Loading...

⚠ ✕
❮ Top
☎ Help
☰
×

By creating an account you can:

Logo TaxTMI
Call Us / Help / Feedback✕

Contact Us At :

✉ E-mail: [email protected]

✆ To Call / Whatsapp, Check Contact Us

FAQs :

To know Frequently Asked Questions, Check FAQs

Most Asked Video Tutorials :

For more tutorials, Check Video Tutorials

Submit Feedback/Suggestion :

Email :
Please provide your email address so we can follow up on your feedback.
Category :
Description :
Min 15 characters 0/2000
╳
Add to...
You have not created any category. Kindly create one to bookmark this item!
✕
Create New Category
Hide
Title :
Description :
+ Post an Article
Post a New Article ✕
Title :
0/200 char
Description :
Max 0 char
Category :
Co Author :

In case of Co-Author, You may provide Username as per TMI records

Delete Reply

Are you sure you want to delete your reply beginning with ' ' ?

Delete Issue

Are you sure you want to delete your Issue titled: ' ' ?

Articles

Advanced Search ❮
Reset Filters
Search By:
Search by Text :
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms
Select Date:
From To
Category :
Sort By:
Relevance Date
Like 0 Bookmark Print or Download

GST Arrest Is Illegal When the Commissioner Fails to Record Reasons to Believe Under Section 69

Date 16 Nov 2026
Written by
GST arrest requires independently recorded reasons to believe supported by credible evidence, not merely allegations of fraudulent input tax credit.
GST arrest under Section 69 of the CGST Act requires the Commissioner independently to record reasons to believe that a person has committed a specified offence under Section 132 and that the relevant punishment requirements are met. The reasons must identify credible material linking the alleged offence, the applicable monetary threshold and the person concerned. A general assertion of satisfaction or a subordinate officer's detailed assessment cannot substitute for the Commissioner's independent evaluation. Establishing the ingredients of an offence does not automatically justify arrest. The arrest guidelines require separate consideration of whether custody is necessary for investigation or to prevent interference with evidence or witnesses. (AI Summary)

The power to arrest under the Goods and Services Tax law has long raised important questions about protecting personal liberty and the limits of departmental authority. Although Section 69 of the CGST Act, 2017 empowers the Commissioner to authorise arrest for specified offences under Section 132, the Commissioner cannot exercise this power merely because serious allegations of tax evasion or fraudulent Input Tax Credit (ITC) have emerged during an investigation. The Commissioner must independently examine credible material, record reasons to believe, and ensure compliance with the prescribed safeguards before authorising arrest.

In Sahil Chandna Versus State of Haryana and another. - 2026 (11) TMI 212 - PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT, the Punjab and Haryana High Court examined whether an arrest could be sustained when an Inspector, rather than the Commissioner, recorded the detailed reasons to believe. The Court also considered the absence of an electronically generated Document Identification Number (DIN) in the relevant arrest documents. The judgment takes on additional significance in light of the recent GST Council recommendations proposing withdrawal of arrest powers under GST law.

Withdrawal of GST Arrest Powers Recommended by the 57th GST Council

At its 57th meeting on 08.10.2026, the GST Council recommended completely withdrawing arrest powers under GST by omitting Section 69 of the CGST Act, 2017. It also recommended rationalising the prosecution provisions under Section 132, including raising the monetary threshold for prosecution from Rs. 1 crore to Rs. 5 crore, narrowing certain offences, and revising the punishment framework. These recommendations mark an important policy shift toward a more trust-based tax administration while retaining provisions to investigate and prosecute serious tax offences.

Significantly, CBIC Instruction No. 02/2026-GST, dated 30.10.2026, directed all Central GST field formations not to carry out any further arrests under GST pending the proposed legislative amendments. The Council recommended that the amended provisions come into force from 01.04.2027. However, the administrative direction has been issued earlier as an interim measure. The distinction is important because the Council's recommendation and the CBIC instruction do not, by themselves, omit Section 69 from the statute. The instruction presently restricts Central GST field formations, while statutory withdrawal requires legislative amendment. The instruction also does not, by itself, retrospectively invalidate arrests made before its issuance.

