Loading...
By creating an account you can:
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms. Rules for Better Search
Use comma for multiple locations.
---------------- For section wise search only -----------------
No Folders have been created
Are you sure you want to delete "My most important" ?
NOTE:
ISSUES PRESENTED AND CONSIDERED
1. Whether non-compete fee paid by an assessee, on the facts examined, constitutes an allowable revenue expenditure under Section 37(1), or is to be treated as capital expenditure.
2. Whether interest on borrowed funds, utilised for investment in a subsidiary to acquire controlling interest and for interest-free advances to a sister concern and its directors, is allowable as a business deduction under Section 36(1)(iii) on the basis of commercial expediency.
ISSUE-WISE DETAILED ANALYSIS
Issue 1: Characterisation of non-compete fee (revenue vs. capital)
Legal framework: The Court examined Section 37(1), which allows deduction of business expenditure not covered by Sections 30-36, provided it is not capital or personal expenditure and is incurred wholly and exclusively for business purposes. The Court applied judicially accepted tests discussed in its analysis, including the "enduring benefit" approach and the distinction between expenditure in the capital field versus expenditure facilitating trading operations while leaving the fixed capital untouched.
Interpretation and reasoning: The Court treated non-compete fee as a payment made to restrain another from competing, intended to protect/enhance profitability and give a business head-start. It held that such payment, in the circumstances assessed, does not create a new asset, does not add to or replace the profit-making apparatus, and does not bring an advantage in the capital field. The Court emphasised that the duration of benefit is not determinative; what matters is whether the advantage is capital in nature. It further reasoned that even with a non-compete arrangement, there is no certainty that the payer will actually secure the anticipated benefit, and the payer does not thereby obtain monopoly or complete elimination of competition. The expenditure was found to be for operating the business more efficiently and profitably, with fixed assets remaining untouched.
Conclusion: The Court conclusively held that the non-compete fee considered in the decided appeal is revenue expenditure allowable under Section 37(1). As a result, the Court set aside the contrary view treating it as capital expenditure for that case. Because the expenditure was held revenue in nature, the Court held that the related depreciation question (if capital) became unnecessary for decision in that appeal.
Issue 2: Allowability of interest on borrowed funds invested in subsidiary / advanced interest-free to sister concern and its directors
Legal framework: The Court examined Section 36(1)(iii), which permits deduction of interest paid on capital borrowed for the purposes of business or profession. The Court applied the principle that the decisive inquiry is whether the borrowing and its deployment were for commercial expediency, rather than whether the deployment directly yielded profit.
Interpretation and reasoning: The Court found that borrowed funds were used for investment in a subsidiary through purchase of shares to obtain controlling interest, and held this to be a business purpose grounded in commercial expediency. It accepted that business purpose need not be confined narrowly to immediate income generation, and that revenue authorities cannot substitute their own commercial judgment for that of the assessee where nexus with business purpose exists. The Court further held that advances to the sister concern and its directors were also covered by the principle of commercial expediency on the facts as accepted by the Tribunal.
Conclusion: The Court affirmed allowance of interest deduction under Section 36(1)(iii) for (i) interest attributable to borrowings used for investment in the subsidiary to acquire controlling interest and (ii) interest relating to advances treated as commercially expedient. The revenue's challenge on this issue was dismissed, and the issue was conclusively decided in favour of the assessee.
DISPOSITIVE DIRECTIONS (only as decided)
The Court allowed the appeal concerning non-compete fee by holding it to be allowable revenue expenditure, rendering the depreciation-on-non-compete question unnecessary for decision in that appeal. For other matters concerning depreciation claims on non-compete fee, the Court directed remand to the respective Tribunal(s) for fresh adjudication consistent with the ratio laid down. On the interest issue under Section 36(1)(iii), the Court affirmed the allowance and dismissed the revenue's appeal.
Issues: (i) Whether comparables having disproportionately high turnover or functionally dissimilar activities must be excluded while benchmarking software development services; (ii) Whether interest on overdue receivables from associated enterprises should be computed at LIBOR plus 200 basis points instead of LIBOR plus 450 basis points.
Issue (i): Whether comparables having disproportionately high turnover or functionally dissimilar activities must be excluded while benchmarking software development services.
Analysis: Transfer-pricing comparability under the transactional net margin method requires quantitative and qualitative criteria that ensure economic similarity. Substantial turnover differences may affect market position, bargaining power, economies of scale, brand advantage, capacity for complex contracts and profitability. Use of a lower turnover threshold logically supports an appropriate upper turnover filter, though the appropriate range depends on the tested party's facts and no rigid turnover formula applies. A company engaged in infrastructure management, cloud computing, content management, network operations and quality-assurance services is functionally different from a captive software development service provider.
