Advanced Search Options : ❯
Transfer-pricing comparables require functional similarity, reliable segmental data and related-party transaction filters calibrated to available comparables
Transfer-pricing comparability under the transactional net margin method requires functionally similar uncontrolled transactions. Companies with different activities, scale, brand value or intangible assets may be excluded, and reliable segmental financial information is needed to separate margins from diverse activities. Information obtained under Section 133 must be credible and verified. Comparable-selection decisions involving another assessee may provide a relevant basis where material facts and business activities are similar and there is no reason to distinguish them. A 15% related-party transaction filter helps identify uncontrolled margins; a narrower threshold is appropriate when it yields sufficient comparables, while a higher threshold depends on availability at the lower threshold.
Infrastructure developer deduction applies where an enterprise invests in and executes eligible infrastructure projects while assuming entrepreneurial risks.
Section 80-IA(4) permits a deduction for eligible enterprises developing infrastructure facilities under agreements with the government or specified authorities, but excludes mere works contractors. Work orders were issued directly to the assessee or its consortium. The assessee invested funds, carried out development work, deployed technical personnel and equipment, assumed entrepreneurial and investment risks, and undertook maintenance during the defect liability period. On those facts, the assessee qualified as a developer rather than a works contractor or subcontractor and was entitled to the deduction.
Expenditure disallowance for exempt income does not apply when no exempt income is earned during the assessment year.
Section 14A and Rule 8D govern the disallowance of expenditure relating to exempt income. Where no exempt income is earned during the relevant assessment year, expenditure cannot be disallowed under Section 14A. Appellate jurisdiction under Section 260A is confined to substantial questions of law, including in disputes over such disallowance.
Interest on enhanced acquisition compensation forms part of land value, while delayed-payment interest compensates for payment delays.
Interest on excess acquisition compensation under Section 28 forms part of the enhanced value of the acquired land, whereas interest under Section 34 compensates for delay in payment. An acquisition award may also include additional compensation and solatium. Where tax deducted from agricultural-land compensation has been deposited with the Income Tax Department, the Assessing Officer assesses the nature of the land and determines the refund claim.
Mandatory draft assessment orders in transfer pricing cases make final assessments invalid when eligible assessees are not served.
Section 144C of the Income-tax Act, 1961 requires a draft assessment order when a transfer pricing adjustment results in a variation prejudicial to an eligible assessee. The faceless assessment procedure under Section 144B incorporates this requirement and enables objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel. Passing a final assessment order without first serving the mandatory draft order constitutes a jurisdictional defect, not merely a procedural irregularity, and renders the final order invalid.
Revenue appeal monetary limits apply where information comes from the Sales Tax Department, notwithstanding the law enforcement agency exception.
The applicable 2018 circular excludes certain matters based on information from external law enforcement agencies from the monetary limit for Revenue appeals. Information received from the Sales Tax Department falls outside that exception, so the monetary limit applies to Revenue appeals based on such information. The 2024 circular, issued after the relevant Tribunal decision, is not applicable.
Borrowed satisfaction in reopening proceedings involving expenses linked to allegedly bogus purchases leads to petition dismissal on merits.
The validity of reopening proceedings was questioned on whether the reasons to believe reflected borrowed or independent satisfaction, in a matter involving disallowance of expenses related to purchases treated as bogus. The special leave petition was dismissed on merits, with no good ground to interfere with the High Court's order.
GST detention penalties require proof of tax evasion, not an uncorroborated driver's claim about an undisclosed dispatch point.
Recurring questions about mobile-squad enforcement jurisdiction in transportation checks fall outside monetary limits on departmental Tribunal appeals under the litigation circular. A detention-related penalty under section 129 requires intent to evade tax. An uncorroborated driver's allegation of an undisclosed dispatch point cannot sustain the penalty where the goods match the tax invoice and e-way bill and intent to evade is not established. An operational undisclosed facility must be independently established, and penalty discretion must be exercised judicially. Lack of warehouse verification and an opportunity to cross-examine the driver undermine the evidentiary basis for penalty; suspicion cannot replace legal proof.
Timely payment after GST notice precludes penalties, while verified input credit and prior payments resolve disputed tax demands.
The disputed integrated GST input tax credit is supported by verified invoices and a chartered accountant's certificate. Payments already made towards central and state GST must be appropriated against the remaining demands. Section 73(8) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act precludes penalties when tax and interest are paid within the prescribed period after notice. The integrated GST penalty is also unsupported by the records. No tax remains due under the disputed heads, and the consequential interest demand falls.
Transit-state penalties cannot target inter-State consignments without local tax implications or documented, revenue-neutral inter-unit invoice date mismatches.
