Deemed MODVAT credit turns on whether exemption notifications are unconditional or conditional for non-duty-paid inputs.

Deemed MODVAT credit could be denied for copper scrap and aluminium scrap because the exemption notifications were unconditional and treated the goods as clearly recognisable as non-duty paid. By contrast, deemed credit on unwrought copper could not be denied on the same footing, since the relevant notification was conditional and the Department had not shown that the particular inputs came from a non-duty-paid stream or satisfied the exemption conditions. The note therefore draws a distinction between unconditional exemptions, which may justify denial of deemed credit, and conditional exemptions, where proof of the non-duty-paid character of the inputs is required before credit can be refused.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether deemed MODVAT credit on copper scrap and aluminium scrap could be denied on the footing that the inputs were clearly recognisable as non-duty paid under the exemption notifications; and (ii) whether deemed MODVAT credit on unwrought copper could be denied on the same basis.

Issue (i): Whether deemed MODVAT credit on copper scrap and aluminium scrap could be denied on the footing that the inputs were clearly recognisable as non-duty paid under the exemption notifications.

Analysis: Rule 57G(2) permits deemed credit in specified cases unless the inputs are shown to be clearly recognisable as non-duty paid. Notifications governing copper scrap and aluminium scrap granted total exemption, coupled with a deeming clause treating stocks as duty paid for the purposes of the notifications. The exemption was therefore unconditional, and the Department was entitled to treat such scrap as clearly recognisable as non-duty paid for the purposes of the deemed credit scheme.

Conclusion: Deemed MODVAT credit on copper scrap and aluminium scrap was rightly denied; the finding was against the assessee.

Issue (ii): Whether deemed MODVAT credit on unwrought copper could be denied on the same basis.

Analysis: The notification relating to unwrought copper was conditional and did not create the same unconditional exemption as in the case of the scrap notifications. In the absence of enquiry or proof that the particular unwrought copper came from a non-duty-paid stream or that the exemption conditions were satisfied, the Department could not deny deemed credit merely on the basis of the notification.

Conclusion: Deemed MODVAT credit on unwrought copper was allowable; the finding was in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The denial of deemed credit was sustained for copper scrap and aluminium scrap, but the assessee succeeded in respect of unwrought copper, resulting in a partial allowance of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi: Under the deemed credit scheme, unconditional exemption notifications may justify denial of credit on the ground that inputs are clearly recognisable as non-duty paid, but where the exemption is conditional the Department must establish that the particular inputs satisfy the non-duty-paid condition before denying credit.

---