Advanced Search Options : ❯
Input tax credit under the Odisha Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 requires actual receipt of goods and an underlying supply. Invoices, e-way bills, weighment slips and bearer-cheque payments do not necessarily establish receipt. Apparent supplier registration, return filing and GSTR-2B entries cannot validate paper transactions where no supply occurred. Admission of a stock register or affidavit as additional evidence of receipt requires a formal application explaining reasonable cause for earlier non-production. Fraudulent availment permits recovery of credit with interest and penalty under section 74. Taking or utilising credit without receipt of goods also attracts a penalty under section 122(1)(vi).
For refund of accumulated input tax credit on exports, invoices issued during the relevant period for goods cleared under bond or a letter of undertaking are included in that period's zero-rated turnover, even if physical export occurs later. Section 31 and the time-of-supply provisions of section 12 of the CGST Act distinguish supply of goods for export from completion of actual export. Refund under rule 89(4) remains conditional on proof that the goods have actually been exported.
For goods supplied for export under a bond or letter of undertaking, supply takes place on removal and preparation of the tax invoice, although export is completed only when the goods leave India. Invoices issued during the relevant period form part of that period's zero-rated turnover under Rule 89(4), even if the goods are exported later. Refund of accumulated input tax credit on such supplies remains conditional on proof of actual export.
Rule 56(10) creates a rebuttable presumption of maintenance for a registered person's records, even when found away from registered premises. Records linked to a trader by their contents, custody and an admission can establish suppressed sales on a balance of probabilities. Section 74 applies to deliberate suppression with intent to evade tax, attracting a penalty equal to tax; a shortfall or bona fide mistake alone is insufficient. Enhancement-notice requirements do not apply where the fresh determination reduces the original demand covered by the notice. An appellant-initiated remand cannot worsen the appellant's position: the earlier appellate determination caps tax, penalty and interest accrued up to that determination, while statutory .....
Input tax credit requires the claimant to establish actual receipt of goods and payment to the Government of the tax charged on the supply. Section 155 places the burden of proving entitlement on the claimant. Where a supplier is found non-existent, invoices, e-way bills, banking entries, lorry receipts and photographs without verifiable dates or coordinates may not establish physical supply without independent, verifiable evidence. Payment to the supplier does not satisfy the separate requirement that tax be paid to the Government, whether in cash or through admissible input tax credit. Failure to establish either condition can result in denial of credit.
Section 107(12) of the CGST Act, 2017 and corresponding State law require GST appellate orders to state the points for determination, the decisions and the reasons for them. Reasoned orders are a statutory requirement and an essential element of natural justice. An appellate order setting aside tax and penalty for transporting goods without an e-way bill was set aside for lack of cogent reasons. The matter was remanded for a fresh reasoned decision after hearing both parties, without determining the underlying liability.
Limitation for refund of excess GST paid through monthly GSTR-3B returns runs separately from each payment, not from annual reconciliation or a consolidated claim. COVID-19 limitation exclusions preserve the February 2018 claim, but not claims for July 2017 to January 2018, whose limitation periods had already expired. The March 2018 claim is timely, but no refund is payable because the records show a shortfall rather than excess payment. Reconciliation differences did not establish payment without authority of law, leaving the claim subject to Section 54(1). The February 2018 refund is to be segregated, quantified and granted in accordance with law.
Crude cashew nut shell liquid obtained by thermal and mechanical extraction without chemical modification or polymerisation is classified as a vegetable extract under tariff item 1302 19 20. Classification depends on the product's nature, composition, degree of processing and essential character at clearance. Its non-edible, derivative character and absence of polymerisation exclude the other identified competing classifications. A GST rate entry specified at four-digit heading level covers its subheadings and tariff items unless specifically excluded. The unrestricted Heading 1302 entry in Schedule I to Notification No. 9/2025-Central Tax (Rate) therefore applies, with GST at 5%, comprising 2.5% CGST and 2.5% SGST, effective from 22 September 2025.
GST exemption under Serial No. 77A of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate), as amended, applies to a registered non-profit entity's healthcare scheme services subject to the prescribed conditions. Promotion of social welfare is construed broadly to cover cashless treatment for economically weaker and vulnerable groups, while incidental membership fees do not make the activity commercial. Registration under sections 12AA/12AB of the Income Tax Act established the entity's non-profit status. Services were confined to enrolled members and eligible family members, and the annual family contribution, apportioned per covered member, did not exceed Rs. 1,000 per member.
Interest charged independently of brokerage for financing securities purchases under a Margin Trading Facility is exempt from GST as consideration for extending loans or advances. The broker funds purchases beyond the client's available margin, and the funded amount is repayable with interest for the period outstanding. Although activities involving the use of money for separate consideration constitute services under the CGST Act, the exemption for lending services applies to the extent that consideration is represented by interest or discount.
