AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Issues: (i) Whether assessment under section 153A was valid in absence of incriminating material for unabated years; (ii) Whether the amount of 'on-money' receipts detected in search should be added in full or only the profit element (percentage) of such receipts; (iii) Whether provision for interest on late payment of service tax (provision for contingency) was correctly disallowed; (iv) Whether alleged bogus purchases should be added back by reducing Work-in-Progress (WIP) for the assessment year; (v) Whether the transfer pricing adjustment on interest paid to Associated Enterprise (CCD interest) was correctly deleted by the CIT(A) or rightly sustained by AO/TPO.
Issue (i): Validity of assessment under section 153A where incriminating material for unabated year is contested.
Analysis: The appellate record and seized documents show incriminating material specific to the assessee (details in seized Annexure) relied upon by AO; Supreme Court authority distinguishing failure of assessments where no incriminating material is found was considered but facts here differ as material was found in search. Bench examined precedents distinguishing normal and search assessments and applicability of centralization instructions.
Conclusion: Decision in favour of Revenue.
Issue (ii): Quantum of addition for 'on-money' cash receipts full receipt vs. profit element percentage.
Analysis: CIT(A) applied established practice and precedent taking the net income element embedded in on-money receipts rather than entire gross receipts, referencing group/ITSC outcomes and Gujarat High Court authority which support estimation of profit element; comparative decisions confirming 15% as reasonable guiding figure in group cases were considered and found applicable on facts.
Conclusion: Decision in favour of Assessee.
Issue (iii): Disallowance of provision for interest on late payment of service tax as contingent.
Analysis: Records show provision was an ascertained liability and partly paid in the relevant year with remaining balance written back in subsequent year; authorities on compensatory nature of interest were applied to classify the provision as allowable expense.
Conclusion: Decision in favour of Assessee.
Issue (iv): Treatment of admitted bogus purchases and reduction from WIP for the assessment year.
Analysis: Director's recorded admission of bogus purchases and absence of documentary evidence from assessee to prove genuineness meant onus was not discharged; coordinate and higher court precedents distinguishing cases where supporting evidence existed were considered and found not to assist assessee.
Conclusion: Decision in favour of Revenue.
Issue (v): Transfer pricing adjustment on interest paid on CCDs appropriateness of SBI PLR +75 bps (TPO) v. SBI PLR +300 bps (CIT(A)) and invocation of tolerance band under section 92C(2).
Analysis: Bench found assessee's CUP benchmarking based on foreign industrial yields was not functionally comparable or representative of INR-denominated CCDs; judicial precedents relied upon by assessee were fact-specific and not universally binding; AO/TPO's domestic-market based approach with a 75 bps risk adjustment was held to be factually supported and more appropriate than mechanical application of 300 bps benchmark or automatic invocation of tolerance band where comparability is unreliable.
Conclusion: Decision in favour of Revenue.
Final Conclusion: The Tribunal upheld revenue's transfer pricing adjustment and certain other AO findings while sustaining the CIT(A)'s reductions in respect of on-money receipts and the provision for interest; overall, the revenue appeals are partly allowed and the assessee's cross-objections are dismissed, producing a mixed result with substantive determinations on jurisdiction, profit estimation for on-money receipts, contingency provision treatment, bogus purchases treatment, and TP benchmarking.
Pecuniary jurisdiction and search assessments clarified; incriminating material supports additions while TP and bogus purchase tests refined
Pecuniary jurisdiction has no application to search assessments because such assessments are not assigned by pecuniary limits; therefore jurisdictional objections to a search assessment fail. Where incriminating material is found during search, additions based on that material are sustain able; thus part of assessment under section 153A was upheld. Treating gross sale proceeds as taxable additions is impermissible when those receipts embed gross profit; only the profit element may be added, and the appellate finding to that effect is sustained. Provisions for interest on delayed service tax payments are compensatory and allowable where paid or written back. Bogus purchases require the assessee to discharge the primary onus of genuineness; absent evidence, additions stand. Transfer pricing: an unreliable single foreign comparable fails CUP scrutiny and ALP; domestic SBI PLR plus risk adjustment upheld.
