Advanced Search Options : ❯
Income tax reassessment challenge seeks to set aside statutory notices and restrain enforcement pending the writ petition.
Income-tax reassessment proceedings are challenged through a writ petition seeking to set aside a notice under section 148 and an order under section 148A(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The challenge also extends to further reassessment notices and any reassessment order made during the petition's pendency. Interim relief is sought to restrain enforcement of those measures and a notice under section 142(1). The specific grounds for the alleged illegality are not stated.
Faceless assessment deadlines govern late replies and hearing requests; harmless digital signature date differences do not invalidate orders
Section 144B of the Income-tax Act requires a show-cause notice for a proposed prejudicial variation and permits a reply within the specified or extended period. A timely request for a personal hearing must be granted by video conference. The response period must be reasonable, although the ordinary period may be shortened having regard to the assessment limitation. Where no timely reply or extension request is made, a proposal has been prepared and no sufficient cause is shown, the authority need not reopen the show-cause stage or issue a reasoned decision on a belated reply or hearing request. A minor discrepancy between the order date and digital authentication date does not invalidate the order where no prejudice is shown. The merits of additions remain available for consideration in statutory appeal.
Scope of precedent in an earlier disposal is questioned as the main matter returns for hearing on unadjudicated issues.
The scope of the precedent relied on for the earlier disposal is in question because the main matter may raise issues not covered by it. The earlier order was recalled and the main matter restored for hearing. The issues in the main matter remain unadjudicated, including the question of precedent coverage.
Plastic nursery pots and seedling trays fall under plastic articles for GST, not agricultural implements or machinery.
Plastic nursery pots, flowering-plant pots and seedling trays are classified under the tariff headings and relevant section and chapter notes. Polypropylene products fall under HSN 39269080 and HDPE products under HSN 39269099. They hold soil and seedlings, perform no mechanical function and are not agricultural implements or horticultural tools. The products attract 18% GST as plastic articles; Schedule I does not apply. Questions about supplies by distinct persons in other States are inadmissible for an applicant's advance ruling where those supplies are not undertaken or proposed by the applicant.
Double-sided PVC-coated fabric classification as plastic sheets determines the applicable tariff item and GST rate on supply.
Woven polyester fabric fully coated on both sides with PVC visible to the naked eye is excluded from heading 5903 and, when supplied as qualifying rectangular sheets or uncut rolls, falls under heading 3921. Lacquered sheets fall under tariff item 39219022, while other sheets fall under tariff item 39219029. Supplies of the specified plastic sheets attract 18% GST, comprising 9% CGST and 9% SGST.
Electricity and eligible water reimbursements are excluded from taxable supply value when lessors meet pure-agent conditions and recover actual costs.
Rule 33 excludes expenditure incurred by a supplier acting as a pure agent from taxable supply value when prescribed conditions are met, including authorisation, separate indication in the invoice and recovery of actual costs. Electricity supplied with renting is treated as part of a composite supply, while actual-cost recovery by a lessor acting as a pure agent is addressed separately. Electricity charges and charges for water covered by the exemption notification are excludable when the lessor meets the pure-agent requirements and recovers the invoiced charges without surplus or deficit.
Maintenance GST exemptions and pure-agent utility reimbursements remain available despite association turnover exceeding the registration threshold.
Maintenance collections by a non-profit association for goods or services for common use are exempt from GST up to Rs. 7,500 per member per month, even if annual aggregate turnover exceeds Rs. 20 lakh. If the monthly amount exceeds Rs. 7,500 per member, GST at 18% applies to the entire maintenance amount. Reimbursements for common-area electricity and water qualify for exemption when recovered at actual cost in compliance with pure-agent conditions, including recipient authorisation, separate indication on the invoice, and procurement in addition to the association's own services.
Maintenance charges and utility recoveries receive different GST treatment based on monthly limits and compliance with pure-agent requirements.
Monthly maintenance charges supplied by a non-profit entity to members for common use are exempt from GST up to Rs. 7,500 per member per month. If that limit is exceeded and annual aggregate turnover exceeds Rs. 20 lakh, GST at 18% applies to the entire maintenance charge. Separately recovered actual costs of common-area electricity and water qualify for exemption where pure-agent requirements are met, including authorisation, separate invoicing, procurement in addition to the supplier's own services, and recovery of actual costs. Qualifying pure-agent expenditure is excluded from the value of supply, and exempt supplies require a separate bill of supply.
Tax demands outside the show-cause notice, unverified interest and dependent penalties cannot be restored without substantiated determinations.
Sections 73 and 75 require an intelligible charge and a reasoned tax determination confined to the notice. The disputed tax demand cannot be restored: TDS was not identified as a distinct ground, the Forms C objection was not pursued, and the tax components and adjustments were not reconciled. The net legacy balance remains unascertained. Interest under section 50 cannot be restored without a verifiable computation of the relevant dates, rate, period and ledger-based utilisation. Penalty cannot be restored because its statutory basis depends on the unsustained tax determination; the absence of fraud alone does not preclude a penalty under section 73.
GST refund rectification relates back to a timely original filing, while the statutory limitation period remains mandatory.
