Facts: H Ltd is registered in Maharashtra and Gujarat. In 2021 it gave a Rs 500 crore corporate guarantee to a bank for its 100% subsidiary S Ltd (Gujarat). The guarantee was renewed in Feb 2024 and no fee is charged. Under Ind AS 109, H's standalone accounts record the fair value as a deemed investment in S, amortised to P&L as 'guarantee commission income'. The TPO made an arm's-length adjustment at 0.5% p.a. DGGI issued an SCN u/s 74 to the Gujarat GSTIN from July 2017, applying Rule 28(2) at 1% p.a., 'whichever is higher'.
Conflict:
- Bombay HC, D.P. Jain (May 2026): no consideration means no supply, following Edelweiss.
- Gujarat HC, Torrent Power (Aug 2026): Schedule I makes it a supply between related persons even without consideration. Rule 28(2) is valid, but 'whichever is higher' is read down. There is no levy before 26.10.2023, though continuing guarantees are taxable from then. S.74 cannot be invoked.
Questions:
1. Which HC's view governs: the one where the guarantee was executed, where the GSTIN targeted by the SCN sits, or where the recipient is? Can DGGI pick the Gujarat GSTIN to sidestep D.P. Jain?
2. Do the Ind AS 109 notional commission or the TP adjustment amount to 'consideration' u/s 2(31)? If so, the guarantee becomes a priced supply even under D.P. Jain, and that amount fixes value under Rule 28(2) as read down.
3. Is the 2024 renewal a fresh supply after 26.10.2023 or a 'continuing' guarantee per Torrent? What is the time of supply u/s 13 for an annual deemed value?
4. If S can take full ITC, does revenue neutrality defeat s.74 and the extended limitation?
5. For the FY 2025-26 audit, is this an Ind AS 37 contingent liability or a provision? Is it a Key Audit Matter given the conflicting HC rulings?
TaxTMI