Advanced Search Options : ❯
Personal hearing compliance in assessment proceedings was not independently decided when the writ petition was disposed of.
Personal hearing requirements in assessment proceedings were raised, but compliance with those requirements was not independently adjudicated. The writ petition was disposed of in terms of an earlier judgment; the relief granted and the effect of that judgment on the assessment proceedings are not specified.
Electronic credit ledger blocking over credit from a non-existent unit remains open to an application for unblocking.
Blocking an electronic credit ledger because a supplier was non-functioning and input tax credit was availed from a non-existent unit falls prima facie within Rule 86A. The authorised authority may unblock the ledger if satisfied that the conditions for disallowing debits no longer exist. For the challenged blocking, an application for unblocking may be made, and the respondents must decide it within 30 days. The validity of the blocking and entitlement to input tax credit have not been finally determined.
Dishonoured cheque claims for chitty debts require proof of the underlying transaction, not merely production of the cheque.
For cheque dishonour under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the complainant's initial burden includes proving the transaction underlying a legally enforceable debt; producing the dishonoured cheque alone does not discharge that burden. In relation to an alleged chitty debt, relevant evidentiary matters include a cheque dated before the alleged auction, unexplained repayments, missing chitty documents and account statements, and a defence that the cheque was issued as security.
Broadcasting invoices to an advertising agency do not bar CENVAT credit when the manufacturer bears tax and documentation is adequate.
CENVAT credit for broadcasting services procured through an advertising agency is admissible despite the broadcasters invoicing the agency, where the manufacturer receives and uses the services, bears the tax and the required particulars are available. Advertising qualifies as an input service, and documentary deficiencies may be considered where prescribed particulars are available. The broadcasters' invoices identified the manufacturer as advertiser, while the agency's invoices disclosed the tax and service particulars. The broadcasting charges passed through as reimbursement, and the agency did not claim the tax as input credit, eliminating duplicate-credit risk.
Residential construction service tax liability began with the statutory Explanation, leaving the services concerned untaxed for earlier periods.
Service tax on the residential construction services concerned applied from 1 July 2010, not for the preceding period. On that date, an Explanation to the definition of taxable construction of complex services under the Finance Act, 1994 took effect. The relevant framework includes tribunal precedents on the Explanation and Board circulars issued on 29 January 2009 and 10 February 2012.
Service tax limitation cannot be extended for mere non-payment without fraud, suppression or other specified grounds.
Service tax demands issued beyond the normal limitation period under Section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994 cannot rely on the extended period merely because tax was not paid. Invoking that period requires fraud, collusion, wilful misstatement, suppression of fact or contravention of a provision or rule. A demand issued beyond the normal period without any such ground is time-barred and unsustainable.
Service tax refund limitation applies to mistaken payments despite non-liability and absence of unjust enrichment under the jurisdictional approach.
The one-year limitation under Section 11B of the Central Excise Act, 1944 applies to service tax refunds through Section 83 of the Finance Act, 1994, including tax paid erroneously or under a mistake, under the jurisdictional High Court's approach; another High Court has taken a contrary approach. For the relevant period, the builder was not liable for service tax on the works contract services. An enabling contractual clause for legally leviable tax, without admissible evidence of collection from buyers, did not establish unjust enrichment. Neither non-liability nor the absence of unjust enrichment displaced the applicable limitation.
Service tax limitation requires proof of wrongdoing, while audit discrepancies alone cannot justify an extended demand period
Section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994 prescribed a one-year normal limitation period for service-tax demands, with an extended period requiring proof of specified wrongdoing. Discrepancies found during an audit of maintained records do not alone establish that wrongdoing, and returns filed after a notice cannot retrospectively extend limitation. Consequential interest and penalties cannot survive a time-barred demand. Input-service credit requires a business nexus, and the applicable definition includes advertising and sales promotion. Life or health insurance used primarily for employees' personal consumption is excluded. Accounting capitalisation does not itself convert services into capital goods, and a prior reversal does not determine original credit eligibility.
Refund disputes involving contested service taxability must follow the statutory appeal route for questions concerning assessment and duty rates.
Refund disputes involving determination of taxability for assessment fall outside the High Court's appellate jurisdiction under section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944. Section 35G excludes appeals involving questions relating to the rate of duty or the value of goods for assessment. Section 35L treats determination of taxability or excisability as a question relating to the rate of duty and provides for an appeal to the Supreme Court. The refund character of a dispute does not change this position where rejection rests on contested taxability.
Substitution of attached land with alternate assets permitted subject to title, non-alienation and third-party rights safeguards.
Substitution of land attached in money-laundering proceedings with alternate assets was permitted subject to safeguards, including proof of clear, marketable and unencumbered title and authority to offer the assets. The safeguards also required preservation of bona fide third-party rights, non-alienation, deposit of title documents, indemnity, disclosure of the source of funds and cooperation with the investigation. Substitution did not prejudice the Directorate's rights or the merits of the ongoing trial.
Provisional attachment after quashing a predicate-offence FIR requires independent assessment of proceeds of crime and other underlying FIRs.
Provisional attachment based on two predicate-offence FIRs cannot be cancelled solely because one FIR is quashed, without considering the other and independently assessing the effect of quashing. Quashing a predicate-offence FIR on compromise does not itself eliminate proceeds of crime. The attachment's validity and the parties' contentions require fresh determination.
