Loading...
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms. Rules for Better Search
No Folders have been created
Are you sure you want to delete "My most important" ?
NOTE:




















This is a neutral professional article. The judgment is analysed in the context of its factual background, issues framed, and conclusions reached by the Court.
2026 (8) TMI 719 - Supreme Court
Rule 96 provides the framework for refund of integrated tax paid on goods or services exported out of India. In relation to export of goods, Rule 96 treats the shipping bill filed by an exporter as a deemed refund application. The application is deemed to have been filed only after the export manifest, export report or departure manifest covering the shipping bill is filed, the applicant furnishes a valid return in FORM GSTR-3B, and Aadhaar authentication is completed in the prescribed manner. For export of services, Rule 96(9) requires an application in FORM GST RFD-01, to be dealt with under Rule 89.
Prior to its omission, Rule 96(10) imposed a distinct restriction upon the refund route involving payment of integrated tax on exports. In substance, it provided that a person claiming such refund should not have: "received supplies" on which the benefits under specified notifications had been availed; or "availed the benefit" under specified customs notifications. The provision also contained an Explanation under which the relevant notification benefit was not treated as availed where the registered person had paid integrated tax and compensation cess on inputs and had availed exemption only from basic customs duty under those notifications.
Notification No. 20/2024 omitted Rule 96(10) with effect from 08 October 2024. The omission did not contain a clause continuing investigations, adjudications, refund rejections, or other proceedings pending under the omitted sub-rule. The central question, therefore, was whether the restriction nevertheless survived for claims and proceedings that were pending when the omission took effect.
The answer is supplied by 2026 (8) TMI 719 - Supreme Court. The Court dismissed the departmental challenge to the view that omission of Rule 96(10) operates in respect of every proceeding pending on the date of omission. Consequently, pending refund claims must be considered without applying the restriction formerly contained in Rule 96(10).
Section 16 of the Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 defines "zero rated supply" to include export of goods or services or both. Section 16(4) permits the Government, subject to notification-based conditions, safeguards and procedures, to specify a class of persons or goods or services that may make zero-rated supply on payment of integrated tax and claim refund of tax so paid in accordance with Section 54 of the CGST Act or the rules made thereunder.
Section 54 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 is the general refund provision. Section 54(1) permits a refund application "before the expiry of two years from the relevant date" in the prescribed form and manner. Its Explanation expressly includes within "refund" the refund of tax paid on zero-rated supplies. Section 54(8)(a) further requires that a refundable amount relatable to tax paid on export of goods or services be paid to the applicant rather than credited to the Fund, subject to the statutory framework.
These provisions establish the substantive refund setting. Rule 96 supplied the export-specific mechanism, including the deemed application procedure for export of goods. Rule 96(10), when it existed, operated as a restriction on the eligibility of persons claiming refund of integrated tax paid on exports. Its omission thus bears directly on the eligibility determination in pending matters, while leaving the other statutory conditions, safeguards and verification requirements intact.
Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 applies where the Act itself, or a Central Act or Regulation, repeals an enactment. Unless a contrary intention appears, the repeal does not affect prior operation, accrued rights, obligations or liabilities, or an investigation, legal proceeding or remedy concerning them. The operative saving in clause (e) permits such proceeding or remedy to be "instituted, continued or enforced" as if the repealing Act or Regulation had not been passed.
Its textual limits are material. Section 3 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 defines a "Central Act" as an Act of Parliament and defines "Rule" as a rule made in exercise of power conferred by an enactment. A Rule is consequently subordinate legislation and does not become a Central Act merely because the power to frame it derives from a Central Act. Rule 96(10) was omitted by amendment rules; that mode of omission does not satisfy the statutory basis required for Section 6 to apply.
In 2026 (8) TMI 719 - Supreme Court, the issue was framed as whether omission of Rule 96(10), with effect from 08 October 2024, benefits assessees in pending proceedings concerning refund of integrated tax paid on exports, so that the claim is considered without the Rule 96(10) restriction. The Court answered the issue in the affirmative.
The Court recorded that the sub-rule was omitted without a saving clause or a sunset clause. It accepted the governing principle that, on omission of a rule, a pending proceeding can continue only where there is a provision for its continuance or a statutory legal device creating a fiction under which proceedings under the omitted rule may continue. Neither was present here.
The Court also considered the GST Council recommendation that the omission be prospective. The recommendation was held to be advisory and non-binding upon the rule-making authority. More importantly, the Court found that the stated reason for omission was that Rule 96(10) was "leading to unnecessary complications without any intended benefit being served". In the absence of a saving clause, the Court concluded that the omission was intended to bring those complications to an end, including in pending proceedings. The departmental appeals were accordingly dismissed.
2000 (2) TMI 823 - Supreme Court is the principal authority applied in the controlling ruling. It held that Section 6 of the General Clauses Act is confined to repeals by a Central Act or Regulation and does not extend to omission of a rule. It further explained that where an old rule is omitted and there is no saving provision in the omission instrument, the parent statute, or a newly introduced provision, proceedings initiated under the omitted rule lapse. Any order thereafter made in such proceedings lacks legal basis.
The relevance is direct. Rule 96(10) was a rule, and its omission was effected through subordinate legislation. The absence of a saving mechanism was therefore decisive. The ruling also rejects the proposition that a newly available or continuing statutory refund framework, by itself, keeps alive a restriction created exclusively by the omitted rule.
1969 (7) TMI 109 - Supreme Court considered whether a prosecution could be initiated under a rule after that rule had been omitted. The saving there covered only matters already done or omitted to be done; it did not continue the rule so as to support fresh proceedings after omission. The decision confirms that a saving must clearly preserve the authority sought to be exercised. Its relevance to Rule 96(10) lies in the insistence that a general reference to past conduct cannot substitute for an express continuation of the omitted rule.
