Criminal prosecution for alleged VAT non-payment cannot survive final annulment of the underlying fiscal liability.

Criminal proceedings based solely on a director's alleged non-payment of VAT cannot continue after statutory appellate proceedings have finally annulled the underlying tax liability. Where the fiscal determination allows the input-tax claim and deletes the related tax, interest and penalty, and no independent allegation remains in the charge-sheet, the criminal prosecution has no surviving factual basis. The notes state that proceedings against the director were consequently quashed.

---

---

Issues: Whether criminal proceedings against a company director could continue when the sole allegation of non-payment of VAT had been conclusively resolved in the director's favour under the Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003.

Analysis: The charge-sheet contained no allegation against the petitioner apart from non-payment of VAT as a director of the company. The reassessment creating the VAT demand, interest and penalty was set aside in fiscal appellate proceedings, which allowed the input-tax claim and directed deletion of the tax, interest and penalty. That determination had attained finality.

Conclusion: The criminal proceedings lacked any surviving basis against the petitioner and were quashed.

Ratio Decidendi: Criminal proceedings cannot continue where their sole factual foundation is a fiscal liability that has been finally annulled in statutory appellate proceedings.

---