Conclusion: The specified high-turnover comparables and the functionally dissimilar comparable must be excluded from the comparability set, in favour of the assessee.
Issue (ii): Whether interest on overdue receivables from associated enterprises should be computed at LIBOR plus 200 basis points instead of LIBOR plus 450 basis points.
Analysis: Benchmarking interest on overdue receivables requires a rate justified by the credit risk involved. No basis was recorded for adding 450 basis points over LIBOR, while the receivable was from the holding company and involved limited or no material credit risk. A LIBOR-plus-200-basis-points benchmark was appropriate to bring finality to the adjustment.
Conclusion: Interest on overdue receivables must be recomputed at LIBOR plus 200 basis points, in favour of the assessee.
Final Conclusion: The arm's-length price requires recomputation after exclusion of the identified comparables and application of the revised benchmark for overdue receivables.
Ratio Decidendi: Transfer-pricing benchmarking must be founded on economically and functionally comparable entities and on pricing that is justified by the actual risk profile of the transaction.
Issues: Whether GST is payable on medicines, medical devices and consumables supplied to in-patients as part of hospital health services.
Analysis: The factual controversy concerns whether GST was separately collected on such supplies. The adjudicating authority was directed to consider the invoices, procurement details, tax paid at procurement, and the manner in which the supplies were billed to patients.
Outcome: Notice issued; adjudication may continue, but any final order shall not be given effect to during pendency of the writ petition.
Issues: Whether setting aside customs demand and penalty for non-fulfilment of an Advance Authorisation export obligation is sustainable where an Export Obligation Discharge Certificate is subsequently produced in one matter but remains unproduced in another despite production of a duty-payment certificate.
Analysis: A conditional duty exemption requires production of an Export Obligation Discharge Certificate or redemption letter evidencing fulfilment of the export obligation. Where proof of an application to the DGFT for the certificate is available, customs action may be kept in abeyance pending the DGFT's decision. A duty-payment certificate is not a substitute for the Export Obligation Discharge Certificate, though it may enable the importer to seek that certificate from the DGFT.
Conclusion: Relief from demand and penalty was sustainable for the advance authorisation in respect of which the Export Obligation Discharge Certificate was produced. Such relief was not sustainable where only a duty-payment certificate had been produced and the Export Obligation Discharge Certificate remained to be obtained from the DGFT.
Issues: (i) whether interest on loans advanced to the Mauritius associated enterprise could be benchmarked on a floating LIBOR basis or required a fixed rate with appropriate spread; (ii) whether interest on overdue receivables from the associated enterprise warranted a separate transfer-pricing adjustment; (iii) whether the specified domestic transaction relating to power conversion charges and the deduction under section 80IA were correctly dealt with; (iv) whether disallowance under section 14A and its impact on book profits under section 115JB were sustainable; (v) whether depreciation claim on capitalised expenditure relating to M/s Gremach Infrastructure Equipments & Projects Ltd. was allowable; and (vi) whether the cross-objections challenging limitation under sections 153 and 144C succeeded.
Issue: whether interest on loans advanced to the Mauritius associated enterprise could be benchmarked on a floating LIBOR basis or required a fixed rate with appropriate spread.
Analysis: The loan arrangement underwent repeated amendments, enhancement of exposure, and progressive deferment of interest payment dates, with no actual interest receipt for a prolonged period. On these facts, the contractual floating-rate structure was treated as unworkable in substance, the earlier year orders were held not fully applicable, and the transaction was required to be benchmarked as a long-term, higher-risk outbound loan. Drawing guidance from safe-harbour principles, the arm's length rate was fixed at 6.5% and credit was to be given for interest already offered to tax.
Conclusion: The assessee's challenge to the floating-to-fixed benchmarking failed, and the revenue's adjustment was sustained in principle with the rate determined at 6.5%.
Issue: whether interest on overdue receivables from the associated enterprise warranted a separate transfer-pricing adjustment.
Analysis: This issue was treated as consequential to the loan-interest benchmarking. Once the loan interest was re-determined on a fixed-rate basis, no further independent interest was warranted on the same receivable stream.
Conclusion: The separate adjustment for overdue receivables was not sustained.
Issue: whether the specified domestic transaction relating to power conversion charges and the deduction under section 80IA were correctly dealt with.
Analysis: The eligible unit supplied converted power from fuel provided by the group entity and charged conversion charges. The price was compared with the rate at which power was sold to another captive user, and the legislative scheme under section 80IA(8), read with the explanation defining market value, permitted adoption of an open-market benchmark where such value was ascertainable. The Tribunal held that the assessee's method was acceptable on the facts and rejected the revenue's contention that the TPO's lower processing-cost benchmark should apply. The deduction under section 80IA for the SBU-II unit was also upheld on the basis that the claim had already been allowed in earlier years and no change in facts or law was shown.