2002 (9) TMI 3 - Supreme Court applied the omission principle to a penal statutory provision. Following the earlier binding approach, it held that Section 6 does not extend to an omission and could not sustain prosecution under the omitted provision. Although it concerned a statutory penal provision rather than an export-refund rule, it reinforces the distinction between repeal and omission that underlies the Rule 96(10) result.
2025 (9) TMI 806 - Bombay High Court examined the omission of Rules 89(4B) and 96(10) and held that they affected substantive rights rather than being purely procedural provisions. It held that Section 6 of the General Clauses Act did not apply because the omission was made through rules, not through a Central Act or Regulation. It consequently treated unfinalised matters as not preserved by the omission instrument. The controlling ruling upheld this approach specifically in relation to Rule 96(10) and pending proceedings.
2025 (5) TMI 1811 - Uttarakhand High Court addressed an order passed after Rule 96(10) had been omitted. Applying the omission principle, it held that an unconditional omission without a saving clause required action under the rule to stop and invalidated a post-omission adjudication founded on the omitted restriction. This decision is particularly relevant to pending refund adjudications and is consistent with the subsequent controlling determination.
2019 (12) TMI 1312 - Karnataka High Court held that proceedings founded exclusively on an omitted statutory provision could not survive where there was no saving clause. The decision concerns a statutory provision rather than Rule 96(10), but supports the proposition that an unqualified omission removes the legal foundation of pending action that depends solely upon the omitted measure.
1985 (3) TMI 65 - Gujarat High Court held that a proceeding initiated under an omitted recovery rule could not be concluded after omission where there was neither a saving clause nor a statutory fiction continuing the old proceeding under a new provision. It also held that simultaneous introduction of a replacement statutory provision was insufficient without express language preserving the earlier proceeding. This reasoning accords with the absence of any continuation provision for Rule 96(10).
1981 (12) TMI 39 - High Court of Allahabad similarly held that a show-cause notice issued under an omitted rule lapsed where the new statutory framework did not deem the old proceeding to continue under the new provision. The decision is relevant for the procedural proposition that a notice does not independently survive the omission of the legal source that authorises its adjudication.
2012 (11) TMI 954 - Gujarat High Court considered omitted subordinate rules and an omitted charging provision. It held that proceedings could not be initiated after omission of the rules and that, once the parent charging provision was omitted without a saving clause, unfinalised proceedings could not lawfully be completed. While the statutory context differs, the decision illustrates the need for an express saving if an omitted legal regime is to continue operating.
1995 (8) TMI 5 - Madhya Pradesh High Court quashed prosecution commenced after omission of penal provisions in the absence of a saving clause. Its relevance is confined to the general consequence of omission: action cannot be founded on a provision no longer in force unless the legislature has expressly preserved that authority.
1992 (8) TMI 89 - Gujarat High Court Full Bench took a different approach in the context of substituted and omitted excise recovery rules. It reasoned that the charging liability under the parent statute remained in force, while the changes concerned the machinery for recovery; the substituted provisions substantially continued the earlier scheme. On that basis, it held that the recovery proceedings did not lapse merely by substitution or omission.
That reasoning does not alter the present result. Rule 96(10) was not treated in the controlling ruling as a mere interchangeable recovery mechanism. It was a specific restriction on the availability of integrated-tax refund on exports. Further, the controlling ruling holds that omission without a saving clause applies to all pending proceedings and requires the refund claim to be assessed without the omitted restriction. To that extent, any contrary analogy based on continuity of machinery provisions cannot govern the application of Rule 96(10).
Refund claims pending on 08 October 2024 must be assessed without applying the former Rule 96(10) restriction. An adjudication cannot continue to deny the integrated-tax refund by invoking that omitted sub-rule.
Taxpayers should identify the precise status of every claim, show-cause notice, adjudication and appeal as on the omission date. The controlling ruling concerns proceedings that were pending; the treatment of matters not pending is outside this article's scope.
A challenge to a refund denial should distinguish between a ground based solely on Rule 96(10) and other independently applicable refund conditions. Removal of Rule 96(10) does not itself establish refund entitlement where the claim fails on another surviving statutory or procedural requirement.
Exporters should retain and reconcile shipping bills, export manifest or report details, FORM GSTR-1 data, FORM GSTR-3B, bank-account particulars and other materials required under Rule 96. For services, the FORM GST RFD-01 route and Rule 89 procedure remain material.
The two-year limitation in Section 54(1), computed from the applicable "relevant date", remains important. For goods exported by sea or air, Section 54 explains that the relevant date is the date on which the ship or aircraft carrying the goods leaves India; distinct statutory rules apply for goods exported by land or post and for export of services.
In litigation, the decisive propositions are the absence of a saving clause, the subordinate character of Rule 96(10), and the inapplicability of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act to its omission. The advisory character of the GST Council recommendation cannot create a saving that the rule-making instrument did not enact.
The legal position for pending export-refund proceedings is clear. By 2026 (8) TMI 719 - Supreme Court, omission of Rule 96(10) without a saving clause operates in favour of assessees in all proceedings pending on the date of omission. The refund claim must therefore be considered without the former restriction concerning specified notification benefits.
This conclusion follows not from a retrospective re-enactment of refund rights, but from the legal consequence of unconditional omission of a subordinate rule. Section 6 of the General Clauses Act does not preserve the omitted Rule 96(10), because the provision concerns repeal by a Central Act or Regulation and not omission of a rule. At the same time, all independent conditions under the zero-rated supply, refund and export-refund framework continue to require compliance.
Full Text: