxable at the same rate. The judicial approach reflected in the authorities below is that an administrative circular cannot narrow the statutory test or create an exclusion that Section 54(3)(ii) does not contain. The Court in the governing decision recorded that the impugned circular had already been declared unconstitutional and held that no separate relief concerning it was required.
The central reasoning in 2026 (7) TMI 1337 - MADRAS HIGH COURT is doctrinally straightforward. The statute makes no distinction between major and minor components. The fact that cotton yarn, as the principal input, and the resultant yarn were subjected to the same rate did not erase the rate differential on chemicals, packing materials and other input goods. Where such inputs attracted higher rates and generated unutilised credit, the statutory condition could be satisfied.
This construction gives effect to the words "on account of". They require a real connection between the higher-rated inputs and the accumulation of credit. They do not require that every input, or the principal input, must bear a higher rate. Conversely, the provision does not sanction a refund merely because some purchases bear a higher rate in the abstract; the claimant must demonstrate use or intended use in the course or furtherance of business, eligibility of the credit, the applicable rates, and the factual accumulation attributable to the inverted structure.
The statutory formula is not displaced by this conclusion. Rule 89(5) determines the maximum refund and guards against a direct one-to-one refund of the entire electronic credit balance. In particular, Net ITC is credit availed on inputs during the relevant period. The computation must therefore be supported by period-wise purchase registers, tax invoices, inward-supply details, output tax data, return reconciliations and a reasoned working of adjusted total turnover and inverted-rated turnover.
The decision also reinforces the difference between entitlement and quantification. Section 54(3)(ii) determines whether the class of claim is maintainable. Rule 89(5) determines the maximum refundable quantum. An authority may verify the computation, eligibility of ITC, nexus of goods with the outward supply and the absence of a notified exclusion; it cannot reject the claim merely by comparing only the principal raw material with the output product.
In 2021 (9) TMI 626 - Supreme Court, the Supreme Court held that the first proviso to Section 54(3) is a substantive restriction, not merely an eligibility threshold. It construed "inputs" in clause (ii) as input goods and not input services, upheld Rule 89(5) as intra vires, and rejected a constitutional challenge founded on Article 14. The Court acknowledged imperfections in the formula but declined to rewrite it. This authority is decisive on the exclusion of input services from Net ITC for inverted-duty refunds; it does not endorse a principal-input test.
In 2020 (9) TMI 931 - MADRAS HIGH COURT, the Court had similarly held that "inputs" in Section 54(3)(ii) bears the statutory meaning in Section 2(59), namely goods other than capital goods. It treated the words "credit has accumulated on account of" as imposing a source-based limitation and upheld the amended Rule 89(5). The analysis complements the governing decision: the refund can rest on higher-rated input goods, but not on input services or capital goods.
In 2023 (12) TMI 361 - DELHI HIGH COURT, the Court held that parity between a principal input and principal output does not by itself defeat a claim where other component inputs taxed at higher rates cause accumulation. It construed Circular No. 135/05/2020-GST as addressing temporal rate changes for the same goods, rather than as an absolute denial of a claim involving higher-rated component inputs. This reasoning closely supports the result in the governing decision.
In 2022 (7) TMI 73 - RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT, the Court held that the circular could not introduce a restriction based on sameness of input and output supplies when Section 54(3)(ii) contains no such condition. The decision emphasises the settled hierarchy that subordinate executive directions cannot override the parent statute.
In 2022 (4) TMI 118 - CALCUTTA HIGH COURT, the Court likewise held that a circular issued for uniform implementation under Section 168(1) cannot curtail the statutory entitlement under Section 54(3). A distinction excluding claims merely because inputs and outputs are the same was held impermissible.
In 2021 (9) TMI 472 - GAUHATI HIGH COURT, the Court held that the conflicting portion of the circular must yield to Section 54(3)(ii). Importantly, it remitted the matter for a factual determination of whether the actual rate on inputs exceeded the actual rate on outputs. The authority shows that invalidity of an overbroad circular does not eliminate the claimant's burden to establish factual rate inversion.
In 2024 (7) TMI 1160 - MADRAS HIGH COURT, a rejection founded on the circular was set aside and remitted for fresh decision, particularly because refunds had been sanctioned for earlier periods on the same basis. The decision underscores the need for consistency in departmental treatment of materially similar claims.
In 2026 (9) TMI 2079 - MADRAS HIGH COURT, the Court held that eligibility in a cotton-yarn claim required factual examination of whether the taxpayer manufactured the output using the asserted inputs or merely traded the yarn. The ruling confirms that the nature of activity and documentary nexus are foundational to an inverted-duty refund.
In 2023 (9) TMI 905 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT, the Court held that portal constraints could not extinguish the underlying refund entitlement computed under Rule 89(5). A second application made under an available administrative mechanism for the balance amount required substantive consideration. The practical lesson is that technical portal treatment and ledger reversals must be reconciled against the statutory and rule-based entitlement.
In 2019 (8) TMI 159 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT, the Court held that the delegated power to notify supplies for which refund is unavailable did not extend to providing for lapse of already accumulated ITC. The decision distinguishes a restriction on refund from extinguishment of validly accumulated credit, a distinction that remains relevant when applying notification-based exclusions.
A robust refund application should contain a rate-comparison matrix for every material input good and the relevant output supply. It should identify the principal input but should not allow the analysis to end there. Chemicals, consumables, packing materials and other goods used in manufacture should be separately mapped to invoices, applicable rates and the manufacturing process. Input services and capital goods should be distinctly identified because their credit is not included in Net ITC for Rule 89(5).
The claimant should file FORM GST RFD-01 with the invoice statement required by Rule 89(2)(h) and a transparent Rule 89(5) computation. Under Rule 90, the proper officer must scrutinise completeness within fifteen days and issue FORM GST RFD-02 if complete. If deficiencies are communicated in FORM GST RFD-03, a fresh application is required after rectification; the interval between filing and communication of deficiencies is excluded from the two-year limitation period for the fresh claim.
A proposed rejection must follow the safeguards in Rule 92. Rule 92(3) requires a notice in FORM GST RFD-08, a reply in FORM GST RFD-09 within fifteen days of receipt, and consideration of the reply; no refund application may be rejected without an opportunity of hearing. Where a claim is rejected, Rule 93 requires re-credit to the electronic credit ledger of the amount debited to the extent of rejection, subject to the rule's conditions.
Delay consequences should be specifically tracked. Section 56 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 provides for interest where tax ordered to be refunded under Section 54(5) is not refunded within sixty days from receipt of the application. The proviso prescribes a separate interest framework where a final order of an adjudicating authority, appellate authority, tribunal or court gives rise to refund and the consequential application is not refunded within the specified period.
The governing principle is that an inverted-duty refund under Section 54(3)(ii) turns on accumulation caused by higher-rated input goods vis-a -vis output supplies, not on a comparison restricted to the principal input and output alone. The statutory phrase is broad enough to capture qualifying component inputs, but narrow enough to exclude input services and capital goods from the Rule 89(5) Net ITC computation.
Administrative guidance must operate within that statutory boundary. Equally, a claimant must meet the evidentiary burden of showing genuine manufacturing or supply activity, eligible input goods, actual rate inversion, quantified accumulation and compliance with the statutory exclusions, formula and prescribed procedure. The result is a disciplined statutory remedy: neither defeated by an unstated principal-input condition nor expanded beyond the limits enacted in Section 54(3)(ii) and Rule 89(5).
Full Text: