Advanced Search Options : ❯
Reverse charge on construction-related payments requires proof of taxable services, while exemptions and limitation restrict service tax liability.
Service tax exemptions cover qualifying dam and irrigation works supplied to government, public road works, and repair or renovation of civil structures supplied to governmental authorities. A medical college subcontract is taxable where the applicable exemption has been withdrawn; tax paid by the main contractor does not itself exempt the subcontractor. Reverse charge applies to qualifying goods transport agency and advocate services, not merely to supplier invoices, loading expenses or payments to other professionals. Revenue must establish that labour and subcontract payments are for taxable services; accounting descriptions or assumptions alone do not suffice. Royalty deductions alone do not establish a taxable government service or a grant of natural-resource rights. The extended limitation period is unavailable where disputes involve statutory interpretation, returns are regularly filed, information is drawn from books and no fraud or suppression is established.
Residential construction tax distinguishes independently contracted houses from complexes and permits conditional abatement for flats with land interests.
Before 1 July 2012, a residential complex required buildings with more than twelve residential units, common areas and specified facilities within an approved layout. From that date, a self-contained single residential unit outside a residential complex was exempt. Separately contracted houses on demarcated plots do not become part of a residential complex solely because they share gates or amenities; agreements, title documents and approved plans are material. Abatement for residential flats depends on the applicable notification and conditions: 67% for April to June 2010, 75% for July 2010 to June 2012, and the prescribed rate thereafter. Consolidated consideration for a flat and an undivided land interest need not separately allocate the land value; unit specifications require verification.
Prior hearing before criminal investigation is not ordinarily required when writ proceedings direct registration and investigation of a cognizable offence.
Proposed accused persons are not ordinarily entitled to a prior hearing before a writ court directs registration and investigation of a case. The statutory safeguard for public servants governing a Magistrate's complaint procedure does not automatically create that right in writ proceedings based on information from a statutory agency. A direction to investigate does not determine guilt, which remains for investigation and, if applicable, trial. Under the applicable High Court Writ Rules, review is available in criminal writ petitions on Code of Civil Procedure grounds; statutory bars on criminal courts reviewing judgments do not curtail writ jurisdiction. Recall may also be available in appropriate circumstances. The State may withdraw its own challenge despite a change of government, but should not change its position merely to serve political interests.
Money-laundering proceedings based solely on a predicate criminal case cannot survive its quashing but may be revived.
Money-laundering proceedings linked solely to a scheduled offence cannot survive the quashing of the predicate criminal case and its consequential proceedings. Proceeds of crime are property derived or obtained from criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence. The linked money-laundering proceedings and their consequential proceedings may be revived if the predicate proceedings are revived.
Pre-existing operational debt disputes bar insolvency proceedings even when a debtor provides no timely detailed demand notice reply
Pre-existing, plausible and non-illusory disputes over operational debt require rejection of an operational creditor's insolvency application. A late or absent reply to a demand notice does not prevent the debtor from relying on evidence of an earlier dispute. A holding response withholding admission of the demand may constitute notice of dispute even without specific details. The dispute must be supported by evidence, but its likely success need not be determined. Relevant communications may concern outstanding credit notes, detention and demurrage charges, reconciliation and the amount payable, provided they relate to the transactions underlying the claim.
Recall jurisdiction cannot rehear resolution plan merits or grant fresh declarations concerning unadjudicated property attachment rights.
Recall jurisdiction does not permit a rehearing on the merits or a fresh substantive declaration. A remand for reconsideration of a resolution plan does not itself set aside a provisional attachment or determine an enforcement authority's rights where those matters have not been adjudicated. The availability of a statutory appeal and the absence of a challenge to subsequent plan approval are relevant to the recall question. An approved resolution plan that remains unchallenged acquires finality.
MSME revival protection requires substantiated status and prescribed procedure; unsupported claims do not bar insolvency proceedings for debt and default.
The MSME revival framework requires a borrower seeking its benefit to substantiate MSME status and invoke the prescribed procedure. A belated claim without registration evidence or a prescribed application does not bar insolvency proceedings based on established debt and default exceeding the statutory threshold. Debt acknowledgments and settlement proposals admitting liability are relevant to assessing limitation for an insolvency application.
Personal guarantor insolvency objections to creditor standing and maintainability are decided after the resolution professional reports.
Objections to a creditor's standing and the maintainability of an insolvency application against a personal guarantor are adjudicated at the Section 100 stage, after the resolution professional submits a recommendatory report under Section 99. Jurisdictional and limitation objections are also considered at that stage, rather than before the professional's appointment. The treatment of a debtor's own application under Section 94 is distinct from that of a creditor's application under Section 95. The creditor's substantive entitlement to initiate proceedings remains undecided.
Contempt appeals cannot challenge dismissal of a complaint concerning company bank account directions; punishment requires proven deliberate disobedience.
Section 425 of the Companies Act attracts the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and punishment for contempt requires deliberate disobedience to be established beyond doubt. In relation to a direction permitting specified persons to operate company bank accounts, evidence of when disputed cheques were issued, whether they were encashed and whether cash was withdrawn is relevant to proving disobedience. An appeal under Section 19 of the Contempt of Courts Act lies against an order of punishment for contempt, not against dismissal of a contempt petition. An applicant reporting alleged contempt does not control whether the Tribunal continues or drops the proceedings.
Related-party import pricing requires evidence of price influence before customs can reject declared values and impose differential duty.
Related-party status alone does not justify rejecting a declared customs transaction value; evidence must show that the relationship influenced the import price. Customs valuation methods must be applied sequentially, starting with transaction value and comparable-goods methods before later methods are used. Prices of identical or similar goods imported from unrelated suppliers had been accepted. Where no influence on the prices of the imports in question was demonstrated, the declared values were accepted and the differential duty demand, confiscation and penalties were set aside.
Gold seizure requires objective grounds for reasonable belief before possessors bear the burden of proving the gold is not smuggled.
Section 110 of the Customs Act, 1962 requires reasonable belief based on objective material available at seizure; unexplained possession and the purity of unmarked gold do not, by themselves, establish that belief. Without reasonable belief, the burden under Section 123 does not shift to the possessor, and the Department remains responsible for proving foreign origin and smuggling. Uncorroborated retracted statements cannot alone establish the smuggled character of unmarked gold, and reliance on statements requires compliance with Section 138B. Confiscation and penalties cannot be sustained without proof of smuggling.
Court-directed customs deposits before assessment are refundable with interest and are not subject to duty refund limitation.
Court-directed cash deposits made towards prospective customs duty before assessment are not payments of customs duty, so the statutory limitation for duty refunds does not apply. A bank guarantee securing the release of goods is also not a payment of customs duty. The depositor is entitled to a refund of the cash deposit with applicable interest from the date of deposit until refund.
Brown rice protein classification: Technical evidence, disclosed tariff positions and good-faith conduct shape limitation and penalty consequences.
Revenue bears the burden of displacing an importer's brown rice protein powder classification and cannot substitute assumptions for an unrebutted technical opinion identifying cereal proteins. HSN notes distinguish cereal proteins from textured protein substances; the stated 90% protein content for vegetable isolates is not a mandatory threshold for cereal proteins. The classification analysis favours tariff item 3504 0099, although tariff item 2106 1000 is also identified. Rule 3 favours a specific description, while Rule 4 applies only if earlier rules do not determine classification. Foreign customs rulings are not binding under Indian customs law. Extended limitation is unavailable where the classification is disclosed and no suppression or wilful misstatement occurs. Confiscation, redemption fine and penalty are unsustainable where the goods are unavailable and the dispute involves no incorrect description or valuation or bad faith.
Specific tariff entries govern classification of split air conditioners incorporating refrigerating units, taking precedence over generic entries.
Two-ton split air conditioners incorporating a refrigerating unit fall under tariff item 8415 82 10. In tariff classification, a specific entry takes precedence over a generic entry when both describe the goods. The tariff distinguishes split air conditioners incorporating a refrigerating unit from those without one, making that feature relevant to the applicable entry.
Extended customs limitation cannot rest on departmental inaction where known import facts show no collusion, wilful misstatement or suppression.
The extended limitation period under the Customs Act, 1962 requires circumstances such as collusion, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts. Prior departmental knowledge of the nature and description of imported goods, followed by inaction within the normal limitation period, does not justify invoking the extended period in the absence of those circumstances. A wholly time-barred show cause notice raises a threshold jurisdictional question, and an order passed without jurisdiction cannot be cured on appeal.
Personal penalties for fraudulent exports require deliberate abetment by customs officers, not mere negligence or administrative oversight.
Personal penalties under Section 114 of the Customs Act, 1962 require mens rea and a positive, deliberate act of abetment that renders goods liable to confiscation. In the context of fraudulent exports, negligence or administrative oversight by customs officers alone does not establish the penal abetment necessary for imposing personal penalties.
Customs pre-deposit refund interest cannot exceed the notified rate, preventing enhancement beyond the applicable statutory interest prescription.
Interest on a refunded customs investigation deposit treated as a pre-deposit runs from the date of deposit at the 6% rate prescribed by the applicable statutory notifications. A statutory tribunal cannot award a higher rate in excess of those notifications or exercise the writ jurisdiction available to High Courts. Interest therefore cannot be enhanced to 12% in these circumstances.
Countervailing duty refunds depend on rebutting presumed pass-through using invoices, accounting records and a chartered accountant's certificate.
Under the Customs Act, an importer seeking a countervailing duty refund bears the burden of rebutting the presumption that the duty was passed on to customers. Invoices showing no recovery of the duty, balance sheets and a chartered accountant's certificate supported by accounting records can rebut that presumption, permitting payment of the refund. Failure to claim the duty as expenditure does not, by itself, prove that its burden was passed on. The applicable Board circular supports reliance on the certificate, particularly alongside books of account, and the certificate cannot be disregarded contrary to that circular.
Monetary limits on departmental appeals raise maintainability questions where no excess over the prescribed threshold is claimed.
Departmental instructions prescribe monetary limits for appeals before the High Court, with exceptions including classification and refund issues of a legal or recurring nature. The amount involved was not claimed to exceed the prescribed threshold, and classification was neither pleaded nor argued. The appeals remain pending, and their maintainability has not been finally determined.
Charitable trusts' incidental receipts require scrutiny of purpose and income use, while accumulation claims depend on filing requirements.
Receipts from property held under trust and incidental activities do not, by their existence or quantum alone, establish commercial activity under the proviso to section 2(15) and section 13(8) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The nature of the activities, the trust's dominant purpose and application of income are relevant to charitable exemption. Section 11(2) permits accumulation for charitable purposes subject to prescribed requirements. Late filing of Form 10 is not necessarily fatal when it is available before assessment is completed; the form need not separately particularise every charitable object or proposed expenditure.