Security features determine tariff classification of ballot boxes under Heading 83.03 rather than residual iron or steel entries.

Ballot boxes made of thin steel sheets with locking devices were treated as classifiable under Heading 83.03, because that heading covers armoured or reinforced safes, strong-boxes, cash or deed boxes, and similar metal containers designed for security. The classification turned on the material, sheet thickness, and locking arrangement, which showed protection against theft and fire and made the boxes comparable to cash or deed boxes. They were therefore not classifiable under Heading 7326.90 as other articles of iron or steel, and the departmental trade notice adopting the same view was regarded as correct.

---

---

Issues: Whether ballot boxes made of thin steel sheets with locking devices were classifiable under Heading 83.03 as boxes comparable to cash or deed boxes, or under Heading 7326.90 as other articles of iron or steel.

Analysis: Heading 83.03 covers armoured or reinforced safes, strong-boxes, cash or deed boxes and the like of base metal. The HSN notes make clear that the heading extends to portable metal cash or deed boxes, and also to collecting-boxes and money-boxes having similar security features, such as protection against theft and fire. The relevant factors include the material used, thickness of the sheets, and the locking arrangement. The ballot boxes in question were made of steel sheets of 1 mm and 1.6 mm thickness and had locking devices, showing that they were intended to provide security. On that basis, they were not materially different from cash or deed boxes of the kind covered by Heading 83.03. The trade notice of the department taking the same view was also treated as correct.

Conclusion: The ballot boxes were correctly classifiable under Heading 83.03 and not under Heading 7326.90, and the assessee's appeal failed.

Ratio Decidendi: For tariff classification, boxes designed with security features to protect contents against theft or fire may fall within Heading 83.03 as boxes comparable to cash or deed boxes, even if their actual use is for ballot papers rather than money or documents.

---