Conclusion: The revenue's challenge to the power conversion pricing and the SBU-II deduction failed.
Issue: whether disallowance under section 14A and its impact on book profits under section 115JB were sustainable.
Analysis: For years where no exempt income was earned, no disallowance beyond the assessee's suo motu disallowance was warranted. For the years where exempt income existed, only investments yielding exempt income were to be considered for the computation. While computing book profits, the section 14A disallowance could not be imported into section 115JB computation.
Conclusion: The revenue's challenge was rejected, with the disallowance confined as directed and no section 14A addition permitted for book-profit computation.
Issue: whether depreciation claim on capitalised expenditure relating to M/s Gremach Infrastructure Equipments & Projects Ltd. was allowable.
Analysis: The Tribunal found that the expenditure had been supported by an accommodation-entry admission and that no genuine work execution was established for the relevant year. The earlier year orders were distinguished because the decisive factual material before the Tribunal now included the adverse admission by the alleged contractor's director. The capitalised amount was therefore treated as not allowable for depreciation purposes and was brought to tax.
Conclusion: The depreciation claim was disallowed and the revenue succeeded on this issue.
Issue: whether the cross-objections challenging limitation under sections 153 and 144C succeeded.
Analysis: The controversy on the inter-play between the limitation provisions and the DRP procedure was noted to be pending authoritative resolution before the Supreme Court, including in light of divergent views. In that situation, no conclusive finding on merits was recorded and the issue was left to be governed by the final pronouncement of the Supreme Court.
Conclusion: The cross-objections were dismissed.
Final Conclusion: The appeals resulted in mixed success, with the revenue substantially succeeding on the loan-interest and depreciation issues, while the assessee retained relief on certain transfer-pricing, section 80IA, and section 14A-related issues; the cross-objections were rejected.
Ratio Decidendi: Where a shareholder loan is repeatedly amended so that tenure is extended and interest payment is deferred for years, the true nature of the arrangement may be treated as a long-term high-risk transaction and benchmarked on substance rather than the original floating-rate form; open-market price may be adopted for section 80IA where such market value is otherwise ascertainable, and section 14A disallowance cannot be carried into section 115JB computation.
Issues: Whether the notice issued under section 148 was invalid for want of approval from the prescribed authority under section 151, and whether the reassessment order could survive on that basis.
Analysis: The notice under section 148 was issued after more than three years from the end of the relevant assessment year. In such a case, section 151(ii) required prior sanction from the Principal Chief Commissioner or Principal Director General or, where applicable, the Chief Commissioner or Director General. The approval was obtained only from the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, who was not the competent authority under the statutory mandate. The defect went to the root of jurisdiction and rendered the reopening invalid. Once the notice itself was void, the reassessment order passed under sections 147 and 144 could not be sustained.
Conclusion: The notice under section 148 was held invalid and void, and the reassessment order was quashed.
Issues: Whether the detention order under the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 was liable to be set aside for want of a real possibility of release on bail, alleged non-supply of relied upon materials, and violation of Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India.
Analysis: The detention order was passed with recorded awareness that the detenue was in judicial custody and that his bail application had been rejected. The detaining authority also recorded its assessment that there existed a likelihood of release and a further likelihood of prejudicial activities if released. The materials relied upon were stated to have been furnished to the detenue, including the detention order, grounds, and supporting documents, and the detenue acknowledged receipt but did not submit any representation. The Court found that the safeguards under Article 22(5) were complied with and that the subjective satisfaction was formed after consideration of relevant materials. The challenge based on alleged non-connection with the specific seizure incident was rejected in view of the finding that the detenue was involved in continuing smuggling ies.
Conclusion: The detention order was held valid and was not liable to be interfered with.
Issues: Whether a successive application for regular bail could be entertained in the absence of any fresh ground.
Analysis: The petitioner sought regular bail for an offence under Section 4 of the Prevention of Money-laundering Act, 2002. The prayer had earlier been rejected by a coordinate Bench, and the later challenge before the Apex Court had been permitted to be withdrawn. A subsequent attempt for the same relief was also rejected. In the present application, no new circumstance or fresh ground was shown, the plea being only a repetition of the earlier request and the period of custody.
Conclusion: The Court held that there was no reason to entertain the repeated bail application and dismissed it.
Ratio Decidendi: A successive bail application is not entertainable on the same material unless supported by fresh grounds or changed circumstances.
Issues: (i) whether the addition made on account of share capital received from investor companies under section 68 could be sustained on the facts found by the appellate authority, and (ii) whether the assessment was liable to be quashed for breach of the mandatory requirement of prior show-cause notice under CBDT Instruction No. 20/2015.
