Tribunal overturns rejection of duty refund claim paid via DEPB scrip, citing valid payment mode.

The Tribunal allowed the appeals, overturning the rejection of the refund claim for duty paid through DEPB scrip. It emphasized that the relevant Notifications did not prohibit refunds for duty paid via DEPB scrips if conditions were met, citing previous judgments supporting DEPB scheme debit as a valid mode of duty payment. The Tribunal found no justification to deny the refund claim, contrary to the Adjudicating Authority and Commissioner's decisions.

---

---

Issues:
Whether the appellant is entitled to a refund of additional duty of Customs (SAD) paid through DEPB scrip/licenseRs.

Analysis:
The appellant filed refund claims for SAD paid under Customs Tariff Act, 1975 through cash and DEPB License. The Adjudicating Authority sanctioned the refund of cash payments but rejected claims where duty was debited from DEPB License. The Commissioner upheld the rejection. The appellant argued that conditions in the relevant Notifications did not prohibit refunds for duty paid via DEPB scrips. The Revenue contended that a public notice by DGFT restricted refund for duty paid using DEPB scrips after 30/09/2013. The Tribunal noted that the Notifications did not deny refunds for duty paid through DEPB scrips if conditions were met. Citing previous judgments, including one by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, the Tribunal emphasized that DEPB scheme debit is a valid mode of duty payment. The Tribunal found no justification to reject the refund claim for duty paid through DEPB scrip, overturning the impugned order and allowing the appeals.

This detailed analysis of the judgment highlights the key arguments presented by the parties, the legal interpretation of relevant Notifications and public notices, and the Tribunal's reliance on previous judgments to support its decision in favor of the appellant.

---