Loading...

⚠ ✕
❮ Top
☎ Help
☰
×

By creating an account you can:

Logo TaxTMI
Call Us / Help / Feedback✕

Contact Us At :

✉ E-mail: [email protected]

✆ To Call / Whatsapp, Check Contact Us

FAQs :

To know Frequently Asked Questions, Check FAQs

Most Asked Video Tutorials :

For more tutorials, Check Video Tutorials

Submit Feedback/Suggestion :

Email :
Please provide your email address so we can follow up on your feedback.
Category :
Description :
Min 15 characters 0/2000
╳
Add to...
You have not created any category. Kindly create one to bookmark this item!
✕
Create New Category
Hide
Title :
Description :
+ Post an Article
Post a New Article ✕
Title :
0/200 char
Description :
Max 0 char
Category :
Co Author :

In case of Co-Author, You may provide Username as per TMI records

Delete Reply

Are you sure you want to delete your reply beginning with ' ' ?

Delete Issue

Are you sure you want to delete your Issue titled: ' ' ?

Articles

Advanced Search ❮
Reset Filters
Search By:
Search by Text :
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms
Select Date:
From To
Category :
Sort By:
Relevance Date
Like 0 Bookmark Print or Download

RECENT CBIC CIRCULARS IN GST (PART-2)

Date 18 Nov 2026
GST demand notices and adjudication orders require specific allegations, evidence-based fraud claims, fair hearings and reasoned findings.
Fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax must be supported by specific facts and evidence; non-payment, incorrect reporting or a routine discrepancy alone is insufficient. Where that basis is absent, the adjudicating authority should record findings and apply the appropriate non-fraud provisions, subject to limitation and other statutory requirements. Under section 74A, applicable from financial year 2024-25, fraudulent and non-fraudulent allegations and demands must be separately identified. A second notice for a subsequent period on the same facts and fraud grounds is generally invalid without new and independent grounds. (AI Summary)

CBIC has issued several Notifications, Circulars and Instructions post 57th GST Council meeting held on 8th October, 2026 to implement its decisions. Circular No. 257 to 266 have also been released to explain or clarify certain changes and simplified understanding of law / procedures. Further, MoF has issued instructions vide Instruction No. 02/2026-GST dated 30.10.2026 to implement recommendations in relation to 'Arrest' provisions. All CGST filed formations have been directed that no further arrests may be carried out under GST law. These also include reforms for rationalization of e-way bill inspection and verification procedures and minimum threshold for issuance of show cause notices upto Rs. 10,000 u/s 73, 74 and 74A of CGST Act, 2017. Few changes are applicable w.e.f. 01.11.2026 itself.

This part contains gist of new Circular No. 258/2026-GST dated 26.10.2026

Clarification on issues related to demand, adjudication and appeal proceedings under the CGST Act, 2017.

1. Objective of the Circular

CBIC has issued guidelines to improve the quality, transparency, consistency and fairness of GST proceedings. The circular emphasizes that:

  • Show Cause Notices (SCNs) must clearly explain the allegations and legal grounds.
  • Adjudication and appellate orders must be reasoned, speaking orders.
  • Taxpayers must receive a reasonable opportunity to present their case.
  • Demands, interest and penalties must be properly justified and quantified.
  • Proceedings must comply with statutory time limits and principles of natural justice.

2. Key provisions and clarifications

A. Pre-Show Cause Notice Intimation - Rule 142(1A)

  • Pre-SCN intimation in FORM GST DRC-01A may be issued wherever feasible before issuing a formal SCN.
  • This provides taxpayers an opportunity to clarify discrepancies and may reduce unnecessary litigation.
  • The summary of the SCN or statement must be uploaded electronically in FORM GST DRC-01 or DRC-02, as applicable.

B. Mandatory requirements for drafting an SCN

A properly drafted SCN should contain the following:

  1. Taxpayer details: Name, GSTIN, registration status, jurisdiction and relevant tax period.
  2. Facts and evidence: Specific discrepancies, omissions and supporting documentary evidence.
  3. Legal provisions: Relevant statutory provisions and an explanation of how the alleged conduct violates them.
  4. Statement of charges: Clear allegations and grounds requiring an explanation from the taxpayer.
  5. Quantification: Proposed tax demand, preferably broken down financial year-wise.
  6. Conclusion: Name of the adjudicating authority, reply deadline and consequences of non-compliance.

An SCN cannot merely reproduce statutory provisions without explaining the factual basis of the allegations.

The circular refers to the Supreme Court judgment in M/s G.R. Infra Projects Limited Ratlam Versus The State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors. - 2026 (8) TMI 1497 - Supreme Court, emphasizing that deficiencies in the SCN cannot subsequently be cured by the final order.

