Search penalty requires undisclosed income found during search, not a foreign-account record already held by the Revenue.
Section 271AAA applies to undisclosed income within its search-related definition; a foreign-account record already held by the Revenue and merely shown during a search is not a record found in that search. Once original penalty proceedings conclude without initiating penalty on the foreign-account amount, a second penalty order and an appellate direction to impose it lack authority. Penalty also requires a substantive, rather than a protective, addition. Immunity depends on conditions concerning admission, the manner of derivation, and payment of tax and interest; the absence of a specific query about the manner was taken into account. A mechanically issued notice lacking the addition's quantum and the precise charge cannot sustain penalty. The assessee's death during pending proceedings was also treated as a ground against penalty, consistent with earlier proceedings.
Issues: (i) Whether income disclosed after confrontation with a document already held by the Revenue constituted undisclosed income found during search; (ii) whether a second penalty order and the appellate direction to impose it were valid; (iii) whether penalty could be sustained on a protective addition; (iv) whether the assessee qualified for penalty immunity; (v) whether the penalty could be sustained following the assessee's death; and (vi) whether the penalty notice was valid.
Issue (i): Whether income disclosed after confrontation with a document already held by the Revenue constituted undisclosed income found during search.
Analysis: Section 271AAA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 applies to undisclosed income within its prescribed search-related definition. The foreign-account document was already in the Revenue's possession and was shown to the assessee during the search; no search record established its seizure during that operation.
Conclusion: The document did not establish undisclosed income found during search for the purpose of the penalty, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (ii): Whether a second penalty order and the appellate direction to impose it were valid.
Analysis: The Assessing Officer had completed the original penalty proceedings without initiating penalty for the foreign-account amount. Once those proceedings concluded, the officer was functus officio. Coterminous appellate powers did not authorise a direction requiring the officer to take an action for which the officer lacked authority.
Conclusion: The second penalty order and the direction underlying it were invalid, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (iii): Whether penalty could be sustained on a protective addition.
Analysis: The foreign-account amount had been offered in the return, rather than added by the Assessing Officer, and was subsequently retained on a protective basis. The Tribunal applied the principle that a penalty requires a substantive rather than a protective addition.
Conclusion: Penalty could not be sustained on the protective addition, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (iv): Whether the assessee qualified for penalty immunity.
Analysis: Section 271AAA provides immunity where its conditions concerning admission, manner of derivation and payment of tax and interest are met. The amount was offered during the search, included in the return and subjected to tax and interest. The approach followed in the assessee's earlier penalty proceedings also took account of the absence of a specific query about the manner of derivation.
Conclusion: The assessee qualified for penalty immunity, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (v): Whether the penalty could be sustained following the assessee's death.
Analysis: The assessee died while the penalty dispute was pending. A coordinate bench had taken the death into account in the assessee's earlier penalty proceedings, and that approach was followed for consistency.
Conclusion: The penalty was untenable on account of the assessee's death, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (vi): Whether the penalty notice was valid.
Analysis: The notice was issued mechanically without specifying the quantum of the relevant addition or the precise charge for which penalty was proposed.
Conclusion: The penalty could not be sustained on the notice, in favour of the assessee.
Final Conclusion: The disputed foreign-account disclosure was not subject to the impugned penalty, for independent substantive and procedural reasons.
Ratio Decidendi: A document already held by the Revenue and merely shown to an assessee during a search is not a document found during that search for establishing undisclosed income under section 271AAA.