AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Issues: (i) Whether the pre-shipment inspection certificate remained valid when the inspection was conducted at Duisburg, Germany, while the bill of lading mentioned Antwerp, Belgium as the port of loading; (ii) Whether the imported goods were liable to confiscation under Section 111(d) of the Customs Act, 1962; (iii) Whether redemption fine and penalty were imposable in the facts of the case.
Issue (i): Whether the pre-shipment inspection certificate remained valid when the inspection was conducted at Duisburg, Germany, while the bill of lading mentioned Antwerp, Belgium as the port of loading.
Analysis: The governing requirement under the foreign trade framework was that the importer furnish a pre-shipment inspection certificate from a DGFT-approved agency certifying that the consignment did not contain arms, ammunition, mines, shells, cartridges or any other explosive material, and that radiation levels were within natural background. The record showed that the certificate was issued by an approved agency, the goods were later subjected to 100% examination, and the post-shipment inspection confirmed that the consignment was non-hazardous, non-radioactive and within acceptable radiation limits. No provision was shown to require that inspection must necessarily be conducted only at the port of loading.
Conclusion: The certificate was held to be valid for the purpose of clearance, and the objection based only on the inland place of inspection was rejected.
Issue (ii): Whether the imported goods were liable to confiscation under Section 111(d) of the Customs Act, 1962.
Analysis: Confiscation under the customs law requires a real prohibition or improper importation. Here, the post-shipment inspection and physical examination established that the consignment was safe, non-hazardous and non-radioactive, and that the description and quantity matched the declaration. The only objection was a perceived procedural irregularity in the pre-shipment certificate, which did not convert the import into prohibited importation.
Conclusion: The goods were held not liable to confiscation under Section 111(d) of the Customs Act, 1962.
Issue (iii): Whether redemption fine and penalty were imposable in the facts of the case.
Analysis: Once confiscation was found unsustainable, the basis for redemption fine ceased to exist. Likewise, penalty under Section 112(a)(i) could not survive where the alleged infraction was only procedural and the consignment itself satisfied the substantive safety requirements. The case cited by the Revenue was distinguished on facts because the present certificate was genuine and the post-import verification supported it.
Conclusion: Redemption fine and penalty were held not imposable and were set aside.
Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded, the confiscation and penalty were annulled, and the consignment was directed to be released on payment of applicable customs duty.
Ratio Decidendi: A procedural irregularity in the pre-shipment inspection certificate does not justify confiscation or penalty where the imported consignment is otherwise found by examination and inspection to be non-hazardous, non-radioactive, and compliant with the substantive import conditions.
Pre-shipment inspection irregularity alone cannot trigger confiscation when the consignment is otherwise found safe and compliant.
A procedural irregularity in the pre-shipment inspection certificate did not justify confiscation where the certificate was issued by an approved agency and subsequent examination confirmed that the consignment was non-hazardous, non-radioactive and compliant with the substantive import conditions. The objection that inspection was conducted at an inland location rather than the port of loading was rejected because no rule required inspection only at the loading port. As the import was not shown to be prohibited, confiscation under the Customs Act was unsustainable, and redemption fine and penalty could not survive once the substantive compliance was established.
Validity of Pre-Shipment Inspection Certificate (PSIC) issued by a DGFT approved Pre-Shipment Inspection Agency (PSIA) certifying that the imported Low Nickel Turning Scrap does not contain radiation levels in excess of natural background - inspection was conducted at Duisburg, Germany (an inland port and logistics hub) whereas the Port of Loading mentioned in the Bill of Lading is Antwerp, Belgium (the nearest seaport) - Confiscation - redemption fine - penalty - HELD THAT:- From the facts of the case, we observe that the appellant filed the Bill of Entry No. 4490495 dated 13.09.2025 for import of the goods in question. The Bill of Entry was RMS facilitated and no examination was prescribed. However, while checking the uploaded documents in e-sanchit for the pre-shipment cft vide cft no.psicmelxxx517038am86, the assessing officer found that the ‘country of inspection’ and ‘port of shipment’ were not matching. The assessing officer was of the opinion that the Pre-Shipment Inspection Certificate submitted by the appellant was not valid for importation of the said goods, as it was not issued at the country of origin where the Inspection took place. Accordingly, the assessing officer ordered a First-check (100% examination) of the subject goods, which was carried out in the presence of a PSIA at the Port of Discharge. It is clear that the consignment does not contain any type of arms, ammunition, mines, shells, cartridges or any other explosive material in any form. It is apparent that the radiation levels were also found to be within the acceptable limits. There was no discrepancy found in the description of the goods. Confiscation of goods - HELD THAT:- Thus, it is found that the Post Shipment Inspection Certificate confirms that the goods meet all the prescribed parameters and requirements under Para 2.51 of HBP, 2023. In this regard, it is pertinent to note that the very purpose and objective of the PSIC requirement is to ensure that the imported metallic scrap does not contain hazardous, radioactive or explosive materials which could pose a threat to public health and safety. This purpose has been fully achieved and satisfied in the present case. When all the parameters as required under Para 2.51 of HBP, 2023 stand fulfilled, it is observed that the goods cannot be held as liable for confiscation. Redemption fine - HELD THAT:- It is observed that various Courts and Tribunals have taken a consistent view that where Post-Shipment Inspection has been conducted and goods have been found to be in order and meeting the prescribed parameters without there being any incriminating or prohibited materials, then any procedural deficiency in the PSIC does not warrant confiscation of goods or imposition of redemption fine and penalty. In the present case, it is found that the Post-Shipment Inspection has conclusively established that the goods are safe, non-hazardous and non-radioactive - confiscation of the goods as ordered vide the impugned order is not sustainable and hence, the same is set aside. As the goods are not liable for confiscation, the question of imposition of redemption fine does not arise and hence, the redemption fine imposed in the impugned order stands set aside as well. Penalty - HELD THAT:- As the procedural deficiency, if any, in the PSIC submitted by the appellant cannot be construed as a ‘violation’ amounting to importation of 'prohibited goods' warranting confiscation, we hold that such deficiency does not warrant imposition of penalty under Section 112(a)(i) of the Customs Act, 1962. Accordingly, the penalty imposed on the appellant is not sustainable. Consequently, the penalty imposed under Section 112(a)(i) of the Act is set aside. Conclusion - i) When all the parameters as required under Para 2.51 of HBP, 2023 stand fulfilled, it is observed that the goods cannot be held as liable for confiscation. Consequently, the redemption fine imposed on the appellant in lieu of the same also stands set aside. ii) The penalty of Rs.15,00,000/- imposed on the appellant under Section 112(a)(i) of the Customs Act, 1962 is set aside. iii) The Revenue is directed to release the consignment with immediate effect, subject to payment of appropriate duties of customs, as payable. Appeal allowed.