Closing stock valuation of dining leaves justified only a limited addition where older stock had deteriorated.

Closing stock of dining leaves was revalued on the basis that older stock had become brittle, torn and mixed with newer stock, affecting its realizable value. On a broad assessment of the probabilities, the Tribunal held that the addition for alleged under-valuation was excessive and required only a limited adjustment. The sustained addition was therefore restricted to Rs. 4,000, and the balance was deleted.

---

---

Issues: Whether the addition made on account of alleged under-valuation of the closing stock was justified in full, or whether it required reduction on a reasonable estimate.

Analysis: The dispute concerned the valuation of closing stock of dinning leaves. The assessee explained that older stock became brittle, torn, and was mixed with newer stock, affecting realizable value. On a broad view of the matter and the probabilities of the case, the Tribunal found that the addition sustained by the lower authorities was excessive and that only a smaller addition was warranted.

Conclusion: The addition was reduced to Rs. 4,000 and the balance was deleted.

---