Conditional customs exemption denied where imported brass scrap was not shown to have been sold as required by the notification.

Exemption from special additional duty on imported brass scrap was available only if the goods were sold, and that condition was not satisfied on the admitted facts because the goods were taken to the factory and entered in the raw material register without proof of sale. The duty demand was therefore sustained. The separate question of interest required limited reconsideration on the existing record to determine whether the imported brass scrap was subsequently sold in the market, and that issue was remanded for fresh examination.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the appellants were entitled to retain the benefit of exemption from special additional duty on imported brass scrap when the imported goods were taken to the factory, entered in the raw material register, and not shown to have been sold as required by the notification; (ii) Whether the question of liability to interest required fresh examination on the existing record.

Issue (i): Whether the appellants were entitled to retain the benefit of exemption from special additional duty on imported brass scrap when the imported goods were taken to the factory, entered in the raw material register, and not shown to have been sold as required by the notification.

Analysis: The exemption was available only on the condition that the imported goods were sold. The goods were admittedly brought into the factory premises and recorded in the raw material register. On these undisputed facts, the condition attached to the exemption was not satisfied. The plea that the goods were later sold did not displace the breach of the notification condition for the purpose of exemption already availed.

Conclusion: The demand of special additional duty was upheld against the appellants.

Issue (ii): Whether the question of liability to interest required fresh examination on the existing record.

Analysis: The duty having already been paid, the only remaining controversy was the liability to interest. For that limited purpose, the matter required examination of the material already on record to determine whether the imported brass scrap was subsequently sold in the market.

Conclusion: The issue of interest was remanded to the Commissioner (Appeals) for reconsideration on the existing record.

Final Conclusion: The duty demand was sustained, but the question of interest was sent back for fresh consideration, resulting in a partial success for the appellants.

Ratio Decidendi: An exemption granted subject to a condition must be denied when the condition is not satisfied on the admitted facts, while a distinct ancillary question such as interest may be remanded for limited reconsideration on the existing record.

---