Advanced Search Options : ❯
Transfer-pricing comparables and the related party transaction filter remain undisturbed, with neither issue raising a substantial question of law.
The exclusion of four companies from transfer-pricing comparables for determining the arm's length price raised no substantial question of law, as a High Court decision covered their exclusion. The use of a related party transaction filter set at 15% of total revenue likewise raised no substantial question of law, being covered by a coordinate bench decision. The Tribunal's determination of comparables and the filter remained undisturbed in favour of the assessee.
Proven deposit repayments and loan balances brought forward without fresh credits cannot be treated as unexplained cash credits
Repayment of an assessee's own short-term deposit cannot be treated as an unexplained cash credit when evidence establishes the creditor's identity and creditworthiness and the genuineness of the transaction. Financial statements, tax returns and banking records can support those requirements where a non-banking financial company repays a deposit through banking channels. Section 68 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 also does not apply to loan balances brought forward from earlier years when no fresh loans are received from those creditors in the relevant assessment year.
Cash loan reporting directions do not specifically require a litigant's PAN card for transactions predating later cash-receipt restrictions
Cash loans made before the introduction of Section 269ST in 2017 may be reported to the jurisdictional tax authority where the earlier cash-loan restrictions under Section 269SS apply. Those restrictions covered acceptance of cash loans or deposits above the prescribed threshold. Reporting directions aimed at curbing unaccounted money do not specifically require disclosure of a plaintiff's PAN card. The card contains personal identifying information, and informational privacy forms part of the fundamental right to privacy. Relevant suit documents may be reported without requiring disclosure of the PAN card.
Transfer pricing operating margins exclude costs from periods without revenue when income arises only during part of the year
Rule 10B prescribes the transactional net margin method, under which the net profit margin is computed by reference to a relevant base and comparable margins are adjusted for material differences. Operating costs must relate to the operating revenue generated; costs incurred during a period without operating revenue are excluded from the operating margin. Where revenue is generated only in the first two months of the financial year, the margin is determined using the operating revenue and costs of those two months.
Unconsidered electronic adjournment requests can lead to ex parte assessments being set aside for a fresh hearing.
The alleged failure to consider an electronically filed adjournment request before an ex parte assessment presented a prima facie basis for interference. The assessment was set aside, with an opportunity to respond to the show-cause notice and be heard before a fresh reasoned decision. The substantive assessment was not examined on merits.
Tax deduction certificates raise permanent establishment and officer-duty questions where a person residing in India holds power of attorney.
The legality of a certificate under section 197 directing tax deduction at 10% concerns tax deduction at source under section 195, permanent establishment and the duties of the competent officer. The issue arises where a power of attorney has been granted to a person residing in India. Petitions on the same issue remain pending for final hearing.
Input tax credit mismatches and post-audit reversals do not establish fraud without proof of intent to evade tax
Input tax credit mismatches and reversals after departmental detection do not, without proof of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax, justify a penalty under Section 74. The revenue bears the burden of proving those elements. A Section 74 penalty is linked to tax specified in the notice and determined in the order; it is not a standalone penalty where neither identifies tax. Where fraud is not established, Section 75 applies the non-fraud procedure under Section 73, which permits payment based on the taxpayer's or officer's ascertainment and provides penalty relief when tax and interest are paid within 30 days of notice.
Monetary threshold for departmental GST appeals limits maintainability where no exception is pleaded, leaving legal questions open.
Departmental appeals before the GST Appellate Tribunal are subject to a monetary threshold of Rs. 20 lakh under section 120 and the applicable circular. A departmental appeal concerning a refund below that threshold was not maintainable where no exception was pleaded. The resulting order has no precedent value and does not constitute departmental acquiescence. The merits were not decided, and all questions of law were left open.
Outward supply return discrepancies require verification of claimed duplicate and incorrect invoices before the underlying tax liability is determined.
The discrepancy between outward tax liability reported in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B involves claimed duplicate and incorrect invoice entries. These claims require verification against the uploaded sales register and audited profit and loss account. The tax demand requires fresh determination after examination of those records, and the underlying tax liability remains undecided.
Late fees paid for delayed annual returns preclude a general penalty for the same filing default.
Section 47 provides for a late fee for delayed filing of an annual return, while Section 125 provides for a general penalty. Where the annual return has been filed and the applicable late fee paid, a general penalty cannot be imposed for the same delay, as this would create a double penal consequence.
GST rectification for multiple notices or orders covering the same tax period may address errors with intimation to assessees
Section 161 of the Telangana Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 empowers the proper officer to rectify errors in GST notices or orders. Errors in multiple notices or orders covering the same tax period may be addressed through this statutory power, in accordance with law. Affected assessees are to be informed of the rectification exercise and may provide relevant information.