Against this background, the High Court's judgment dated 28.10.2026, delivered two days before the CBIC instruction, remains significant in determining the legality of arrests made under the existing statutory framework. The decision explains why the Commissioner's independent satisfaction, recording of reasons to believe, and compliance with procedural safeguards are indispensable when the Department exercises powers affecting personal liberty.

Alleged Fake ITC Transactions Through Twenty-Eight Firms Led to the Arrest

The controversy arose from an investigation into alleged fraudulent availment and passing on of ITC through twenty-eight shell or dummy firms operating across India. The petitioner, Sahil Chandna, a Chartered Accountant, was alleged to have created and controlled these entities in connection with transactions involving M/s Targetone Innovations Pvt. Ltd. and its associated entity, M/s Parcit Autocracy Pvt. Ltd. According to the Department, he obtained KYC documents from relatives and acquaintances, arranged GST registrations and bank accounts, generated invoices and e-way bills, filed GST returns and controlled financial transactions through the nominal proprietors.

The Department alleged that these entities received ITC of approximately Rs. 55.28 crore and passed on ITC of approximately Rs. 54.51 crore without corresponding genuine movement of goods. The Department described the aggregate fraudulent ITC involvement as exceeding Rs. 110 crore, with transaction values exceeding Rs. 220 crore. It was further alleged that the petitioner received commission ranging from 3% to 4% of the transaction value and paid approximately 1% to the nominal proprietors. These allegations formed the basis of proceedings under Section 132(1)(b), (c) and (f) of the CGST Act.

The petitioner was arrested on 25.07.2026 by an Inspector attached to the office of the Principal Commissioner, CGST, Gurugram, and subsequently remanded to judicial custody. Challenging the legality of his arrest, detention, and remand under Article 226 of the Constitution, he contended that the reasons to believe and grounds of arrest were recorded by the Inspector rather than the Commissioner. He also questioned the absence of DIN from the relevant documents. The Department maintained that the Commissioner had digitally signed the arrest authorisation, the petitioner had acknowledged receipt of the documents and the allegations involved serious economic offences. Thus, the principal controversy concerned the legality of the arrest procedure rather than the ultimate merits of the alleged ITC fraud.

Section 69 Requires Independent Satisfaction of the Commissioner Before Arrest

Section 69(1) authorises the Commissioner to order arrest where he has reasons to believe that a person has committed an offence specified in clauses (a) to (d) of Section 132(1), punishable under the relevant provisions of Section 132. The statutory language specifically entrusts the Commissioner with forming reasons to believe. Although an authorised officer may carry out the arrest, the Commissioner remains responsible for examining the material and forming the necessary statutory satisfaction.

Section 132 prescribes punishment for specified GST offences, including issuing invoices without an underlying supply and fraudulently availing ITC. Under Section 132(5), offences covered by clauses (a) to (d) of Section 132(1), when punishable under clause (i), are cognizable and non-bailable. Section 132(1)(i) applies where the specified amount exceeds Rs. 5 crore. However, allegations involving amounts above this threshold do not automatically justify arrest. The Commissioner must examine the material establishing the relevant offence, the monetary threshold, the involvement of the person concerned and the circumstances justifying arrest.

The High Court emphasised that reasons to believe must rest upon tangible and credible material and demonstrate genuine application of mind by the Commissioner. A general statement that an offence has been committed cannot substitute for a reasoned assessment identifying the supporting evidence. The requirement protects individuals against arbitrary deprivation of liberty and ensures that the statutory authority independently examines an investigating officer's conclusions. The Court observed that the legislature deliberately entrusted this responsibility to a senior officer because arrest affects not only personal liberty but also an individual's reputation and dignity.

