Tribunal Grants Full Waiver & Stay on Recovery Pending Disposal

The Tribunal granted a full waiver of pre-deposit beyond the appellant's deposit of Rs. 10 lakhs, ordering a stay on recovery pending case disposal. The case was directed for an early hearing due to revenue implications, set for 02/11/2016, with the Tribunal considering the potential impact on similar cases.

---

---

Issues:
1. Service tax liability on ocean freight charges and expenses
2. Irregular availment of CENVAT credit
3. Service tax liability on amounts received from SEZ units

Analysis:
1. The appellants, providing steamer agent services, faced a show-cause notice for not paying service tax on ocean freight charges exceeding expenses and for service provided to SEZ units. The adjudicating authority confirmed demands including service tax on excess ocean freight charges, short payment on services, reimbursable amounts, irregular CENVAT credit, and other P&L account amounts. The total liability was Rs. 1,82,83,322, with penalties and interest imposed.

2. The appellant's counsel cited precedents to argue against the demands. The Tribunal found the demands related to reimbursable amounts were covered by previous cases. The Mumbai Tribunal distinguished a Larger Bench decision regarding reimbursable amounts. Considering the appellant's deposit of Rs. 10 lakhs during investigation, the Tribunal granted a full waiver of pre-deposit beyond this amount, ordering a stay on recovery pending case disposal.

3. The Assistant Commissioner requested an early hearing due to revenue implications, which both parties agreed to. The Tribunal directed the case to be listed for an early hearing on 02/11/2016, acknowledging the potential impact on similar cases.

---