Issue (i): Whether the addition made on account of share capital received from investor companies under section 68 could be sustained on the facts found by the appellate authority.
Analysis: The appellate authority had examined the net worth of the investor companies, their audited balance sheets, income-tax returns and tax paid particulars, and recorded that they possessed sufficient financial capacity to invest. It also found that no notice sent by the Investigation Wing had been returned unserved and that the Assessing Officer had not made independent verification through notices under section 133(6) before treating the receipts as unexplained cash credits. On these findings, the appellate authority held that the share capital transactions were genuine and that the addition under section 68 was unwarranted.
Conclusion: The deletion of the addition under section 68 was sustained and the issue was decided in favour of the assessee.
Issue (ii): Whether the assessment was liable to be quashed for breach of the mandatory requirement of prior show-cause notice under CBDT Instruction No. 20/2015.
Analysis: The appellate authority found that no prior show-cause notice had been issued before making the impugned addition in a limited scrutiny assessment and held that the instruction required the Assessing Officer to give the assessee an opportunity to respond before making adverse additions. The Tribunal noted that the revenue had not challenged this foundational finding and agreed that non-compliance with the binding instruction constituted a violation of natural justice and rendered the assessment invalid.
Conclusion: The quashing of the assessment on this ground was upheld and the issue was decided in favour of the assessee.
Final Conclusion: The appeal failed because the challenged addition did not survive on merits and the assessment itself stood invalid on the unassailed procedural ground.
Ratio Decidendi: A binding CBDT instruction requiring prior show-cause notice before proposed additions must be complied with, and failure to do so in a limited scrutiny assessment can invalidate the assessment; where that foundational finding is not challenged, the appeal becomes unsustainable.
Issues: (i) Whether Persistent Systems Ltd. was a valid comparable and whether Akshay Software Technologies Ltd., Cigniti Technologies Ltd. and Evoke Technologies Pvt. Ltd. were required to be included as comparables; (ii) Whether the claim for foreign tax credit required verification by the Assessing Officer; (iii) Whether working capital adjustment was to be granted.
Issue (i): Whether Persistent Systems Ltd. was a valid comparable and whether Akshay Software Technologies Ltd., Cigniti Technologies Ltd. and Evoke Technologies Pvt. Ltd. were required to be included as comparables.
Analysis: Persistent Systems Ltd. was found to operate as an entrepreneurial, IP-driven product development entity engaged in outsourced product development, technology innovation, licensing and royalty-based activities, with no reliable segmental break-up isolating pure software development services. This functional profile, risk structure and absence of segmental data made it incomparable with a captive software development service provider under TNMM. Akshay Software Technologies Ltd. was held comparable because its revenue was overwhelmingly from software services, it satisfied the relevant filters, and its activities were substantially in software development and related services. Cigniti Technologies Ltd. was held comparable because software testing forms part of the software development life cycle and the company's revenue was entirely from software-related services. Evoke Technologies Pvt. Ltd. was also held comparable because reliable financial data was available and it was engaged exclusively in software development services.
Conclusion: Persistent Systems Ltd. was directed to be excluded and Akshay Software Technologies Ltd., Cigniti Technologies Ltd. and Evoke Technologies Pvt. Ltd. were directed to be included; the assessee succeeded on this issue.
Issue (ii): Whether the claim for foreign tax credit required verification by the Assessing Officer.
Analysis: The entitlement to foreign tax credit depended on verification of supporting evidence, including proof of foreign tax payment, corresponding income offered to tax in India and the prescribed declaration. The matter therefore required factual examination by the Assessing Officer before credit could be granted.
Conclusion: The issue was remitted for verification and the assessee obtained relief subject to such verification.
Issue (iii): Whether working capital adjustment was to be granted.
Analysis: The record showed that the adjustment had been accepted in principle and no objection was raised to its grant after verification. The adjustment was therefore required to be carried out in accordance with law.
Conclusion: Working capital adjustment was directed to be allowed after necessary verification; the assessee succeeded on this issue.
Final Conclusion: The appeals were disposed of by granting partial relief to the assessee, principally on comparables, foreign tax credit verification and working capital adjustment, while other grounds were either withdrawn, not pressed or not adjudicated.
Ratio Decidendi: A captive software development service provider cannot be benchmarked against an IP-driven product development company without segmental data, and adjustments such as foreign tax credit and working capital require factual verification before final allowance.
Issues: (i) whether the disallowance of employees' contribution to provident fund was sustainable in part; (ii) whether the addition to book profit under section 115JB on account of withdrawal from reserves was justified; (iii) whether the assessee was entitled to a direction for verification of brought forward business losses and unabsorbed depreciation; and (iv) whether the deletion of the addition relating to extraordinary items was justified.
Issue (i): whether the disallowance of employees' contribution to provident fund was sustainable in part.