Supreme Court Decisions Require Credible Material and Communication of Reasons

The High Court relied substantially upon the Supreme Court's decision in RADHIKA AGARWAL Versus UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS - 2025 (2) TMI 1162 - Supreme Court (LB), particularly paragraphs 58 and 59. The Supreme Court held that the Commissioner must satisfactorily demonstrate, through recorded reasons to believe, that the statutory conditions for arrest are fulfilled. The reasons must refer to relevant material supporting the alleged offence and the monetary threshold attracting the applicable punishment. Arrest cannot be founded merely upon suspicion, unsupported assertions or a desire to investigate whether the necessary statutory conditions might eventually be established.

The decision draws an important distinction between investigation and arrest. Information suggesting fraudulent transactions may justify investigation, but arrest requires a separate and objective assessment of the available evidence. The Commissioner must establish a reasoned connection between the material collected, the alleged offence and the individual whose liberty is proposed to be restricted. The existence of numerous firms, substantial transaction values or allegations of organised fraud cannot dispense with this requirement. The statutory power of arrest must be exercised on established reasons rather than investigative suspicion alone.

The High Court also referred to Union Of India Versus Sunil Biyani. - 2026 (8) TMI 909 - Supreme Court, observing that the Supreme Court required the Commissioner's order under Section 69 to be communicated to the person sought to be arrested. This requirement ensures that the individual is informed of the actual statutory basis for the arrest. Reading these decisions together, the High Court treated the Commissioner's independent satisfaction, proper recording of reasons and their communication as essential safeguards. Supplying a detailed explanation prepared by a subordinate officer cannot, by itself, establish that the Commissioner personally discharged the responsibility imposed by Section 69.

Reasons Recorded by an Inspector Cannot Replace the Commissioner's Statutory Duty

The decisive finding concerned the arrest authorisation dated 25.07.2026, digitally signed by Commissioner Sanjiv Gautam. The authorisation contained a general statement that the Commissioner had reasons to believe that the petitioner had committed an offence under Section 132. However, Inspector Pushpendra Singh Shekhawat, who was also the investigating officer, prepared and signed a separate document containing detailed reasons to believe. The Department argued that the Commissioner's satisfaction was reflected in the official record and that the supporting documents sufficiently explained the petitioner's alleged involvement.

The High Court rejected this contention. It observed that a solitary statement in the arrest authorisation that the Commissioner had reasons to believe could not satisfy Section 69(1). The reasons must refer to the underlying evidence and demonstrate independent application of mind. Interestingly, the Court acknowledged that the Inspector's document contained considerable detail on the allegations, statutory provisions, supporting evidence, and the cognizable and non-bailable character of the alleged offences. Nevertheless, the fundamental defect remained: the Inspector recorded the reasons, not the Commissioner.

The judgment does not prohibit investigating officers from collecting evidence, preparing reports or submitting recommendations. Such assistance is an ordinary part of departmental investigation. However, the Commissioner must independently evaluate that material and record the statutory reasons before authorising arrest. A digitally signed authorisation containing a general assertion of satisfaction cannot replace this exercise. The High Court accordingly held that an order under Section 69 recording the Commissioner's reasons to believe is a sine qua non for arrest. Since this mandatory requirement had not been fulfilled, the petitioner's arrest was illegal.

CBIC Arrest Guidelines Require Justification Beyond the Seriousness of Allegations

The High Court also examined the CBIC guidelines dated 17.08.2022, which prescribe safeguards governing arrest under the CGST Act. Paragraph 3.1 requires reasons to believe to be clear and supported by credible material. Paragraph 3.2 further explains that even where the statutory ingredients of an offence are established, arrest does not automatically follow. The competent authority must separately consider whether custody is necessary for proper investigation or to prevent interference with evidence and witnesses.

The guidelines identify relevant considerations such as the possibility of tampering with evidence, influencing witnesses, avoiding investigation and the alleged role of the person as a mastermind or key operator in fraudulent transactions involving dummy registrations. They also require consideration of the necessary intention or guilty mind. Conversely, cooperation with investigation, compliance with summons, furnishing of documents and absence of evasive conduct are relevant circumstances. Paragraph 3.5 discourages arrest in cases involving technical disputes or differences in interpretation of tax law.

