Loading...

⚠ ✕
❮ Top
☎ Help
☰
×

By creating an account you can:

Logo TaxTMI
Call Us / Help / Feedback✕

Contact Us At :

✉ E-mail: [email protected]

✆ To Call / Whatsapp, Check Contact Us

FAQs :

To know Frequently Asked Questions, Check FAQs

Most Asked Video Tutorials :

For more tutorials, Check Video Tutorials

Submit Feedback/Suggestion :

Email :
Please provide your email address so we can follow up on your feedback.
Category :
Description :
Min 15 characters 0/2000
╳
Add to...
You have not created any category. Kindly create one to bookmark this item!
✕
Create New Category
Hide
Title :
Description :
+ Post an Article
Post a New Article ✕
Title :
0/200 char
Description :
Max 0 char
Category :
Co Author :

In case of Co-Author, You may provide Username as per TMI records

Delete Reply

Are you sure you want to delete your reply beginning with ' ' ?

Delete Issue

Are you sure you want to delete your Issue titled: ' ' ?

Articles

Advanced Search ❮
Reset Filters
Search By:
Search by Text :
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms
Select Date:
From To
Category :
Sort By:
Relevance Date
Like 0 Bookmark Print or Download

Related-Party Transactions Under Section 188 and LODR: A Five-Light Filter for Boards, Auditors and Advisers

Date 18 Nov 2026
Related-party transactions in family and group businesses call for pricing evidence, proper approvals and disclosure to manage conflicts.
Under section 188 of the Companies Act, 2013, specified transactions outside the ordinary course of business or not at arm's length require board approval and, above prescribed thresholds, shareholder approval, with interested parties abstaining as required. The ordinary-course exemption generally requires both ordinary-course and arm's-length conditions to be satisfied. Listed entities face additional requirements under the LODR Regulations, including prior audit committee approval and shareholder approval for material transactions. Ind AS 24 and IAS 24 require disclosure of related-party relationships and transactions in financial statements. (AI Summary)

Dealing with relatives, friends and group companies is normal in Indian business. Doing it without transparency is how value drains away unnoticed.

During a limited review, the auditor notices that a mid-sized company's packaging costs have risen 30% in two years while volumes are flat. The supplier, it turns out, is a firm owned by the managing director's brother-in-law. There is no contract, no comparison quote and no board resolution - just a long-standing understanding.

Nothing illegal may have happened. But the question that matters is now unavoidable: would the company have accepted these terms from a stranger?

A case that changed how boards look at RPTs

In 2018 Fortis Healthcare, one of India's largest hospital chains, was plunged into a governance crisis. SEBI later passed orders finding that money had been diverted from a Fortis subsidiary through transactions routed to entities connected with the then promoters, and directed repayment.

The promoters lost control, and the company was eventually acquired by a foreign hospital group. Minority shareholders, lenders and staff carried the uncertainty.

The transactions had looked like routine dealings between related companies - and that was precisely what made them dangerous.

Everyday examples

  • Raw material bought from a firm owned by the managing director's brother-in-law.
  • Office space rented from a property owned by the promoter's spouse.
  • An interest-free loan to a group company that has lost money for years.
  • "Consultancy fees" paid to an entity controlled by a director's son.

None of these is automatically wrong. Family and group businesses use related parties for sound reasons - trust, speed, availability and shared interest.

Yet each carries the same risk: the person deciding on the company's behalf may also gain personally from the decision.

How value leaks

In an ordinary transaction, two independent parties bargain and each protects its own interest, so the outcome is broadly fair.

With a related party, that tension can vanish, leading to:

  • Purchases above market from a related supplier.
  • Sales below market to a related customer.
  • Loans on soft terms to entities that may never repay.
  • Valuable assets, contracts or opportunities moved out of the company.
  • Guarantees for related parties' debts with no fee.

Economists describe value moving from a company to its controllers at the expense of minorities, creditors or the exchequer as tunnelling.

The test isn't "do we trust them?" It's "would we sign this with an outsider?"