Analysis: The factual record showed that only a part of the disputed amount related to delayed remittance, while the balance was found to have been deposited within the due date. The delayed remittances were held to be inadmissible in view of the governing law on employees' contribution and the Supreme Court ruling referred to in the order.
Conclusion: The disallowance was sustained only to the extent of the delayed amount and the balance was deleted, resulting in no relief to the assessee on the sustained portion.
Issue (ii): whether the addition to book profit under section 115JB on account of withdrawal from reserves was justified.
Analysis: The matter turned on whether the amount withdrawn from reserves had been credited to the profit and loss account and consequently included in the net profit for the year. The assessee failed to furnish the material required to demonstrate compliance with the earlier direction for verification, and the statutory scheme of section 115JB required the relevant credit to be established before reduction could be allowed.
Conclusion: The addition to book profit was not deleted and the matter was left to verification by the Assessing Officer, with the assessee's ground being allowed only for statistical purposes.
Issue (iii): whether the assessee was entitled to a direction for verification of brought forward business losses and unabsorbed depreciation.
Analysis: The claim was not part of the original set-aside proceedings and arose for the first time in the second round. The appellate authority nevertheless directed verification in the interest of justice, and the Tribunal found that course to be fair and lawful, causing no prejudice to the assessee.
Conclusion: The direction for verification was upheld and the assessee's ground was rejected.
Issue (iv): whether the deletion of the addition relating to extraordinary items was justified.
Analysis: The record showed that the assessee had filed material and a reply before the revenue authorities, and the appellate authority accepted that reasonable opportunity had not been effectively afforded in the set-aside proceedings. On merits also, the deletion was found sustainable.
Conclusion: The deletion of the addition was upheld and the Revenue's ground failed.
Final Conclusion: The appeal of the assessee succeeded only in part and for statistical purposes on the MAT issue, while the Revenue's appeal failed. The net result was a limited relief to the assessee with the remaining findings maintained.
Ratio Decidendi: Where the assessee seeks a reduction or deletion under section 115JB, the relevant credit to the profit and loss account must be established on evidence; delayed employees' contribution remains disallowable; and a reasoned verification direction on brought forward losses and unabsorbed depreciation can be sustained when made in the interest of justice.
Issues: Whether the receipt of Rs. 40,01,107/- from entities controlled by an accommodation-entry provider could be treated as unexplained cash credit/accommodation entry and whether the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) was correct in restricting the Assessing Officer's addition to Rs. 2,00,055/- by estimating profit at 5% instead of confirming the full addition.
Analysis: The assessee did not dispute receipt of Rs. 40,01,107/- from the entities identified with the entry-provider but stated that the amounts were sale proceeds of goods sold to third parties; documentary records including ledgers and bank statements were produced. The Assessing Officer relied on the third-party search and found discrepancies between ledgers and bank entries but did not obtain corroborative evidence from the parties to whom sales were allegedly made or from the payors. The appellate authority examined the ledger-bank reconciliation, accepted explanations showing timing/clerical reasons for apparent mismatches, found no evidence of cash withdrawals or a cash trail to substantiate that cheques were converted into cash for accommodation, and held that acceptance of sales as income precluded treating the same receipts as unexplained credits without further proof. As a precautionary measure to guard revenue, the appellate authority estimated a reasonable profit at 5% on the transactions routed through the entities controlled by the entry-provider; that estimation was upheld for limited addition.
Conclusion: The Assessing Officer's full addition was not sustained; the finding and order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) restricting the addition to Rs. 2,00,055/- (by estimating profit at 5%) is upheld and the Revenue's appeal is dismissed in favour of the assessee.
Issues: (i) Whether the applicant is eligible to avail input tax credit (ITC) of GST paid on works contract services for construction of the breakwater wall adjacent to its jetty.
Analysis: The Authority examined the factual scope of the contract (composite works contract by Larsen & Toubro) and the statutory scheme in Section 17(5) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 which blocks ITC for works contract services supplied for construction of immovable property (other than plant and machinery). The Authority reviewed the definition of "plant and machinery" in the Explanation to Section 17(6), the distinction between "plant and machinery" and "plant or machinery" as addressed by the Supreme Court, and the subsequent retrospective legislative amendment (Section 124 of the Finance Act, 2025 and Notification No. 16/2025-Central Tax dated 17.09.2025) which substituted "plant and machinery" into clause (d) and introduced Explanation 2. The technical record (Engineers India Ltd. report) and contract scope show the breakwater as an integrated, permanently embedded civil structure composed of core, armour and accropodes, constructed on the seabed and functioning collectively to dissipate wave energy. The Authority found the services obtained were works contract services for construction of an immovable civil structure; individual constituent items (rocks, accropodes) lose separate character once integrated into the permanent structure. The Authority further considered invoice non compliance (absence of requisite SAC/HSN digits under Rule 46) and the time limit for claiming ITC under Section 16(4). The Authority also declined to answer the question on classification of the contractor's supply under Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) because a ruling on that point would affect rights of the supplier who is not a party to the AAR proceeding.
