Derivative trading stock revaluation permits deduction of unrealised losses when market value falls below cost under commercial accounting.
Derivative contracts held as stock-in-trade are valued at cost or market value, whichever is lower, making an unrealised revaluation loss deductible. Transitional leave travel and medical benefit liabilities determined actuarially under a revised employee-benefit accounting standard are allowable rather than prior-period expenditure. A predecessor bank's debenture redemption reserve, created from appropriated income and later released, is not taxable again. Minimum alternate tax under Section 115JB does not apply to the banking company for the assessment year in question. Section 43B links leave-encashment deductions to actual payment, so an unpaid provision is not deductible. A UPS serving a computer qualifies for depreciation at 60% where independent use has not been established by material.
Issues: (i) Whether a loss on revaluation of derivative contracts held as stock-in-trade is allowable; (ii) whether transitional liabilities for leave travel entitlement and medical benefits are allowable; (iii) whether the release of a predecessor bank's debenture redemption reserve is taxable; (iv) whether minimum alternate tax applies to the banking company for the assessment year in question; (v) whether an unpaid provision for leave encashment is deductible; and (vi) whether a UPS qualifies for depreciation at 60%.
Issue (i): Whether a loss on revaluation of derivative contracts held as stock-in-trade is allowable.
Analysis: The classification of the contracts as stock-in-trade was undisputed. Commercial accounting principles applied under Sections 37 and 145 require closing stock to be valued at cost or market value, whichever is lower, with an unrealised fall in value taken into account in computing business profits.
Conclusion: The revaluation loss is allowable, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (ii): Whether transitional liabilities for leave travel entitlement and medical benefits are allowable.
Analysis: The employee-benefit accounting standard was revised during the relevant year. The liabilities were disclosed in the annual accounts and determined on an actuarial basis under the revised standard; their treatment as prior-period expenditure was factually incorrect.
Conclusion: The transitional employee-benefit liabilities are allowable, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (iii): Whether the release of a predecessor bank's debenture redemption reserve is taxable.
Analysis: The reserve had been created from the predecessor bank's appropriated income. When it was no longer required, it was credited to the profit and loss account and reduced in the income computation; the adjustment was not a claim for a deduction of expenditure.
Conclusion: The released reserve is not taxable again, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (iv): Whether minimum alternate tax applies to the banking company for the assessment year in question.
Analysis: The question under Section 115JB was governed by the precedent previously applied to the same banking company.
Conclusion: Minimum alternate tax does not apply to the banking company for the assessment year in question, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (v): Whether an unpaid provision for leave encashment is deductible.
Analysis: Section 43B regulates the deduction of leave-encashment liability by linking it to actual payment, notwithstanding that the liability is recognised under mercantile accounting.
Conclusion: The unpaid provision is not deductible, in favour of the Revenue.
Issue (vi): Whether a UPS qualifies for depreciation at 60%.
Analysis: The applicable precedent treats a UPS serving a computer as eligible for the computer depreciation rate where independent usage has not been established by material.
Conclusion: Depreciation at 60% is allowable on the UPS, in favour of the assessee.
Final Conclusion: The assessment must give effect to the permitted trading-stock, employee-benefit and reserve adjustments, exclude minimum alternate tax for the relevant year, disallow the unpaid leave-encashment provision and apply the computer depreciation rate to the UPS.
Ratio Decidendi: Stock-in-trade is valued at cost or market value, whichever is lower, and the resulting trading loss is allowable even if unrealised.