Remand for fresh consideration of job-worker exemption and amended penalty claim, with hearing before the original authority.

The Tribunal directed remand where additional claims on exemption for clearances to job workers and on the amended penalty provision had not been examined by the lower authorities. Because duty and penalty were already being reworked, it held that the original authority should also consider these submissions and afford the appellants a reasonable opportunity of hearing. The matter was therefore sent back for fresh consideration of the exemption and reduced-penalty issues together with the issues already directed to be reconsidered.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellants' additional claims regarding exemption for clearances made to job workers and the applicability of the amended penalty provision required fresh consideration by the original authority, warranting remand.

Analysis: The appeal did not call for a final adjudication on the merits of the exemption claim under the relevant notification or on the reduced penalty contention. Those grounds had not been examined by the lower authorities, while the matter was already being sent back for reworking of duty and penalty. In that situation, the Tribunal held it proper that the original authority should consider these additional submissions as well, after giving the appellants a reasonable opportunity of hearing.

Conclusion: The matter was remanded to the original authority to decide the additional exemption and penalty submissions along with the issues already directed to be reconsidered.

---