Dependent classification of C4 Raffinate stream led to remand for fresh adjudication after incoming stream review.

Classification of the returned C4 Raffinate stream under Heading 2711.12 or 2711.19 depended on the classification status of the incoming stream, which was under reconsideration. The Tribunal therefore declined to finally determine the classification or limitation issues on the existing record and directed that the matter be remitted for fresh adjudication. After the incoming stream is finally classified, the original authority must re-hear the dispute and make any necessary duty or credit adjustment accordingly.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appeal should be remanded to the original authority for a fresh decision after awaiting the classification of the incoming C4 Raffinate stream.

Analysis: The dispute arose from the classification of C4 Raffinate return stream under Heading 2711.12 or 2711.19 and the corresponding duty demand. The Tribunal noted that in an earlier decision involving the same manufacturing process, the returned stream had been treated as the same C4 Raffinate received from the supplier. Since the classification of the incoming stream was stated to be under reconsideration, the Tribunal considered it appropriate not to finally decide the classification or limitation questions at that stage. The proper course was to await the final classification of the incoming stream and then make any necessary duty or credit adjustment after fresh hearing.

Conclusion: The matter was remanded to the original authority for fresh adjudication after the classification of the incoming stream was determined.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the classification of the returned stream depends on the classification status of the incoming stream, and the latter is under reconsideration, the dispute should be remitted for fresh decision rather than finally reclassified on the existing record.

---