Conclusion: The applicant is not eligible to avail input tax credit of GST paid on the works contract services for construction of the breakwater wall; no ruling is given on the contractor's classification under Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate).
Issues: (i) Whether the refund claim filed on 24.03.2015 is time-barred for clearances of Jan-2014 and Feb-2014 and whether the refund for March-2014 is maintainable; (ii) Whether the appellant can re-open or challenge the question of dutiability/self-assessment and relevant-date determinations made in the earlier Commissioner (Appeals) order dated 26.03.2019 (res judicata/appealability issue).
Issue (i): Whether the refund claim is time-barred for Jan-2014 and Feb-2014 and whether refund for Mar-2014 is allowable.
Analysis: The Tribunal considered the dates of filing ER-1 returns and statutory payment deadlines under Rule 8(1) and the explanations to Section 11B of the Central Excise Act, 1944. The Commissioner (Appeals) had determined the date of filing as 24.03.2015 (electronic filing) and held that for the clearances in Jan-2014 and Feb-2014 the one-year limitation expired before that date, whereas the claim portion for March-2014 fell within one year of the relevant payment date. The adjudicating authority on remand examined ER-1 filing dates and last dates for refund claims and allowed the March-2014 portion while rejecting Jan-2014 and Feb-2014 portions as time-barred.
Conclusion: Partly in favour of Appellant (refund for March-2014 of Rs.38,24,252 upheld; refunds for Jan-2014 and Feb-2014 barred by limitation).
Issue (ii): Whether the appellant may re-agitate or challenge final assessment/self-assessment and the related findings on relevant date despite the Commissioner (Appeals) order dated 26.03.2019.
Analysis: The Tribunal examined the Commissioner (Appeals) order which had held that the issue of rate of duty was not part of the provisional/final assessment and therefore the relevant date for the refund was the date of payment; that order was not appealed by either party and thereby attained finality for purposes of the remand proceedings. The Tribunal applied principles of res judicata, constructive res judicata and related precedents to conclude that issues finally decided in the earlier appellate order could not be reopened in the present appeal. The Tribunal therefore declined to entertain arguments contrary to the Commissioner (Appeals) findings and held that the appellant was barred from re litigating those points.
Conclusion: In favour of Respondent (appellant barred from re-agitating the earlier findings; issues on dutiability/self-assessment and relevant-date determination stand final).
Final Conclusion: The appeal lacks merit and is dismissed; the refund claim is allowed only to the extent of the March-2014 portion while other portions are time-barred, and the appellant cannot reopen issues conclusively decided by the Commissioner (Appeals) dated 26.03.2019.
Ratio Decidendi: Where an appellate order on legal and factual issues attains finality because it is unchallenged, parties are barred by res judicata from re litigating those issues in subsequent proceedings; refund claims must be adjudicated having regard to the statutory relevant date under Section 11B of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and limitation is to be computed accordingly.
Issues: Whether the appellant is entitled to refund of service tax, interest and penalty paid voluntarily during departmental inquiry for FY 2014-15 and 2015-16, or whether the voluntary payment and intimation under Section 73(3) of the Finance Act, 1994 concludes proceedings and precludes refund.
Analysis: The issue is governed by Section 73(3) of the Finance Act, 1994 which permits a person to pay service tax on his own ascertainment and inform the Central Excise Officer, and provides that on receipt of such information no notice under subsection (1) shall be served in respect of the amount so paid; the proviso preserves the officer's right to determine any short payment and recover it with the limitation period counted from receipt of the information. The appellant paid service tax with interest and penalty during the course of an inquiry and informed the department seeking closure under Section 73(3) and relying on departmental instructions. Prior Tribunal precedent was applied to hold that once proceedings are concluded by voluntary payment and intimation under Section 73(3), the issue stands closed, the department cannot issue a notice in respect of the amount so paid, and the assessee cannot later seek refund of that amount. The appellant's reliance on the Delhi High Court decision cited was found factually distinguishable and inapplicable.
Conclusion: The voluntary payment and intimation under Section 73(3) concludes the proceedings and precludes the refund claim; appeal dismissed. (In favour of Revenue)
Issues: Whether the impugned GST assessment orders require fresh adjudication because the petitioners contentions about alleged transcription errors in GSTR-09 and supporting documents were not dealt with by the assessing authority.
