Loss of Exemption for Charitable Trust Donations to Religious Trusts: Tribunal Ruling

The Tribunal dismissed the assessee's appeals for the assessment years 2009-10 and 2010-11, upholding the disallowance of contributions made to M/s. Little Flower Monastery under Section 13(1)(b). The Revenue's appeal for the assessment year 2011-12 was allowed, reinforcing that contributions to a religious trust result in the loss of exemption under Section 11. The Tribunal emphasized that a charitable trust cannot donate to a trust formed for religious purposes, and any violation of Section 13(1)(b) leads to the loss of exemption under Section 11.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Disallowance of contributions made to a religious trust under Section 13(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act.
2. Applicability of Section 11(3) and Section 11(5)(d) regarding the donation of income by a charitable trust.
3. Admissibility of additional grounds raised by the assessee.
4. Impact of excess application of income on the exemption under Section 11.
5. Revenue's appeal against the CIT(A)'s decision to grant exemption despite the violation of Section 13(1)(b).

Issue-wise Detailed Analysis:

1. Disallowance of Contributions Made to a Religious Trust under Section 13(1)(b):
The primary issue in ITA Nos. 2270/Mds./14 and 1222/Mds./14 (Assessee's Appeals) and ITA No. 2714/Mds./14 (Revenue's Appeal) revolves around the disallowance of contributions made by the assessee to M/s. Little Flower Monastery, Coimbatore. The Assessing Officer (AO) disallowed these contributions on the grounds that the recipient, M/s. Little Flower Monastery, is a religious trust, and contributions to such a trust are hit by Section 13(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act, which debars charitable institutions from existing for a particular religious community. The CIT(A) upheld this disallowance, stating that the Monastery did not carry out any charitable activities and was advancing money to various provinces of the Christian Missionary, thus classifying it as a religious institution.

2. Applicability of Section 11(3) and Section 11(5)(d):
The assessee argued that the contributions were made out of its income for the relevant assessment year and not from accumulated income, hence Section 11(3) and not Section 11(5)(d) should apply. The Tribunal noted that as per the provisions of Section 11(1), a charitable trust must apply 85% of its income for charitable or religious purposes. However, if income is paid or credited to another trust or institution, it is deemed to be the income of the assessee as per Section 11(3) and Section 11(5)(d). The Tribunal concluded that donations to a trust with religious objects cannot be considered as an application of income for charitable purposes, thus upholding the disallowance.

3. Admissibility of Additional Grounds Raised by the Assessee:
In ITA No. 1222/Mds./14, the assessee raised additional grounds regarding the excess application of income. The Tribunal admitted these additional grounds, citing the Supreme Court's judgment in National Thermal Power Co. Ltd. Vs. CIT, which allows new grounds to be raised if they involve questions of law arising from the facts on record.

4. Impact of Excess Application of Income on the Exemption under Section 11:
The assessee contended that even after disallowing the contribution, there was an excess application of income, which should entitle it to exemption under Section 11. However, the Tribunal rejected this argument, stating that any violation under Section 13(1)(b) results in the loss of exemption under Section 11, regardless of the excess application of income.

5. Revenue's Appeal Against the CIT(A)'s Decision:
In ITA No. 2714/Mds./14, the Revenue challenged the CIT(A)'s decision to grant the assessee the benefit of set off against excess application of income despite the violation of Section 13(1)(b). The Tribunal agreed with the Revenue, reiterating that contributions to a religious trust result in the loss of exemption under Section 11, and thus, the appeal of the Revenue was allowed.

Conclusion:
The Tribunal dismissed the assessee's appeals for the assessment years 2009-10 and 2010-11, upholding the disallowance of contributions made to M/s. Little Flower Monastery under Section 13(1)(b). The Revenue's appeal for the assessment year 2011-12 was allowed, reinforcing that contributions to a religious trust result in the loss of exemption under Section 11. The Tribunal emphasized that a charitable trust cannot donate to a trust formed for religious purposes, and any violation of Section 13(1)(b) leads to the loss of exemption under Section 11.

---