Taxpayer Wins Major Tax Credit Battle: Full ITC Refund Ordered with Immediate Unblocking of Rs. 81.68 Lakh

Court ruled in favor of petitioner by directing unblocking of Input Tax Credit (ITC) amounting to Rs.81,68,812. HC ordered respondents to refund the blocked amount and not pass assessment order until ITC is unblocked. The court considered legal remedies under CGST Act and found the account blocking unjustified, effectively settling the primary dispute through its September 2022 order.

---

---

Issues:
1. Unblocking of Input Tax Credit and refund sought by Petitioner.
2. Quashing of impugned orders.
3. Waiver of late fee and interest for non-filing of returns.
4. Direction to not pass assessment order until Input Tax Credit is unblocked.
5. Implications of the order dated 13 September 2022.
6. Consideration of legal remedies under Section 73/74 of the CGST Act.
7. Examination of the implications of the unblocking of the account.
8. Disposition of the writ petition.

Analysis:
1. The Petitioner sought the unblocking of Input Tax Credit amounting to Rs.81,68,812 and refund, along with the quashing of impugned orders. The Court directed Respondent No.3 to unblock the Input Tax Credit account and refund the amount. The Petitioner also requested the waiver of late fees and interest for non-filing of returns, which was considered in the detailed order passed on 12 December 2022.

2. The Court addressed the issue of quashing impugned orders as per the Petitioner's prayers. The Respondents were directed not to pass the assessment order until the Input Tax Credit amount was unblocked and refunded to the Petitioner.

3. The Court discussed the implications of the order dated 13 September 2022, which directed the unblocking of the Input Tax Credit account. The Respondents filed a reply stating that the ledger account was unblocked, and the Petitioner utilized the Input Tax Credit. The Court considered the actions taken after the unblocking and filing of returns by the Petitioner.

4. The legal remedies under Section 73/74 of the CGST Act were examined. The State argued that under Rule 86A of the Rules, the account could be blocked to prevent fraudulent transactions. The Court deliberated on the appropriate remedy and the powers of the Respondents to block the account.

5. The Court considered whether the petition had been rendered academic after the unblocking of the account and subsequent actions taken by the Petitioner. The implications of the order dated 13 September 2022 were analyzed, and the course of action for the pending petition was discussed.

6. The Court disposed of the writ petition by concluding that the issue regarding the unblocking of the Input Tax Credit account was settled by the order dated 13 September 2022. Other aspects were kept open for consideration in pending proceedings or for the Respondents to take further legal action, which the Petitioner could challenge as per the law.

---