Transit-state authorities may inspect and verify inter-State consignments, but cannot impose a penalty under Section 129 where the movement has no tax implication in that State. Potential document deficiencies may instead be reported to authorities in the origin or destination State. Seizure and penal demands in these circumstances also implicate the constitutional freedom of trade and commerce. Where goods move under valid supply invoices and e-way bills, a revenue-neutral date mismatch between dispatch documents and inter-unit stock transfer invoices does not justify a transit penalty; Section 129 addresses deliberate tax evasion rather than such technical irregularities.
Deemed export refunds depend on supply-related return dates, prior intimation and recipient undertakings, with cross-year claims permitted.
Deemed export refund claims may combine successive tax periods across financial years. The two-year limitation period under Section 54 runs from the date of furnishing the return relating to the supplies claimed, rather than merely from the period entered in the application. Form A prior intimation must be provided to the supplier and the jurisdictional officers. A supplier may claim a deemed export refund where the recipient has not availed input tax credit and furnishes the required undertaking. Statutory interest may also be payable under Section 56.
Extended GST recovery requires evidence of deliberate evasion; disclosed price adjustments and erroneous self-assessment alone cannot justify it.
An extended-period GST notice under Section 74 requires material supporting fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts with intent to evade tax; mere non-payment or erroneous self-assessment is insufficient. Disclosure of price-adjustment receipts in income-tax and GST filings, bills without GST charges and a bona fide belief in exemption do not, without supporting material, establish deliberate evasion. An unsupported notice is without jurisdiction and, where time-barred, cannot sustain related penalty, surcharge or interest. Statutory remedies do not bar a writ challenge where an authority acts without or beyond jurisdiction. The substantive GST taxability of the price adjustments remains undetermined.
Input tax credit time limits extend retrospectively for eligible past financial years, protecting qualifying claims from earlier restrictions
Section 16(4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 sets a limitation period for claiming input tax credit. Retrospectively applicable Section 16(5) extends the period for credit relating to financial years 2017-18 to 2020-21 where returns were filed by 30 November 2021. Claims falling within the extended period are governed by that period notwithstanding the earlier time limit under Section 16(4).
GST registration cancellation set aside after portal blocks overdue returns, with filing and tax liabilities remaining
GST registration cancelled for non-filing of returns was reinstated after the portal prevented overdue filing beyond the prescribed three-year period. The overdue returns must be filed within 30 days, and tax, penalty, interest and late fees remain payable. Limitation periods under sections 73 and 74 are computed from the order date, except for financial year 2026-27, for which section 44 applies.
GST payments adjusted through accepted DRC-03A forms satisfy the principal tax condition for interest and penalty waiver.
Prior GST payments adjusted through accepted Forms GST DRC-03A count towards the principal tax payment condition for waiver of interest and penalty. Section 128A requires payment of the entire principal tax covered by an eligible demand within the prescribed period. Where tax was previously paid through Form GST DRC-03, Rule 164 requires an adjustment application before the waiver application. The adjusted amount is credited against the demand as payment on the original intimation date. The accepted adjustments left no outstanding principal tax in the electronic liability register, satisfying the payment condition; the waiver application remains to be processed in accordance with law.
GST general penalties must remain within the statutory maximum when imposed in connection with return filing.
General penalties under the Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 cannot exceed the statutory maximum. The return had been filed and the late fee paid, but the general penalty imposed in connection with the return exceeded that limit. The show cause notice and penalty order were quashed in favour of the assessee.
GST arrest safeguards require the Commissioner's recorded reasons and document identification numbers for specified communications, subject to exceptions.
Section 69 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act requires the Commissioner personally to record reasons to believe based on credible material before authorising an arrest. The reasons must demonstrate application of mind to the alleged offence and the need for arrest, and must be conveyed to the person arrested. Reasons recorded by an investigating officer cannot substitute for the Commissioner's reasons. Specified communications, including grounds of arrest and reasons to believe, require a computer-generated document identification number, subject to documented exceptions and subsequent regularisation.
GST late filing penalties are unjustified when statutory late fees are paid and no deliberate delay is found.
Penalty under the general penalty provisions of the Central and Uttar Pradesh GST enactments is unjustified for belated filing of returns where the applicable statutory late fee has been paid and there is no finding of deliberate delay. The relevant conditions are payment of the late fee and the absence of a finding that the delay was deliberate.
Show cause notice reply deadlines must precede personal hearings; scheduling both together breaches the prescribed procedural requirement.
The deadline for replying to a show cause notice must precede the personal hearing under the procedural requirement adopted from the governing precedent. Fixing both on the same day is procedurally irregular. The consent order was expressly declared non-precedential, and entitlement to input tax credit was left for fresh determination.
E-way bill requirements did not apply during the relevant period for a transaction subject to GST penalty proceedings.
For the transaction governed by the Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, no e-way bill was required on 19 February 2018. The requirement to submit an e-way bill did not apply from 1 February to 31 March 2018, the period in which the transaction occurred. Penalty proceedings concerning the transaction arose under section 129 of the Act.