Capital gains valuation under section 50C: circle rate multiplicative factor based on revenue records, factor '1' applied

Capital gains computation under section 50C concerns application of the circle rate multiplicative factor determined by the recorded character of land. The legal basis is that revenue records identifying land as agricultural/residential govern circle rate characterisation, and unauthorised commercial use alone does not effect deemed conversion unless recognised by revenue authorities; consequence: the multiplicative factor of 1 must be applied and an assessing officer's application of factor 3 based on actual use is invalid, resulting in a ruling for reduction of the circle rate valuation.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether, for the purpose of valuation under Section 50C of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the multiplicative factor '1' (applicable to agricultural/residential land) should be applied to the subject Lal Dora property despite its actual commercial use as a godown.

Analysis: The Tribunal examined the revenue records and the identification of the subject property as agricultural/residential (Lal Dora) in state records and the agreement to sell. The Tribunal noted that the building's commercial use as a godown was not recognized by revenue authorities by way of reclassification, levy of penalty, or any alteration in official revenue records. The Tribunal applied the principle that circle rate multiplicative factors for stamp duty are to be determined by the character of the property as shown in revenue records maintained by competent authorities, and that mere unauthorised or factual commercial use does not amount to deemed conversion for valuation purposes unless recognized by revenue authorities.

Conclusion: The multiplicative factor '1' is to be applied for valuation under Section 50C; the application of multiplicative factor '3' by the Assessing Officer is invalid. This conclusion is in favour of the Assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: For stamp-duty valuation under Section 50C, the multiplicative factor applicable to circle rates is determined by the property's classification in official revenue records; unrecognised or unauthorised change in use does not alter that classification for valuation purposes.

---