Classification of paper-based technical laminates turned on whether the goods were electrical insulators or decorative laminates.

Paper-based technical laminates were to be classified by reference to the settled distinction between electrical insulators of any material under Heading 85.46 and decorative paper-based laminates under Chapter 39. The decisive question was factual: whether the goods manufactured were in substance electrical insulators, which had not been determined on the record. The matter was therefore remanded for fresh decision after verification of that factual position and after giving the respondents an opportunity of hearing.

---

---

Issues: Whether paper based technical laminates were classifiable as electrical insulators under Heading 85.46 or as decorative paper based laminates under Chapter 39, and whether the matter required factual verification.

Analysis: The classification principle had been settled by the Supreme Court, which distinguished electrical insulators of any material under Heading 85.46 from decorative paper based laminates under Chapter 39. On the record before it, the factual position as to whether the laminates manufactured by the respondents were electrical insulators was not and required determination.

Conclusion: The matter was remanded for fresh decision after determining whether the laminates were electrical insulators and after granting an opportunity of hearing to the respondents.

---