Lesson from history: the steward's loyalty

Many legal traditions impose a special duty on anyone who manages property for others - a steward, guardian, trustee or agent. In English equity, Islamic law, Hindu law and elsewhere, its core is loyalty: one may not use the position for personal gain at the expense of those served without their informed consent.

Directors are today's stewards. The related-party provisions of company law simply put that ancient duty into detailed form.

What the law and standards require

Identification and disclosure

Ind AS 24 and IAS 24 require disclosure of related-party relationships and transactions in the financial statements.

Approval

Section 188 of the Companies Act requires specified related-party transactions - especially those outside the ordinary course of business or not at arm's length - to be approved by the board and, above prescribed thresholds, by shareholders, with interested parties abstaining. Listed entities face tighter rules under SEBI's LODR Regulations, including prior audit committee approval and shareholder approval for material transactions.

Loans and guarantees

Company law restricts loans to directors and related entities, subject to exceptions and conditions.

Tax

Transfer pricing applies to international and certain domestic related-party transactions, and excessive payments to related persons can be disallowed.

Audit

SA 550 requires auditors to treat related parties as a specific area of risk.

In a nutshell

Essence: related-party transactions are lawful when fair, approved, documented and disclosed - and hazardous the moment any of those four is missing.

The Five-Light RPT Filter

Every related-party transaction should show five green lights before it proceeds:

1. Purpose - Is there a genuine business need?

2. Price - Is the price at or near market, supported by quotes, valuations or data?

3. Permission - Have the board, audit committee or shareholders approved it as the law requires, with interested parties abstaining?

4. Paper - Is there a written contract matching what actually happens?

5. Publicity - Is it fully disclosed in the financial statements and to lenders and investors?

A single red light means stop.

For practitioners: making RPT compliance routine

  • Collect annual declarations from directors and KMP (including MBP-1 disclosures of interest) and use them to refresh the related-party register.
  • Map the register into the ERP. Tag related-party ledgers so transaction reports for the audit committee are generated automatically each quarter.
  • Test "ordinary course" and "arm's length" separately. The section 188 exemption needs both; document the evidence for each.
  • Reconcile the three definitions. Related parties under the Companies Act, Ind AS 24 and LODR differ; maintain a single master list showing which framework captures each party.
  • Cross-check tax filings. Related-party payments reported in the tax audit and transfer pricing reports should agree with the financial statement disclosures.

Good practice for every company

1. Keep a related-party register covering directors, key managers, their relatives, entities in which they are interested and group companies, refreshed through annual declarations.

2. Flag related parties in the accounting system so transactions are tracked automatically.

3. Benchmark prices against the market.

4. Obtain the correct approvals, with interested directors abstaining.

5. Document everything in written contracts and in minutes recording the reasons.

6. Disclose in full.

7. Review periodically - continuing rents, supply contracts and loans must stay fair.

8. Avoid circular or opaque structures, which attract regulatory and tax attention.

Illustration

A listed mid-sized company rents its head office from a promoter-family company for Rs. 45 lakh a year. Comparable offices nearby let for about Rs. 30 lakh.

  • Purpose: green - the company needs an office.
  • Price: red - roughly 50% above market.
  • Permission: amber - board approval obtained, but the audit committee wasn't consulted.
  • Paper and publicity: green.

Outcome: the audit committee commissions an independent valuation, the rent is renegotiated to market terms and the approval is regularised. The relationship continues - on fair terms.

The uncomfortable reality

Many promoters assume that because they hold the majority, related-party dealings are their own affair.

They aren't.

Once a company has minority shareholders, lenders, employees, customers and tax obligations, its money is no longer the promoter's to move at will.

Indicators of success

  • The related-party register is complete and current.
  • Every transaction passes through the proper approval process before it happens.
  • Prices are backed by market comparisons.
  • Financial statement disclosures are complete.
  • Auditors and lenders raise fewer questions each year.

Outlook: the coming decade

Regulators, auditors and investors are scrutinising related-party transactions ever more closely, especially in family-controlled companies. Analytics can now connect companies, directors, addresses and bank accounts automatically. Transactions that once went unnoticed will be visible to anyone who looks.

