Facts: R Ltd built a mall (2018-21), let it out on taxable rent and claimed Rs 180 crore of construction ITC. The SC in Safari Retreats (Oct 2024) held that 'plant or machinery' in s.17(5)(d) is subject to a functionality test and remanded for fact-finding. R then utilised the ITC. S.119 of the Finance Act 2025 substituted 'plant and machinery' retrospectively from 01.07.2017. An SCN now demands Rs 180 crore with interest and penalty, invoking s.74. A financial creditor has also filed u/s 7 IBC.
Developments: GSTAT (Flora Kingdom Farm Resort) upheld the retrospective amendment and denied credit for a resort building. Delhi HC (Riveria Commercial, Aug 2026) disposed of the vires challenge and extended s.14 Limitation Act benefit for past-period claims. Orissa HC stayed recovery in a matter applying the amendment.
Questions:
1. Is the amendment curative or a substantive new burden? Can it survive Arts. 14, 19(1)(g) and 265 when it nullifies an SC interpretation instead of curing a defect (D. Cawasji, Shree Sidhbali Steels)?
2. Is ITC already credited and utilised a vested right (Eicher Motors) that retrospective law cannot take away?
3. Can s.74 (suppression) or s.50 interest lie for a period when R's position matched the law as the SC had declared it?
4. Does the functionality test survive at all for a building that is the very apparatus of a leasing business, given that the Explanation to s.17 excludes 'land, building or other civil structures' from 'plant and machinery'?
5. If CIRP starts, must the disputed GST demand be admitted as a secured statutory claim under Rainbow Papers, or can the CoC value it at nil?
6. Accounting and audit: is the reversal an Ind AS 8 prior-period error or an Ind AS 37 contingency? Must the disputed dues be reported under CARO 3(vii)(b)?
TaxTMI