These guidelines show that the existence of a serious GST offence and the need for arrest are distinct considerations. Even where allegations involve substantial fraudulent ITC, the Department must justify why custodial action is required. The High Court emphasised that arrest cannot become a routine consequence of investigation merely because the statute provides such power. The requirement of independent satisfaction ensures that personal liberty is restricted only after the competent authority has considered the relevant circumstances and recorded adequate justification.

Absence of DIN in Arrest Documents Constituted an Additional Legal Defect

The High Court separately examined the absence of an electronically generated Document Identification Number (DIN) from the reasons to believe and grounds of arrest furnished to the petitioner. CBIC Circular No. 122/41/2019-GST dated 05.11.2019, issued under Section 168(1), introduced mandatory DIN requirements for specified departmental communications, including search authorisations, summons, arrest memoranda and inspection notices, with effect from 08.11.2019. This system ensures transparency, authenticity, and traceability of departmental communications.

The Circular permits communications without electronically generated DIN only in specified exceptional circumstances, including technical difficulties or urgent investigative requirements when the authorised officer is outside the office. Even then, the reasons must be recorded in writing, and the communication must expressly state that it was issued without DIN. Such communications must be regularised within fifteen working days through post facto approval, electronic generation of DIN and placement of the prescribed record in the departmental file. Communications issued without DIN outside the permitted exceptions are treated as invalid and deemed never to have been issued.

In the present case, the Department could neither explain the absence of DIN from the reasons to believe and grounds of arrest nor establish any exceptional circumstances justifying such omission. There was also no contention that the documents had been regularised within the prescribed period. The Court rejected the argument that both documents formed part of the arrest memorandum. The High Court consequently held that the documents failed judicial scrutiny on this additional ground. The decision reinforces that compliance with Section 69 and compliance with mandatory departmental documentation requirements are separate obligations, and failure to satisfy either may affect the legality of the proceedings.

Serious Economic Offence Allegations Cannot Validate an Arrest Contrary to Law

The Department relied upon STATE OF GUJARAT Versus SHRI MOHANLAL JITAMALJI PORWAL AND ANOTHER - 1987 (3) TMI 111 - Supreme Court, Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy Versus Central Bureau of Investigation - 2013 (5) TMI 896 - Supreme Court, and The State of Bihar & Anr. Versus Amit Kumar @ Bacha rai - 2017 (4) TMI 1410 - Supreme Courtto emphasise the seriousness of economic offences. However, the High Court distinguished these authorities. It observed that Mohanlal Jitamalji Porwal did not assist the Department in view of the specific statutory requirements under Section 69, while Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy and Amit Kumar concerned bail rather than the legality of the initial arrest.

The distinction matters because bail proceedings ordinarily involve considerations such as the gravity of the allegations, available evidence, the risk of absconding, and the possibility of influencing witnesses. A challenge to the legality of arrest raises a different question concerning compliance with mandatory statutory safeguards. A person facing serious allegations may nevertheless be entitled to release where the arrest itself is unlawful. Equally, declaring an arrest illegal does not establish innocence or prevent lawful investigation and prosecution. The seriousness of alleged tax fraud cannot cure a defect arising from failure of the competent statutory authority to record reasons to believe.

Illegal Arrest and Consequential Custody Set Aside by the High Court

The Punjab and Haryana High Court allowed the writ petition, holding that the petitioner's arrest had not been preceded by reasons to believe recorded by the Commissioner as required under Section 69(1). The absence of DIN from the relevant documents constituted an additional violation. Accordingly, the Court declared the arrest, detention, subsequent remand, and continued custody illegal and arbitrary, and directed the petitioner to be released forthwith.

The Court clarified that the prosecution remained at liberty to seek remand or custody, if required, after supplying the reasons to believe and grounds of arrest in writing in accordance with law. The decision therefore concerns the legality of arrest rather than the merits of the alleged fraudulent ITC transactions. It reinforces the fundamental principle that the seriousness of allegations cannot override mandatory statutory safeguards governing personal liberty.

***

0 answers
Sort by
+ Add A New Reply
Hide

No Replies are present.

Recent Articles