Facts: For AY 2018-19 the Jurisdictional AO (not the faceless unit) issued notice u/s 148A(b) in May 2022, passed the 148A(d) order and issued the s.148 notice in July 2022. The HC quashed it as the JAO lacked jurisdiction after the e-Assessment Scheme, 2022 notified u/s 151A. While Revenue's appeal was pending, Finance Act 2026 inserted s.147A retrospectively from 01.04.2021, validating JAO-issued notices. The SC set aside the HC rulings and remitted the matters with liberty to challenge s.147A. From 01.04.2026, s.536(1) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 repealed the 1961 Act.
Post-remand split: P&H HC (Jyoti Sareen) struck s.147A down as a bare override of judicial findings, violating separation of powers and Art. 14. AP HC (Bala Sreenivas Rao Somisetty) also struck it down. Madras HC (Nate Nandha, single judge) dismissed the writs, treating JAO jurisdiction as confirmed.
Questions:
1. Does s.147A remove the legal basis of the earlier judgments (the s.151A scheme was left untouched), or merely overrule them? Apply the tests in Madan Mohan Pathak, Cheviti Venkanna Yadav and Bhubaneshwar Singh.
2. After the repeal, is a remitted reassessment a pending proceeding saved u/s 536(2)(c)? Or is the assessee's earlier quashing order a right accrued, protected by s.536 and s.6 of the General Clauses Act, which a validating clause in a statute that no longer exists cannot defeat?
3. With HCs split, which ruling binds: the HC over the JAO, over the assessee, or over the NFAC? Can the AO proceed before the SC decides?
4. Even if s.147A is valid, does the notice still fail the 'surviving period' limitation test in Rajeev Bansal (TOLA)?
Reasoned views with authorities are welcome.
TaxTMI