Analysis: The assessment orders for the tax periods (except 20222023) do not refer to or deal with the petitioners replies and additional submissions which assert that Input Tax Credit was misstated due to transcription between 'inputs' and 'input services' in Form GSTR-09. The petitioners filings and the annual returns prima facie indicate a possible mistake that warrants detailed consideration. Given the substantial disputed amounts and incomplete adjudication of the petitioners explanations and documents, the matter requires reconsideration on merits with opportunity to furnish all invoices, GSTR-2A, GSTR-2B, GSTR-3B and complete e-way bills and transport documents. The Court conditions de novo adjudication on the petitioner paying specified costs and furnishing proof of compliance, and provides consequential directions regarding lifting of attachment upon compliance.
Conclusion: The assessment orders are set aside and the matters are remitted to the assessing authority for de novo adjudication after the petitioner complies with stipulated conditions including payment of costs and submission of full documentary proof; on compliance the assessing authority shall decide the cases on merits and the bank account attachment shall be lifted.
Issues: (i) Whether the assessment order and appellate rejection should be set aside and the matter remitted for fresh consideration; (ii) Whether the attachment of the bank account should be vacated subject to conditions including pre-deposit.
Issue (i): Whether the assessment order and the appellate order rejecting the appeal on limitation grounds should be set aside and remitted for fresh consideration.
Analysis: The Court examined the adequacy of the petitioner's reply to the show cause notice, the respondent's duty to record proper findings and, if necessary, call the petitioner for personal hearing, and the sequence of rectification and appeal proceedings. Balancing the interests of both sides, the Court found that the respondents should be directed to redo the exercise afresh on merits, subject to compliance by the petitioner with an additional pre-deposit requirement.
Conclusion: The Court remitted the matter for fresh consideration and re-adjudication on merits, subject to the petitioner making an additional pre-deposit. This conclusion is partly in favour of the Assessee.
Issue (ii): Whether the bank account attachment should be lifted upon compliance with stipulated conditions including the additional pre-deposit.
Analysis: The Court considered the petitioner's prior pre-deposit and the effect of further deposit on ongoing recovery measures. The Court ordered that upon deposit of the stipulated additional amount and subject to verification that no other arrears exist, the attachment shall stand vacated and any amounts already recovered may be adjusted towards the pre-deposit.
Conclusion: The Court ordered vacation of the bank attachment conditional on the petitioner complying with the deposit and verification requirements. This conclusion is in favour of the Assessee.
Final Conclusion: The writ petition is disposed by remitting the matter to the assessing authority for fresh adjudication on merits, subject to the petitioner making the additional pre-deposit and complying with the stipulated conditions; overall the decision is partly in favour of the Assessee.
Ratio Decidendi: Where an assessment and appellate order are challenged on adequacy of consideration and hearing, a court may remit the matter for fresh consideration on merits while protecting revenue recovery by conditioning relief on a specified pre-deposit and verification, and ordering suspension of recovery measures upon compliance.
Issues: Whether, in respect of invoices/debit notes pertaining to financial years 2017-18 to 2020-21, the petitioner is entitled to avail Input Tax Credit notwithstanding belated claim under the time-limit in Section 16(4), in view of Sections 16(5) and 16(6) inserted by Finance Act (No.2), 2024, and whether the impugned ex parte order confirming demand should be quashed and remitted for fresh adjudication.
Analysis: The Court examined the effect of the statutory amendments introduced by Finance Act (No.2), 2024 which inserted subsections 16(5) and 16(6) into Section 16 of the GST enactments and operate with retrospective effect from 01.07.2017 for the relevant financial years. The amendments prescribe a specific entitlement to take input tax credit in returns filed up to 30 November 2021 for invoices/debit notes pertaining to FY 2017-18 to 2020-21 and provide rules for cases where registration cancellation is revoked. The Court held that where the petitioner satisfies the other requirements of Section 16, the entitlement to claim ITC under the newly inserted provisions arises even if rectification applications were not filed in terms of the earlier interpretation of Section 16(6). Applying these provisions, the Court found that the portion of the demand relating to belated availment of ITC is governed by the statutory intervention and therefore cannot survive without fresh consideration on merits. The Court therefore quashed the impugned ex parte order insofar as it relates to ITC and remitted the matter to the respondent for fresh adjudication, subject to the petitioner depositing specified amounts (penalty for belated filing of annual return, amounts for belated monthly returns and non-submission of documents) within 30 days and filing a proper reply to be treated as rectification for the purposes of Sections 16(5) and 16(6).
Conclusion: The petitioner is entitled to avail Input Tax Credit in respect of invoices/debit notes pertaining to FY 2017-18 to 2020-21 if the other statutory requirements of Section 16 are satisfied; the impugned order is quashed insofar as it relates to ITC and the matter is remitted to the respondent for fresh orders. The decision is in favour of the assessee on the ITC issue and otherwise the petition is disposed of subject to the deposit and procedural conditions imposed.