Bona fide rectification of a timely GST refund application relates back to the original filing but cannot cure an application already barred by limitation. A deficiency memo seeking unspecified documents does not by itself render the original application non-existent. The two-year refund limitation period is mandatory, and neither the proper officer nor the appellate authority has power to condone delay. The period from 1 March 2020 to 28 February 2022 is excluded from refund limitation; where the relevant date fell within that window, the full two-year period became available from 1 March 2022. The monetary-limit exception for departmental appeals covers refund matters and recurring interpretative questions.
Past input tax credit allegations cannot justify confiscating transit goods without allegations or evidence linking them to past supplies.
Allegations of irregular input tax credit on past inward supplies alone do not justify confiscation of goods in transit or the associated penalty where no allegation or evidence links those supplies to the detained goods. Section 130 permits confiscation under the relevant clauses for contraventions involving intent to evade tax, with penalty under Section 122. Compliance with Rule 138A documentation requirements and the absence of alleged discrepancies in the notice or adjudication order are also relevant circumstances.
E-way bill covering multiple invoices does not justify detention or penalty where goods match documents and tax evasion is unproved.
One e-way bill covering two invoices for the same consignment does not justify detention or imposition of tax and penalty where both invoices and a valid e-way bill accompany the goods, the particulars match, the transaction is recorded and tax is paid, and no intention to evade tax is established. Section 129 addresses detention and seizure for transport in contravention of GST law, while Rule 138 requires prescribed information and an e-way bill before movement of qualifying consignments. The applicable circular addresses minor discrepancies in accompanying documents.
Unaccounted taxable stock can trigger confiscation and penalties, while recurring statutory interpretation disputes bypass departmental monetary appeal limits.
Departmental monetary limits do not bar litigation raising recurring questions of statutory interpretation, including the statutory route applicable to stock discrepancies discovered during inspection. Taxable goods that are not accounted for are liable to confiscation and penalty under an independent statutory provision, alongside the requirement to maintain accurate stock records. Confiscation-related liabilities can also include tax. A signed inventory recording varied individual weights, the absence of contemporaneous objections and unreconciled discrepancies are relevant to assessing unaccounted stock. Decisions involving estimated stock may be distinguishable on their evidence and statutory context.
E-invoices and e-way bills generated after interception do not automatically cure transport noncompliance or prevent penalties.
Notified suppliers must issue e-invoices in the prescribed manner, and e-way bills are required before goods move. A manual invoice does not replace a required e-invoice, and subsequent generation of either electronic document does not itself cure its absence during transportation or preclude a penalty. Missing documents at interception near the destination may support an inference of tax evasion, which can be rebutted by a credible explanation. Section 75 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act requires a penalty order to set out the relevant facts and the basis for the decision.
Reconciled order slips cannot support GST demands for exempt supplies or taxable transactions already reported and taxed
GST demands based on loose order slips cannot include exempt supplies or taxable transactions already reported and taxed. Where temporary order slips record exempt supplies of atta, maida and choker, or taxable transactions reconciled with invoices, the sales register and returns reporting turnover and tax paid, the slips do not support disputed tax, interest or penalty liabilities under section 74.
Supplier e-invoice failures cannot trigger recipient penalties when inter-State goods carry proper tax invoices and valid e-way bills.
The supplier is responsible for issuing the tax invoice and meeting e-invoicing requirements. A recipient cannot be penalised for the supplier's failure to generate an e-invoice where goods in an inter-State supply are accompanied by a proper tax invoice and a valid e-way bill. The applicable circular does not require a physical e-invoice to accompany the goods. The inter-State transfer between separately registered units attracted IGST, and its payment was recorded in the invoice and returns.
GST portal service remains sufficient, but unanswered notices call for exploring alternative delivery before an ex parte assessment.
GST portal notices constitute sufficient service, but an issuing officer should explore alternative modes under section 169 when repeated notices receive no response, preferably registered post with acknowledgement due. This supports effective service before an ex parte assessment. Fresh consideration of an assessment where no personal hearing was afforded should provide an opportunity to respond and be heard. Section 16(4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 prescribes the time limit for claiming input tax credit.
GST registration cancellation requires a scheduled personal hearing, while serious breaches of natural justice can support writ jurisdiction.
Section 29 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 requires an opportunity to be heard before cancellation of registration. Where the cancellation notice contemplates a personal hearing, the date, time and venue must be fixed before registration is cancelled. Filing a written reply does not remove the requirement to provide that hearing. An alternative statutory remedy does not bar writ jurisdiction where the challenge concerns a glaring breach of natural justice through denial of a hearing rather than the merits of cancellation.
Prejudgment in interest recovery raises natural justice concerns over an allegedly formal intimation, while liability remains undecided.
The proposed recovery of interest raises a natural justice concern over whether liability had already been prejudged and the intimation was merely an empty formality. Consideration of the prior direction concerning natural justice was expected, but neither the validity of the intimation nor the underlying interest liability was finally adjudicated.
GST notices after mergers must name the amalgamated company once the merger has been communicated to the department.
For GST proceedings under Section 73 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, a show-cause notice issued after a merger has taken effect and has been communicated to the department must name the amalgamated company rather than the merged company. A notice issued in the merged company's name in those circumstances is invalid. The department remains free to proceed in accordance with law.