AI TextQuick Glance (AI)Headnote
Issues: (i) Whether a corporate guarantee for a related person is a taxable supply of services and who is its recipient; (ii) whether the guarantee is excluded as an actionable claim or security; (iii) whether the prescribed valuation and input tax credit proviso are valid; (iv) when the supply occurs and which valuation regime applies to guarantees executed in different periods; and (v) whether the administrative circulars are valid.
Issue (i): Whether a corporate guarantee for a related person is a taxable supply of services and who is its recipient.
Analysis: Section 7 and Schedule I of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 dispense with consideration for a supply between related persons made in the course or furtherance of business. An explicit guarantee provides credit support through the guarantor's present assumption of default risk. The business connection is assessed with reference to the guarantor. The recipient definition turns on rendition of the service rather than privity with the lender.
Conclusion: The guarantee is a taxable supply of services even without consideration, and the related borrower is its recipient. The issue is decided against the assessee.
Issue (ii): Whether the guarantee is excluded as an actionable claim or security.
Analysis: The Schedule III exclusion concerns an actionable claim that is itself supplied. The supply to the borrower consists of credit support, not the lender's claim against the guarantor. The statutory exclusion for securities concerns the specified class of securities, not collateral merely described as security.
Conclusion: The guarantee is excluded from the levy neither as an actionable claim nor as a security. The issue is decided against the assessee.
Issue (iii): Whether the prescribed valuation and input tax credit proviso are valid.
Analysis: Sections 15 and 164 permit delegated valuation of related-person supplies. Rule 28(2) uses a deemed value of one per cent of the guarantee amount per annum or actual consideration, whichever is higher. A presumptive value addresses difficulty in finding comparables, but a compulsory minimum is arbitrary where a lower open market value can be established. The agreed related-party price or absence of consideration alone is insufficient evidence. The proviso accepting invoice value where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit reflects revenue neutrality.
Conclusion: Rule 28(2) and its proviso are valid, but the deemed value is a rebuttable presumption that gives way to a lower open market value established by cogent and verifiable material. The issue is partly in favour of the assessee.
Issue (iv): When the supply occurs and which valuation regime applies to guarantees executed in different periods.
Analysis: Assumption of risk occurs on execution; continued subsistence and invocation do not create recurring supplies. A gratuitous guarantee lacks the periodic payment obligations required for a continuous supply of services. Sections 13 and 31 govern the time of supply, while valuation for the entire tenure is computed at that time. Section 34 permits a credit note for premature discharge within its conditions and time limits. Earlier valuation rules supplied a machinery before Rule 28(2), and the 2024 amendment was partly beneficial and partly clarificatory.
Conclusion: A supply occurs on execution and afresh on renewal, extension or enhancement. Guarantees executed before 1 July 2017 are not taxable unless subsequently renewed, extended or enhanced. Guarantees executed from 1 July 2017 through 25 October 2023 are taxable under the valuation rules then in force, without a uniform one per cent measure. Rule 28(2) applies to relevant supplies from 26 October 2023, and the retrospective 2024 amendment is valid. The issue is decided partly in favour of the assessee.
Issue (v): Whether the administrative circulars are valid.
Analysis: Circulars under Section 168 cannot create or enlarge a levy. Their treatment of corporate guarantees, guaranteed amounts and renewals operates within the statutory framework, subject to the limits established for valuation and the time of supply.
Conclusion: The circulars are valid but cannot prevent proof of a lower open market value or treat continued subsistence of a pre-26 October 2023 guarantee as a fresh supply. The issue is decided partly in favour of the assessee.
Final Conclusion: Qualifying related-person guarantees are taxable subject to the established limits on valuation, timing and prospective application.
Ratio Decidendi: Presumptive valuation of a related-person corporate guarantee must be rebuttable by cogent and verifiable evidence of a lower open market value.
Corporate guarantee valuation permits evidence of lower market value, while GST applies on execution, renewal, extension or enhancement.
Related-person corporate guarantees supplied in the course or furtherance of business attract GST even without consideration; the related borrower receives the credit-support service, which is not excluded as an actionable claim or security. Rule 28(2) prescribes a deemed value of 1% of the guarantee amount per annum or actual consideration, whichever is higher, but a lower open market value may be established by cogent, verifiable evidence. Invoice value is accepted where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit. Supply occurs on execution and afresh on renewal, extension or enhancement, not through continued subsistence or invocation. Guarantees executed before 1 July 2017 are taxable only upon a subsequent renewal, extension or enhancement; those executed from 1 July 2017 through 25 October 2023 are valued under the rules then in force. Rule 28(2) applies from 26 October 2023, and the 2024 amendment applies retrospectively.
