SSI exemption eligibility depends on strict notification limits; prior relief under one paragraph does not create continuing entitlement.

An exemption under Notification No. 175/86-C.E. required registration as a small scale industry with the prescribed authority as the general condition for eligibility. Paragraph 4(a) applied only where clearances in the relevant year did not exceed the prescribed limit, and paragraph 4(b) covered a separate contingency; neither provision created a continuing entitlement once turnover crossed the limit. Prior benefit under paragraph 4(a) did not extend exemption into later years after the threshold was exceeded, and paragraph 4(b) could not be invoked merely because the assessee had earlier enjoyed relief under paragraph 4(a). The exemption was therefore unavailable without an SSI certificate.

---

---

Issues: Whether, in the absence of an SSI certificate, the assessees could claim exemption under Notification No. 175/86-C.E. by relying on paragraph 4(a) or paragraph 4(b) after their clearances exceeded the prescribed limit.

Analysis: The exemption notification made registration as a small scale industry with the prescribed authority the general rule for eligibility. Paragraph 4(a) operated only where the clearances in the relevant year did not exceed Rs. 7.5 lakhs, and paragraph 4(b) covered a distinct contingency. The earlier year's benefit under paragraph 4(a) did not create a continuing right to exemption for later years once the turnover limit was crossed. Paragraph 4(b) could not be invoked merely because the assessee had enjoyed the benefit in an earlier year under paragraph 4(a).

Conclusion: The assessees were not entitled to the exemption without an SSI certificate once their clearances exceeded the limit, and the claim under paragraph 4(b) also failed.

Final Conclusion: The exemption was held unavailable on the facts of the case, and the appeals were rejected.

Ratio Decidendi: An exemption notification requiring an SSI certificate cannot be extended beyond its expressed limits, and a temporary benefit under one exception does not confer a continuing entitlement under another distinct exception once the statutory conditions are no longer satisfied.

---