Pecuniary jurisdiction of assessing officer u/s 153A in search case Jurisdiction to be exercised by ITO or DCIT - CBDT Instruction No.1/2011 - (application U/R 27 of Income Tax(Appellate Tribunal) Rule, 1963 on dated 02/11/2023) - HELD THAT:- In search and seizure cases, the concept of pecuniary jurisdiction has no application, as search assessments are not assigned to any Income-tax Officer. The lowest authority empowered to complete a search assessment is the Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax or Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax. We note that in Chaudhury Skin Trading Company & Ors. [2016 (11) TMI 540 - DELHI HIGH COURT] and Kamlesh Rajnikant Shah [2022 (5) TMI 114 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT] have clearly distinguished between jurisdiction applicable in normal assessments and jurisdiction applicable in search assessments. In view of these binding judicial precedents, the CBDT Instruction relied upon by the assessee is not relevant for determining jurisdiction in search-related assessments. The Ld. AR has further placed reliance on the decisions in Shree Shoppers Ltd. [2023 (3) TMI 1432 - CALCUTTA HIGH COURT] and Ashok D. Jain [2022 (3) TMI 1466 - BOMBAY HIGH COURT]. However, both these decisions pertain to issues arising in non-search assessments and are, therefore, not applicable to the present controversy. In light of the above discussion, we find no merit in the jurisdictional objection raised by the assessee. Assessment u/s 153A - incriminating material was found during the search - HELD THAT:- The reliance placed by the Ld. AR on Abhisar Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. [2023 (4) TMI 1056 - SUPREME COURT] is noted wherein held that where no incriminating material is unearthed during a search in respect of an unabated assessment, no addition can be sustained, and the entire assessment must fail. However, the facts of the present case are materially distinguishable. Here, incriminating material was indeed found during the search, and a part of the addition has been made on the basis of such material. Decided against revenue. Addition of 100% of the on-money amount u/s 69 on sale of shop - CIT(A) observed the only the profit percentage will be applicable for addition - HELD THAT:- As relying on the judgment of Panna Corporation [2014 (11) TMI 797 - GUJARAT HIGH COURT] the Ld. CIT(A) has correctly observed that the gross receipts are embedded with the gross profit element. Therefore, when the amount in question is treated as part of sales, the entire gross receipt cannot be added back to the total income. In this factual backdrop, the order relied upon by the Ld. DR in Ali Akbar Samai Choudhury [2024 (5) TMI 1658 - ITAT MUMBAI] is clearly distinguishable and does not apply to the present case. Accordingly, we uphold the findings of the Ld. CIT(A), and the ground raised by the revenue stands dismissed. Interest on late payment of service tax - provision for contingency - CIT(A) deleted the addition - HELD THAT:- We find that the said issue related to the provision is not a contingent liability. The provision was created by the assessee in respect of interest on delayed payment of service tax. The said provision was made as per the requirement of the service tax Act and it is also submitted that out of provision of Rs. 11,34,400/-, the amount of Rss.11,01,353/- was paid in FY 2013-14 and the balance amount of Rs. 22,047/- was written back and credited to P&L Account in FY 2013-14 relevant to A.Y. 2014-15. So considering this, relying on the order of Laxmandas Mathura [1997 (12) TMI 16 - SUPREME COURT] the expenses is in compensatory in nature. The view taken by the Ld.CIT(A) is upheld. Bogus purchases - primary onus to establish the genuineness of the purchases - HELD THAT:- Assessee has accepted the fact of bogus purchases and has never retracted such admission before any of the authorities below. Moreover, during the assessment proceedings, the assessee failed to furnish any documentary evidence to substantiate the genuineness of the impugned purchases. Thus, the primary onus to establish the genuineness of the purchases has not been discharged. Consequently, the reliance placed on the orders of the co-ordinate benches is misplaced. We respectfully rely on the decision in Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. [2025 (3) TMI 230 - BOMBAY HIGH COURT] find no infirmity in the findings of the Ld. CIT(A), and therefore no interference is warranted. TP adjustment - interest on CCDs issued to the AE - assessee issued fully compulsorily convertible debentures (CCDs) to its AE in earlier years and paid interest at 19.17% - HELD THAT:- We find that the assessee has relied upon a single comparable, drawn from foreign industrial yield data, which is neither functionally comparable nor representative of lending conditions prevailing in the Indian market where the CCDs were denominated and serviced. Assessee’s benchmarking suffers from inherent defects and cannot be regarded as a reliable CUP under Rule 10B. Consequently, the tolerance range u/s 92C(2) cannot be invoked mechanically in a situation where the very determination of ALP is unsupported by credible comparables. Judicial precedents relied upon by the assessee, including Granite Gate Properties Pvt. Ltd. [2019 (3) TMI 1805 - ITAT DELHI] and subsequent orders, are fact-specific and pertained to foreign-currency FCCDs or materially different commercial circumstances. These decisions do not lay down a universal benchmark of SBI PLR + 300 basis points, nor do they assist the assessee in the present INR denominated CCD transaction. The reliance on these judgments is therefore misplaced. On the contrary, the Ld. TPO’s approach of adopting SBI PLR with an appropriate 75-basis-point risk adjustment is grounded in domestic financial realities, reflects borrower-specific credit considerations, and conforms to the arm’s-length principle. Accordingly, we uphold the transfer pricing adjustment made by the Ld. AO/TPO, and set aside the contrary findings of the Ld. CIT(A).