Customs exemption denied for flame proof well glasses classified outside Chapter 85 lighting fittings

Flame proof well glasses were held ineligible for exemption under Notification No. 106/77-Cus. because they were classified as outer glass shells or glass envelopes for electric lamps, not as lighting fittings within Chapter 85. The Tribunal treated the Chapter 85 exclusion in the tariff notes as decisive for customs classification and exemption, and held that a CVD assessment under Tariff Item 23A could not change that customs position. As the notification applied only to lighting fittings falling within Chapter 85, the exemption was denied and the appeal failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether flame proof well glasses were eligible for the benefit of Notification No. 106/77-Cus. in view of their classification under Chapter 85 of the Customs Tariff Act.

Analysis: The appeal turned on whether the goods could be treated as lighting fittings falling within Chapter 85 so as to attract the exemption under Notification No. 106/77-Cus. The prior decision in the same appellant's case had already held that the goods were outer glass shells or glass envelopes for electric lamps used in mines, and that such goods were specifically excluded from Chapter 85 by the tariff notes. The Tribunal held that the notification extended only to lighting fittings which themselves fell within Chapter 85, and that a later contention based on CVD assessment under Tariff Item 23A could not alter the basic customs classification, because the exclusion under Chapter 85 remained controlling for exemption purposes.

Conclusion: The goods were not eligible for the benefit of Notification No. 106/77-Cus., and the appeal failed.

---