Member credit income, co-operative bank deposit interest and share-capital interest remain deductible for unlicensed credit co-operative societies.

A credit co-operative society without an RBI banking licence is not treated as a co-operative bank for the relevant deduction, so income from credit facilities provided to members remains eligible even if it accepts deposits from non-members; income from loans to non-members is excluded. Interest earned on deposits with co-operative banks also qualifies because such banks remain co-operative societies for the depositor society's deduction. Interest paid on repayable share capital is allowable, as the capital is akin to borrowed funds and the payment reduces interest income from members. The first appellate authority's deductions and allowance were sustained.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether a credit co-operative society without an RBI banking licence is entitled to deduction for income from credit facilities provided to its members despite accepting deposits from, or extending loans to, non-members; (ii) Whether interest earned by a co-operative society on deposits with co-operative banks qualifies for deduction; (iii) Whether interest paid on the society's share capital is allowable as a deduction.

Issue (i): Whether a credit co-operative society without an RBI banking licence is entitled to deduction for income from credit facilities provided to its members despite accepting deposits from, or extending loans to, non-members.

Analysis: The exclusion applies to a co-operative bank, and a society cannot be treated as such without the requisite RBI licence. Receipt of deposits from non-members does not itself bar deduction for income attributable to credit facilities provided to members. However, profits attributable to credit facilities extended to non-members are not eligible for the deduction. The claim in the present case was confined to interest from loans advanced to members.

Conclusion: The society is entitled to deduction for income from credit facilities provided to its members; the finding is in favour of the assessee.

Issue (ii): Whether interest earned by a co-operative society on deposits with co-operative banks qualifies for deduction.

Analysis: Interest derived by a co-operative society from investments with another co-operative society is deductible. Although a co-operative bank is excluded from claiming deduction in its own assessment, it continues to be a co-operative society for this purpose; therefore, the depositor society's interest from deposits with such banks remains eligible.

Conclusion: Interest on deposits with the co-operative banks qualifies for deduction; the finding is in favour of the assessee.

Issue (iii): Whether interest paid on the society's share capital is allowable as a deduction.

Analysis: Share capital in a co-operative society is repayable to members upon cessation of membership and is treated akin to borrowed capital. Interest paid on such capital reduces the interest collected from members and does not form part of profit. In any event, an addition of that interest would correspondingly increase eligible business profit.

Conclusion: Interest paid on share capital is allowable as a deduction; the finding is in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The deductions and allowance granted by the first appellate authority stand sustained for both assessment years.

Ratio Decidendi: A co-operative credit society lacking an RBI banking licence is not excluded as a co-operative bank, and deductions remain available only to the extent income is attributable to credit facilities provided to its members; interest from investments with co-operative banks is also eligible where the recipient bank remains a co-operative society.

---