Resolution plan deferral pending appeal does not justify adverse findings where stakeholders rely in good faith on finality clauses.
Payment under an approved resolution plan may be deferred pending finality of litigation where the unmodified plan permits it, even if the plan also contains an implementation schedule and unconditionality clause. An interim direction permitting implementation does not mandate it. Bona fide reliance on the payment clause during a pending appeal, even without a stay, does not warrant adverse findings or referral to the insolvency regulator. Adverse observations against a successful resolution applicant who was neither a party nor heard also raise procedural fairness concerns.
Shareholder standing to appeal resolution plan approval does not arise solely from a residual distribution to equity holders
Section 61 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 permits an aggrieved person to appeal, but shareholders acting solely in that capacity lack standing to challenge approval of a resolution plan. A plan's provision for residual distribution to shareholders does not confer standing. Shareholders have a limited role in the resolution process, and their residual equity interests are consequential to distributions under the plan.
Corporate guarantor proceedings may follow the principal borrower's insolvency forum, while direct debt and default independently support insolvency initiation.
Corporate guarantor status may arise where a loan agreement and hypothecation deed, read together, establish an undertaking to discharge the borrower's liability on default. Under section 126 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the document's title and the absence of all parties' signatures on one instrument are not decisive. Section 60 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code permits proceedings involving a corporate guarantor before the forum handling the principal borrower's insolvency, notwithstanding the guarantor's registered office elsewhere. Section 7 separately governs insolvency initiation based on the corporate debtor's own financial debt and default; unpaid direct loans and unstayed arbitral awards recording defaults support that independent basis.
Corporate debtor immunity after liquidation does not shield directors personally involved in alleged offences before insolvency proceedings.
Section 32A of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code protects a liquidated corporate debtor from prosecution for offences committed before the commencement of the corporate insolvency resolution process. Its proviso preserves the liability of persons responsible for the corporate debtor's business who were directly or indirectly involved in the offences. Directors alleged to have induced an investment with intent to cheat cannot claim the corporate debtor's protection. The corporate debtor's immunity and the personal criminal liability of persons involved in its affairs operate independently.
Resolution plan approval ends pre-existing money-laundering attachments on covered property when statutory clean-slate conditions are met
Section 32A of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code protects property covered by an approved resolution plan from continuation of an attachment linked to an offence committed before insolvency commenced, provided control passes to a person satisfying the statutory conditions. Protection begins on plan approval and does not retrospectively invalidate the original attachment. No prior Special Court finding is required to establish eligibility where the enforcement authority alleges neither that the property is outside the plan nor that the new controller falls within a statutory exception.
Anticipatory bail in organised investment fraud depends on alleged involvement, investigative needs and potential custodial interrogation.
Anticipatory bail is an extraordinary discretionary remedy assessed in light of the accusations, the applicant's alleged role and investigative needs. In allegations of organised investment fraud, relevant considerations include multiple complainants, alleged involvement in investment agreements and demat accounts, and the possibility of further victims. Resignation does not necessarily negate alleged earlier involvement. Regular bail in another matter involving different complainants and a settlement does not determine a separate application. Documentary evidence alone does not eliminate the possible need for custodial interrogation, and the risk of similar offending is also relevant.
Prospectus expert consent alone does not establish criminal liability, and delayed complaints require justification to overcome the limitation period.
Consent by an expert to include a statement in a prospectus does not, by itself, authorise its issue or establish criminal liability for misstatements under the Companies Act, 1956. Fraudulent inducement requires allegations of inducement to invest, while liability for knowingly false statements requires specific allegations and material showing direct complicity or conscious knowledge of falsification. The applicable three-year limitation period was calculated by reference to the complaint's filing; a complaint filed nearly six years after the prospectus was barred, with no application or explanation for delay on record. Delayed cognizance requires a proper explanation and condonation in the interests of justice.
Quashing deposit complaints on defence material requires impeccable material that conclusively displaces allegations without taking evidence.
Section 397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 bars a second revision after a revision has been pursued, but Section 482 preserves inherent jurisdiction for sparing use to prevent grave miscarriage of justice or abuse of process. Defence material relied on to quash a complaint must be of sterling and impeccable quality and conclusively displace the accusation without taking evidence. Section 58A of the Companies Act, 1956 penalises deposit-related contraventions. Amounts received from directors are conditionally excluded under the Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules, 1975, including where a written declaration addresses the source of funds. Disputed loan sources and compliance with the exclusion conditions require evidence.
Company property rights remain enforceable through civil suits despite parallel proceedings alleging oppression and mismanagement of company affairs.
Independent civil suits to protect company property and possession are not barred merely because oppression and mismanagement proceedings are pending before the Tribunal. Civil jurisdiction is preserved unless expressly or impliedly barred, and any exclusion must be strictly construed. Section 430 of the Companies Act, 2013 is matter-specific, while Section 242 does not empower the Tribunal to adjudicate proprietary claims over immovable property. Section 241 applications may be made by eligible members, subject to Section 244 and any applicable waiver, or by the Central Government. A company cannot ordinarily apply in its own right merely because it owns the property.