GST on gratuitous corporate guarantees between related persons - Corporate guarantees and actionable-claim exclusion - Corporate guarantees and securities exclusion - Rebuttable deemed valuation of corporate guarantees - Time of supply of corporate guarantees - Temporal operation of corporate guarantee valuation rules - GST circulars governing corporate guarantees GST on gratuitous corporate guarantees between related persons - Identification of recipient of credit support - Taxability of corporate guarantees furnished without consideration by holding or group companies for related persons' borrowings, and identification of the recipient - HELD THAT: - Entry 2 of Schedule I dispenses with consideration but presupposes an identifiable supply made in the course or furtherance of business. An explicit guarantee presently commits the guarantor's creditworthiness and borrowing capacity, enabling the related borrower to obtain finance or better terms. Such credit support is a service under Section 2(102). Furnishing guarantees to protect and advance the guarantor's commercial investment is incidental or ancillary to its own business; the shareholder motive does not alter the transaction's character. Under Section 2(93)(c), rendition, rather than contractual privity, identifies the recipient: the subsidiary receives the credit support although the lender is the promisee. Subsequent rights of subrogation and indemnity do not establish the supply or its recipient. Decisions under the consideration-based service-tax regime do not govern the materially different GST provisions. [Paras 64, 65, 67, 71, 72] Such guarantees constitute supplies of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I, notwithstanding the absence of consideration; the related person on whose behalf the guarantee is furnished is the recipient. Corporate guarantees and actionable-claim exclusion - Applicability of the actionable-claim exclusion to credit support supplied through a corporate guarantee - HELD THAT: - The exclusion in Entry 6 of Schedule III concerns a supply whose subject matter is itself an actionable claim, not every transaction in which such a claim may arise. The subsidiary receives credit support and acquires no claim against the guarantor. Any claim arising in the lender's favour is distinct from the service supplied to the subsidiary. It was therefore unnecessary to determine whether the lender's right against the guarantor constitutes a claim to a contingent debt. [Paras 73, 74, 75] The corporate guarantee service is not excluded from GST as an actionable claim under Entry 6 of Schedule III. Corporate guarantees and securities exclusion - Treatment of a corporate guarantee as a security excluded from the statutory definition of services - HELD THAT: - Section 2(101) adopts the definition of securities in Section 2(h) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956. Although inclusive, that definition concerns marketable instruments and rights or interests in securities. A guarantee is security in the sense of collateral for a debt; that meaning cannot be equated with a security under the adopted statutory definition. [Paras 77] A corporate guarantee does not fall within the securities exclusion in Section 2(102). Rebuttable deemed valuation of corporate guarantees - Lower open market value - Full input tax credit and invoice-value valuation - Validity of Rule 28(2), its deemed minimum valuation of corporate guarantees, and its invoice-value proviso for recipients eligible for full input tax credit - HELD THAT: - Sections 15 and 164 permit delegation of valuation within the statutory policy; a GST Council recommendation does not, however, immunise subordinate legislation from judicial review. Difficulty in obtaining comparables justifies the deemed value of 1% per annum as a rational default, not an irrebuttable minimum. It is a settled principle that efforts must be made to read down subordinate legislation, rather than striking it down, where this can be done without doing violence to its language [Ref: Calcutta Gujarati Education Society v Calcutta Municipal Corporation [2003 (8) TMI 476 - SUPREME COURT]] The safe-harbour benchmark from which it was drawn is optional, and ascertainable lower open market value cannot be rejected merely for administrative uniformity. The supplier must establish that lower value through cogent and verifiable material, which the proper officer may test. The non-obstante clause in Rule 28(2) overrides Rule 28(1) only where the supplier does not establish a lower open market value. Agreed intra-group consideration, including nil consideration, cannot by itself displace the presumption. Acceptance of invoice value where full input tax credit is available rests on revenue neutrality and is a valid classification; actual credit eligibility remains a factual question. [Paras 86, 87, 89, 90, 91] Rule 28(2) is intra vires Sections 15 and 164 and within Articles 246A and 265, but its operation as an irrebuttable minimum violates Article 14. It is read down to permit proof of lower open market value; its full-input-tax-credit proviso is valid. Time of supply of corporate guarantees - Single supply with a continuing obligation - Tenure-based valuation of guarantees - Time of supply of a gratuitous corporate guarantee, its treatment as a single or continuous supply, and computation of tax for its tenure - HELD THAT: - Assumption of risk is supplied upon execution and delivery of the guarantee; its continued enforceability does not repeat that supply. Renewal, extension of tenure or enhancement is a fresh supply confined to the additional period or amount, while invocation merely performs the existing obligation. A gratuitous guarantee lacks the periodic payment obligations required by Section 2(33), and a valuation fiction cannot create them. Section 13(2)(a) applies where the invoice is timely; otherwise, Section 13(2)(b) fixes the time by reference to provision of the service. Accounting disclosure neither attracts the residuary clause nor creates annual supplies. The annual valuation rate measures the tenure of a single undertaking, requiring computation at the time of supply for its entire tenure. Premature release may support a credit note under Section 34, subject to its conditions and time limits. Annual instalment collection may be provided without altering the supply or its time. [Paras 94, 95, 96, 97, 125] A gratuitous corporate guarantee is a single, not continuous, supply governed by Section 13(2)(a) or (b). Tax is computed for its entire tenure at the time of supply; the respondents remain at liberty to provide for collection in annual instalments. Temporal operation of corporate guarantee valuation rules - Pre-GST corporate guarantees - Retrospective amendment of valuation rules - GST treatment of guarantees executed before the GST regime, valuation before Rule 28(2), and validity of the retrospective amendment to that rule - HELD THAT: - A guarantee completed before 01.07.2017 does not become taxable merely because it remains enforceable; any subsequent renewal, extension or enhancement must be examined separately. Guarantees executed between 01.07.2017 and 25.10.2023 were taxable, but valuation must follow the rules then in force using guarantee-specific material. Existing machinery was not rendered ineffective merely by valuation difficulty. Rule 31 cannot indirectly impose the subsequently prescribed 1% as a uniform measure. Rule 28(2) operates from 26.10.2023 and does not attach to an earlier guarantee solely through its continued subsistence. The 2024 amendment validly operates from that date: confinement to recipients located in India is beneficial, the annual-rate clarification explains the benchmark's existing basis, and the limited retrospectivity is reasonable and authorised by Section 164(3). The request of the Respondents to extend the Rule to the earlier period by ‘harmonious construction’ or on the ground that it is beneficial, must be declined. The Court cannot do what the delegate has not done, and a provision affecting substantive liability is presumed to be prospective [Ref: CIT v Vatika Township (P) Ltd. [2014 (9) TMI 576 - SUPREME COURT (LB)].[Paras 102, 103, 104, 105, 107] Unrenewed, unextended and unenhanced pre-GST guarantees are not taxable. Guarantees supplied before 26.10.2023 are valued under the then-operative rules, without a uniform 1% benchmark. Rule 28(2) applies to execution, renewal, extension or enhancement on or after that date; the retrospective 2024 amendment is valid. GST circulars governing corporate guarantees - Limits of administrative clarification - Validity and permissible operation of Circular Nos. 204/16/2023-GST and 225/19/2024-GST concerning corporate guarantees - HELD THAT: - Circulars issued under Section 168 of the Act of 2017 bind the officers of the department, but do not bind the assessee or the Court, and a circular contrary to the statute has no existence in law [Ref: Ratan Melting & Wire Industries [2008 (10) TMI 5 - SUPREME COURT]. Also a circular can neither create a levy nor widen the scope of a charge [Ref: Karvy Stock Broking [2015 (8) TMI 159 - SC ORDER] and Faridabad Iron & Steel Traders Association [2003 (11) TMI 107 - DELHI HIGH COURT]]. Section 168 permits instructions for uniform implementation, not creation or enlargement of a levy. Circulars bind departmental officers, but not the assessee or the Court. Their premise that related-person corporate guarantees are taxable follows the statute. Different treatment of directors' personal guarantees rests on a generally applicable regulatory restriction affecting open market value, unlike an intra-group contractual prohibition on commission. Valuation by reference to the amount committed, rather than the amount disbursed, reflects the risk undertaken. The clarifications concerning multi-year guarantees, fresh guarantees on loan takeovers and pre-amendment valuation are sustainable subject to the statutory construction adopted. [Paras 108, 109, 110, 111, 112] Both circulars are intra vires Section 168, but must permit proof of lower open market value and cannot treat the continued existence of a guarantee executed before 26.10.2023 as a fresh supply. Final Conclusion: The petitions were partly allowed in the stated terms. Impugned notices, orders and demands were set aside to the extent inconsistent with the findings, with fresh determination after hearing; reserved factual questions and additional issues remain open.