Development services supplied to landowners under a joint development agreement are taxable outward supplies subject to GST under the forward charge mechanism. Eligible input tax credit on goods or services used or intended for business may be utilised to pay GST on those services, subject to statutory conditions and restrictions. Eligible credit need not be reversed, while ineligible credit must be reversed under the Act and Rules. Advance ruling jurisdiction is limited to the matters specified in section 97(2); procedural invoicing methodology and compliance requirements fall outside its scope when they do not concern statutory valuation or another listed matter.
Detachable rooftop solar power systems used for a trading business's electricity needs qualify as plant and machinery under the CGST and KGST Acts, including their mounting structures and associated components. Fixing equipment to a rooftop with bolts, screws or structural supports does not make it part of the building or a civil structure. Input tax credit on supplies for erection, installation and commissioning is admissible where the business nexus and statutory conditions are met; rooftop installation alone does not attract the restriction under Section 17(5)(d). Occasional surplus exports under net metering do not by themselves sever the business nexus. Credit remains subject to restrictions, including where depreciation is claimed on the tax component. Surplus electricity taxability and related credit apportionment or reversal require separate examination.
Kulfi made from milk and sugar, with or without dry fruits, falls under Tariff Heading 2105 00 00 as ice cream and other edible ice, rather than Heading 0404 for products consisting of natural milk constituents. Classification depends on the finished product's identity, character and use, not merely its predominant ingredient. Concentration, added ingredients and freezing produce a ready-to-eat dessert commonly purchased and consumed like ice cream. Under Rule 3(a) of the General Rules for Interpretation, a specific description prevails over a general description for products not elsewhere specified or included.
Transfers of restaurant businesses for consideration in the course or furtherance of business constitute supplies under section 7(1)(a) of the CGST Act, 2017. Transfer of a going concern, as a whole or an independent part, is an exempt supply of services where a functioning economic activity can continue independently under the transferee. Continuity may be established through the transfer of operations, staff, working assets and recurring operational responsibilities. Retention of past liabilities by the transferor does not by itself disqualify the exemption. Lump-sum consideration without item-wise allocation may support, but does not independently establish, the transfer of an operational undertaking.
Banking companies governed by the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, were outside the scope of minimum alternate tax under section 115JB before the Finance Act, 2012. Consequently, the alternative question of deducting provisions for bad debts and investments written off when computing book profits is academic for that period. Deductions for bad and doubtful debts under sections 36(1)(vii) and 36(1)(viia) also raise the question of whether debiting only the bad-debt reserve, without an actual write-off through the profit and loss account, is sufficient.
Voluntary statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 may support penalties for attempted illegal export of red sanders where alleged retractions are not substantiated as having been communicated to the appropriate authority and seizure and recovery evidence corroborates the statements. A natural justice objection based on lack of cross-examination is untenable where the relied-upon documents and statements are supplied, personal hearings are afforded, and examination of the statement makers is not requested during the enquiry or hearing.
GST exemption applies to electrical energy, including solar-generated electricity supplied to a power distribution corporation. Specified charges levied by registered government-owned electricity corporations do not attract reverse charge under section 9(3) or 9(4) in the circumstances described. Government ownership or control does not make a corporation or company Government for the reverse-charge entry concerning government services. The provision addressing specified supplies from unregistered suppliers does not apply to registered providers. The nature and taxability of the underlying services remain undetermined.
Advance rulings concern an applicant's own supplies, tax liabilities and obligations. Although section 97(2)(d) permits questions about input tax credit, it covers credit on the applicant's inward supplies, not a customer's credit on the applicant's outward supplies. A lessor cannot seek an advance ruling on its tenant's entitlement to credit against debit notes for commercial rent. Under section 103, a ruling binds the applicant and its concerned or jurisdictional officer, but not the tenant.
Wooden home temples, idols, statuettes and decorative flower vases fall under heading 4420 as wooden ornaments; picture and mirror frames fall under the specific heading 4414 regardless of finish. Wooden baby cradles are bedroom furniture under subheading 940350 because they provide sleeping space, while wooden-cased wall clocks are classified as clocks under heading 9105 despite their decorative casings. Handicraft status alone does not secure concessional GST: goods must also fall within specified notification entries. Qualifying home temples, idols, statuettes, frames and flower vases attract 5% GST, while wooden cradles and wall clocks attract 18% GST.
Time-share membership fees under the mercantile system are recognised over the membership tenure rather than entirely in the year of receipt. For the software-purchase expenditure, section 194J did not require tax deduction and section 40(a)(ia) did not apply. The expression 'payable' in section 40(a)(ia) includes amounts already paid, although that distinction was academic for the software expenditure.