I am a Radiologist operating an ultrasound centre for approximately six years. For FY 2025-26 (AY 2026-27), I filed ITR-3 declaring professional income under Section 44ADA.
Latest Revised ITR Details:
-
Gross professional receipts: Rs. 29,54,750
-
Presumptive professional income: Rs. 16,54,050
-
Income from other sources: Rs. 8,72,109
-
Sale consideration of equipment: Rs. 15,55,717
-
Cost of acquisition: Rs. 20,11,096
-
Short-term capital loss reported: Rs. 4,55,379
-
Total taxable income: Rs. 25,26,160
In the latest revised ITR, Schedule DPM (Plant & Machinery), Schedule DCG and Schedule DEP reflect NIL depreciation/values. However, a short-term capital loss of Rs. 4,55,379 has been reported under Schedule CG and carried forward.
My CA has revised the return multiple times, adopting different approaches to depreciation, WDV and capital loss computation.
I seek expert opinions on the following:
-
Under Section 44ADA, is depreciation deemed to have been allowed, or can separate depreciation under Section 32 be claimed on ultrasound machines?
-
Should Schedule DPM and DCG be populated when professional income is declared under Section 44ADA?
-
If ultrasound machines form part of a depreciable block, should their disposal be treated under Section 50 rather than calculating loss using purchase cost minus sale consideration?
-
How should historical WDV be determined considering six years of operations and previous depreciation treatment?
-
Is reporting a short-term capital loss of Rs. 4,55,379 under Schedule CG legally correct?
-
Can a professional opting for Section 44ADA independently claim capital loss on disposal of depreciable equipment?
-
Considering multiple revised returns, should another revised return be filed if the present treatment is incorrect?
I request experienced CAs and tax professionals to provide guidance with reference to Sections 32, 44ADA and 50 and applicable ITR reporting provisions.
The latest revised ITR is available for reference.
Thank you for your valuable guidance.
TaxTMI