Duty to record reasons: administrative and appellate decisions must state intelligible reasons or face judicial review of validity.
The core legal point is that an appellate authority cannot reject a statutory appeal without recording reasons; absence of a reasoned order suggests non-application of mind and breaches principles of natural justice. Administrative and quasi judicial decisions must provide intelligible justification to permit review and to replace subjective conclusions with objective reasoning; established precedent treats omission of reasons as a ground for judicial scrutiny. (AI Summary)
The core legal point is that an appellate authority cannot reject a statutory appeal without recording reasons; absence of a reasoned order suggests non-application of mind and breaches principles of natural justice. Administrative and quasi judicial decisions must provide intelligible justification to permit review and to replace subjective conclusions with objective reasoning; established precedent treats omission of reasons as a ground for judicial scrutiny. (AI Summary)
TaxTMI