Issues: Whether the GST paid on supply, installation, testing and commissioning of the fire-fighting system and public health engineering for expansion/commissioning of a new factory is eligible as Input Tax Credit or is blocked under Section 17(5)(c) and (d) of the CGST/TNGST Acts; and whether the secondary question on timeline to avail ITC on the advance component requires separate adjudication.
Analysis: The Appellant sought ITC contending the installations constitute "plant and machinery" (apparatus, equipment or machinery) used for making outward supply and/or are movable. The provisions governing entitlement and restrictionsSection 16(1) (entitlement subject to conditions and restrictions) and Section 17(5)(c) & (d) (blocking ITC on works contract services and goods/services for construction of immovable property other than plant and machinery)and the definition of "plant and machinery" (apparatus, equipment and machinery fixed to earth by foundation or structural support and used for making outward supply) are determinative. The contractual scope ('deliver the Permanent Work to the owner') and the cost-abstract show a composite works contract for supply and installation integrated into the factory infrastructure. Applying established tests (nature/object of annexation, intention of parties, functionality, permanency and marketability), the Authority finds the installations become assimilated into the building and serve permanent beneficial enjoyment of the immovable property; several components are tailor-made and not marketable independently. Even where items may be detachable physically, the contract and the manner of integration indicate they form part of immovable property and are not "plant and machinery" for the purposes of Section 17. Given this conclusion, the ITC is blocked under clauses (c) and (d) of Section 17(5). As the primary query is answered against ITC eligibility, the question on timeline for availing ITC on the advance component is rendered academic and need not be answered.
Conclusion: The GST paid on supply, installation, testing and commissioning of the fire-fighting system and public health engineering for the new factory is not eligible as Input Tax Credit and is blocked by Section 17(5)(c) and 17(5)(d) of the CGST/TNGST Acts; appeal dismissed (in favour of Revenue).
Issues: (i) Whether Input Tax Credit (ITC) is eligible on electrical works carried out for expansion of factory for manufacturing activity; (ii) Whether and on what basis the timeline arises to avail ITC on tax invoice raised by supplier to bill the 'advance component' of the contract and subsequent adjustment in service bills.
Issue (i): Whether the electrical installation works (including LT panels, busducts, LT electrical works, lightning protection, light fixtures and associated civil works) qualify as 'plant and machinery' or otherwise fall outside the scope of blocked credits under Section 17(5)(c) and 17(5)(d) of the CGST/TNGST Acts, thereby permitting availment of ITC.
Analysis: The Authority examined the statutory entitlement under Section 16(1) and the blocking provisions in Section 17(5) including the Explanation defining 'plant and machinery'. It analysed the contractual terms (including delivery of 'permanent work'), the nature and purpose of annexation, and applied judicial tests (nature of annexation, object of annexation, intendment of parties, functionality, permanency and marketability). The Authority considered submissions and comparative rulings and distinguished cases where items directly related to transmission or outward supply were held to be plant and machinery. It concluded that the electrical installation as a whole and its components do not constitute equipment, machinery or an 'apparatus' as contemplated in the Explanation, that the object and intendment indicate permanent beneficial enjoyment by the immovable property, and that the items lack independent marketability or independent functional existence in the instant facts.
Conclusion: ITC on the electrical installation works for the new factory is not eligible and is blocked under Sections 17(5)(c) and 17(5)(d) of the CGST/TNGST Acts; the AAR ruling disallowing ITC is upheld in favour of the Revenue.
Issue (ii): Whether the timeline to avail ITC on the 'advance component' billed by the supplier requires determination given the contract and invoices in question.
Analysis: The Authority treated the timeline issue as subordinate to the primary question of ITC eligibility. Having held that ITC on the contract is not available on merits, the factual and temporal question regarding the treatment of advance invoices and subsequent adjustments becomes moot in the context of this contract.
Conclusion: The question on the timeline to avail ITC on the 'advance component' does not arise and is not answered because the main query on ITC availability has been answered in the negative.
Final Conclusion: The Advance Ruling No.32/ARA/2025 dated 18.08.2025 is upheld and the appeal is dismissed; the electrical installation works in the facts of this case form part of immovable property and ITC thereon is blocked under Section 17(5)(c) and 17(5)(d).
Ratio Decidendi: Where electrical installations cease to have independent existence, are intended for permanent beneficial enjoyment of the immovable property, and do not satisfy the Explanation to Section 17 as 'plant and machinery' (apparatus, equipment or machinery fixed to earth and used for making outward supply), the ITC on such supplies is blocked under Sections 17(5)(c) and 17(5)(d) of the CGST Act, 2017.
Note
Bookmark
Share
Download
Don't have an account? Register Here
TaxTMI