C. Invocation of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression

This is one of the most important clarifications in the circular.

  • Sections 74(1) and 74A(5)(ii) cannot be invoked merely because GST has not been paid or a discrepancy has been detected.
  • There must be specific evidence of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts with intent to evade tax.
  • The SCN must disclose the material facts and evidence supporting the allegation.
  • Mere incorrect reporting or omission does not automatically establish wilful misstatement or suppression. Deliberate conduct and intent to evade tax must be established where required.
  • Routine scrutiny discrepancies should not automatically be treated as fraud cases.
  • Where the necessary evidence or justification is absent, the adjudicating authority should record appropriate findings and restrict the demand to the legally applicable non-fraud provisions, subject to limitation and other statutory requirements.
  • The circular also states that issuing a second SCN for a subsequent period on the same facts and grounds, again invoking fraud or suppression, is generally not legally valid unless new and independent grounds exist.

D. Separate demands under Sections 73, 74 and 74A

Provision

Nature of proceedings

Requirement

Section 73

Tax demand in cases not involving fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression

Demand must be supported by facts and applicable law.

Section 74

Tax demand involving fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression

Specific evidence and intent to evade tax must be established.

Section 74A

Applicable to FY 2024-25 onwards

SCN must clearly distinguish fraudulent and non-fraudulent allegations and quantify the respective demands separately.

Where a notice covers both fraudulent and non-fraudulent issues, the factual basis, legal grounds and amounts must be separately identified.

E. No parallel proceedings

  • Under Section 6 of the CGST Act, where an SGST or UTGST proper officer has already initiated proceedings concerning a particular subject matter, a CGST officer should not initiate proceedings on the same subject matter.
  • CGST and SGST authorities should coordinate to avoid duplicate proceedings and conflicting decisions.

F. Timely issuance and service of SCNs

  • Notices should be issued sufficiently in advance of statutory deadlines wherever practicable.
  • Service must comply with Section 169 of the CGST Act.
  • The prescribed summary of the demand notice must also be uploaded to the GST portal in FORM GST DRC-01, as applicable.

3. Personal hearings and principles of natural justice

Section 75(4) requires an opportunity of hearing where requested in writing by the person concerned or where an adverse decision is contemplated.

The circular provides the following guidance:

  • Adjudicating authorities may provide a maximum of four personal hearing opportunities, taking into account the limit on adjournments under Section 75(5).
  • Adjournment requests must be considered judiciously, with reasons recorded for rejection.
  • Requests for representation through authorized representatives must be considered.
  • Virtual hearings may be encouraged.
  • Detailed records of hearing dates, attendees, submissions and proceedings must be maintained.
  • The adjudication order should preferably be communicated within one month after the personal hearings.
  • If the adjudicating authority is transferred during proceedings, a fresh hearing should be given by the successor authority, subject to the guidance in the circular.

4. Requirements for a proper adjudication order

The circular strongly emphasizes that an adjudication order must be a speaking order, explaining the reasoning behind the decision.

Every order should:

  • Summarize the SCN, facts, tax periods and proposed demand.
  • Identify each issue requiring determination.
  • Analyse the evidence instead of merely reproducing documents.
  • Consider the taxpayer's reply in FORM GST DRC-06 and submissions made during hearings.
  • Record specific reasons for accepting or rejecting each material submission.
  • Discuss relevant judicial precedents cited by both the department and taxpayer.
  • Record clear findings on every material issue.
  • Quantify the final tax, interest and penalty accurately.
  • State the taxpayer's appellate rights and applicable pre-deposit requirements.

A generic statement such as "reply has been considered" is insufficient without discussing the taxpayer's material arguments.

Important restriction under Section 75(7)

The final adjudication order:

  • Cannot confirm tax, interest or penalty in excess of the amount specified in the notice, subject to the applicable statutory provisions.
  • Cannot confirm a demand on grounds other than those specified in the SCN.
  • Any new issue should ordinarily be pursued through a separate SCN.

Quantification of demand

The final order should preferably provide a financial year-wise and issue-wise calculation, separately identifying CGST, SGST, IGST and UTGST, wherever applicable.

It should clearly show:

  • Original demand proposed.
  • Demand confirmed after adjudication.
  • Demand dropped, fully or partially.
  • Interest and penalty.
  • Amounts already deposited and adjusted.
  • Balance payable or refundable.

Interest should be quantified as far as possible up to the date of the order, with clarification that applicable interest continues until actual payment.

Penalties must be justified individually and cannot be imposed mechanically.