Show-cause notice response and tax reconciliation prompt fresh consideration of GST demands after adjudication orders and recovery notices are quashed
The opportunity to respond to show-cause notices enables consideration of documents reconciling tax demands with tax already paid before enforcement. Adjudication orders and recovery notices under the Central Goods and Services Tax Act were quashed, and the proceedings restored for a response and fresh consideration. The demand for one financial year had been fully recovered, while part of the demand for another year had been recovered. The recovered amounts remain subject to the outcome of the restored proceedings.
GST proceedings for different financial years may continue separately before Central and State authorities despite the same-subject-matter restriction.
Section 6(2)(b) restricts one GST administration from conducting proceedings on the same subject matter already taken up by the other. Different financial years are treated as separate assessment units, so the restriction does not prevent Central and State GST authorities from enquiring into different periods for the same taxpayer. The Central authority may proceed for 2018-19 to 2023-24, while the State authority may proceed for 2024-25 to 2025-26.
GST hearing opportunity after pleaded medical difficulties comes with fresh reply and tax deposit requirements in restored proceedings
Section 75(4) provides for an opportunity of hearing in GST adjudication. Medical difficulties of the petitioner's representative were pleaded as the reason for non-participation, and the petitioner was willing to produce documents contemplated by the applicable circular to reconcile the returns. A further hearing was granted, and the adjudication order and recovery notice were quashed. The restored proceedings required a fresh reply and a deposit of 10% of the tax.
Input tax credit without receipt of goods raises questions over penalties, binding revenue circulars and restraint on further action.
Input tax credit allegedly availed without receipt of goods raises the question whether a proposed penalty conflicts with a revenue circular restricting penalties for that conduct. Board circulars are binding on revenue authorities. The show-cause notice is under challenge in a writ petition, and further action under it has been restrained until the next returnable date. The penalty issue remains unresolved, with no final adjudication.
Zero-rated export refunds cannot be denied solely because branch-performed services are not physically delivered to the contracting head office
GST refunds on zero-rated exports cannot be denied solely because services performed by separately registered branches were not physically delivered to the contracting head office's facility. Section 25 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act treats separately registered establishments as distinct persons. A departmental clarification envisages an inter-branch supply to the contracting head office, followed by a supply to the foreign recipient. Where the head office contracted with and invoiced the recipient, received foreign exchange and paid GST, the refund included admissible interest, although data centres in other States performed the services.
Opportunity to respond after ex parte GST adjudication granted on full tax deposit in return and e-way bill mismatch
Following ex parte GST adjudication involving a mismatch between GSTR-3B declarations and e-way bill particulars, a further opportunity to respond was granted subject to deposit of the entire tax demand, despite an indefinite explanation for non-participation. Part of the demand had already been paid. The adjudication and appellate orders were set aside.
Unanswered GST portal notices call for alternative service and a hearing before assessments are completed
Uploading a GST notice on the portal is sufficient service, but an issuing officer receiving no response should explore other statutory modes to secure effective communication. Assessments completed without adequately exploring alternative service or providing a personal hearing were set aside, conditional on payment of 25% of the disputed tax for each assessment within four weeks. Fresh consideration was directed after an opportunity to file objections and receive a personal hearing.
Corporate guarantee valuation permits evidence of lower market value, while GST applies on execution, renewal, extension or enhancement.
Related-person corporate guarantees supplied in the course or furtherance of business attract GST even without consideration; the related borrower receives the credit-support service, which is not excluded as an actionable claim or security. Rule 28(2) prescribes a deemed value of 1% of the guarantee amount per annum or actual consideration, whichever is higher, but a lower open market value may be established by cogent, verifiable evidence. Invoice value is accepted where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit. Supply occurs on execution and afresh on renewal, extension or enhancement, not through continued subsistence or invocation. Guarantees executed before 1 July 2017 are taxable only upon a subsequent renewal, extension or enhancement; those executed from 1 July 2017 through 25 October 2023 are valued under the rules then in force. Rule 28(2) applies from 26 October 2023, and the 2024 amendment applies retrospectively.
Statutory appeal remedies may limit writ jurisdiction when notice and hearing requirements are substantially met and natural justice is respected.
Writ jurisdiction may be invoked despite an alternative statutory appeal where proceedings lack jurisdiction or violate natural justice. Where statutory procedural requirements have been substantially complied with and neither a jurisdictional defect nor a breach of natural justice is established, the availability of a statutory appeal may justify declining writ jurisdiction.