Immediate actions by role

  • Company secretary or CFO: update the related-party register, including relatives and their businesses.
  • Board: review every related-party transaction of the past year.
  • Promoter: request market comparisons for the three largest related-party contracts.
  • Auditor: confirm that disclosures are complete.

Illustration from a smaller enterprise

Take an illustrative manufacturer that rents its factory from the promoter's spouse at twice the market rate and buys packaging from a cousin's firm without competing quotes. Profits look thin, and minority shareholders and the bank are uneasy.

The board adopts the Five-Light Filter, obtains a rent valuation and invites rival packaging quotes. Rent is reset to market and packaging costs drop by 12%. Profit improves, the bank's confidence returns and a family dispute is averted.

Misconceptions clarified

  • "Related-party transactions are illegal." They are lawful when properly approved, priced at arm's length and disclosed.
  • "Family deals don't need paperwork." They need more, because outsiders will question them.
  • "Ordinary course alone is enough for exemption." Under section 188 the transaction must also be at arm's length.

The objection we hear most - and our response

The objection: "In family groups, related parties are often the most dependable partners - quicker, cheaper and more trustworthy than strangers. Why treat them with suspicion?"

The answer: No suspicion is required - only the evidence one would ask of a stranger. If a related party genuinely offers the best price and service, the Five-Light Filter will show it quickly, and the paperwork will protect everyone, the promoter included, if the deal is ever questioned. Transparency doesn't weaken a family business; it is what allows a family business to raise outside capital.

Practitioners' FAQ

"Are all ordinary-course transactions exempt?"

Under the Companies Act, transactions in the ordinary course of business and at arm's length are generally exempt from board and shareholder approval - both conditions are needed, and listed companies have extra rules.

"Who counts as a related party?"

The definitions are detailed and differ between company law, accounting standards and listing rules. Maintain a register and review it with an adviser.

"What if a past transaction was never approved?"

Seek advice quickly; company law allows ratification of certain transactions within time limits.

Position as at October 2026: Key Indian rules include section 188 of the Companies Act, 2013 and related rules, Regulation 23 of SEBI's Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements Regulations (as amended, including materiality thresholds), Ind AS 24 and transfer pricing provisions under the Income-tax Act, 2025. SEBI has revised RPT rules several times in recent years - check current thresholds.

Pitfalls

  • Interest-free or undocumented loans to related entities.
  • Paying related parties for services that aren't clearly delivered.
  • Selling assets to insiders without an independent valuation.
  • Splitting transactions to stay below approval thresholds.
  • Incomplete disclosures.

Terms explained

  • Related party - a person or entity closely connected to the company, such as directors, relatives or group companies.
  • Arm's length price - the price independent parties would agree in comparable circumstances.
  • Disclosure - reporting related-party transactions in the financial statements.
  • Approval process - the board or shareholder sanction required for specified transactions.
  • Register of related parties - the maintained list of related parties and their interests.

Action checklist

Related-party register refreshed from annual declarations

Market evidence held for every major contract

Approval minuted before each transaction

Half-hour action exercise

List every transaction last year with anyone connected to the owners, directors or key managers, and put each through the Five-Light Filter.

Wherever a light shows amber or red, note the remedy - valuation, approval, contract or disclosure. Fix it before an auditor, lender, investor or regulator asks.

Summary for busy professionals

  • Related-party transactions are common but risky because decision-makers may benefit personally; Fortis shows how far value can leak.
  • Leakage happens through off-market prices, soft loans, asset transfers and unpaid guarantees.
  • Law and standards demand identification, approval, arm's length terms and disclosure, with stricter rules for listed entities.
  • Run every deal through purpose, price, permission, paper and publicity.
  • Transparency protects promoters as much as minority investors.

The transactions themselves aren't the problem. Secrecy, unfair terms and missing approvals are.

References

0 answers
Sort by
+ Add A New Reply
Hide

No Replies are present.

Recent Articles