Use of Artificial Intelligence

Where AI or other technological tools are used in adjudication:

  • The output must be independently verified.
  • Appropriate human oversight is mandatory.
  • The issuing officer remains responsible for the correctness of the order.

5. Rectification under Section 161

The circular clarifies the limited scope of rectification of errors apparent on the face of the record.

  • Rectification must be undertaken by the authority that issued the original decision, order, notice or other document.
  • An application for rectification may be filed within three months from the date of issue.
  • The rectification order should ordinarily be passed within six months from the date of issue of the original document, subject to the statutory exception for purely clerical or arithmetical errors arising from an accidental slip or omission.
  • Rectification requests should be disposed of through FORM GST DRC-08.

Rectification cannot be used to:

  • Reconsider the merits of the case.
  • Reappreciate evidence through a detailed review.
  • Correct debatable errors of law or fact.
  • Substitute for an appeal or review.
  • Only errors apparent from the record, not requiring lengthy reasoning or debate, fall within the scope of Section 161.

6. Guidelines for first appeal proceedings under Section 107

A. Preliminary scrutiny and limitation

The Appellate Authority should examine whether the appeal is procedurally complete, including the prescribed form, supporting documents, jurisdiction, pre-deposit and limitation.

  • An appeal must ordinarily be filed within three months of communication of the decision or order.
  • A further period of one month may be condoned where sufficient cause is established, as permitted under Section 107(4).
  • Delay beyond the legally condonable period cannot be overlooked merely because the appellant appears to have a strong case on merits.
  • Reasons for accepting or rejecting an appeal on limitation must be recorded.

B. Hearing and additional evidence

  • Hearing dates and proceedings should be properly documented.
  • Additional grounds may be allowed under Section 107(10), subject to the statutory conditions and recorded reasons.
  • Additional evidence may be admitted only in the circumstances permitted under Rule 112.
  • The adjudicating authority should receive a reasonable opportunity to examine and rebut additional evidence where applicable.
  • Appellate proceedings should not ordinarily become a fresh investigation to compensate for deficiencies in the original adjudication.

C. Disposal of appeals

  • Appeals should, as far as possible, be decided within one year, excluding periods covered by court or tribunal stays.
  • Cross-appeals by the taxpayer and department against the same order should be processed together and disposed of through a common, composite order.
  • The appellate order summary must be uploaded in FORM GST APL-04.

The guidelines on natural justice, reasoned orders and substantiation of fraud or suppression also apply, with necessary modifications, to appellate proceedings.

7. Practical impact on taxpayers

The circular provides useful safeguards for taxpayers facing GST demands, adjudication or appeals.

Issue

Practical benefit to taxpayer

Defective SCN

The taxpayer can challenge notices that lack specific allegations, material facts or legal grounds.

Fraud or suppression allegation

The department must establish the factual basis and required intent; mere non-payment or discrepancy is insufficient.

Ignored reply or evidence

The taxpayer's submissions must be independently examined and reasons recorded for rejection.

Excessive demand

The order cannot exceed the notice's specified demand or travel beyond its grounds, subject to the Act.

Incorrect penalty

The penalty must be legally justified and cannot be imposed mechanically.

Rectification request

Rectification is limited to apparent errors and cannot reopen the merits of the case.

Delayed appeal

The statutory limitation and limited condonation period must be observed.

Duplicate proceedings

Parallel CGST and SGST proceedings on the same subject matter should be avoided in accordance with Section 6.

8. Key takeaways

  1. SCNs must be specific, evidence-based and legally sustainable.
  2. Fraud, wilful misstatement and suppression cannot be alleged mechanically; the necessary evidence and intent must be established.
  3. Adjudication orders must address the taxpayer's submissions and explain the findings issue by issue.
  4. Demand, interest and penalty must be accurately quantified and supported by law.
  5. Rectification under Section 161 is narrow and cannot replace an appeal.
  6. Appellate authorities must follow statutory limitation periods, provide fair hearings and pass reasoned orders.
  7. These guidelines are illustrative and non-exhaustive. The circular specifically states that officers must not cite these guidelines themselves in SCNs, final adjudication orders or appellate orders.

Therefore, Circular No. 258/04/2026-GST seeks to strengthen due process in GST demand and appeal proceedings by requiring specific notices, evidence-based allegations, reasoned orders, fair hearings and accurate quantification. It is particularly relevant when challenging vague SCNs, unsupported allegations of suppression or fraud, non-speaking orders, excessive demands and improper rectification proceedings.

(To be continued)

0 answers
Sort by
+ Add A New Reply
Hide

No Replies are present.

Recent Articles