Tribunal Rules on Rectification Requests: Adjustments for Interest and Guarantee Fees Accepted, IT Licence Costs Rejected.

The ITAT Mumbai adjudicated multiple rectification requests concerning adjustments for I.T. Licence Maintenance costs, interest on trade creditors, and corporate guarantee fees. The Tribunal rejected the rectification concerning I.T. Licence Maintenance costs, finding no apparent error. However, it accepted rectifications regarding interest on trade creditors and corporate guarantee fees, recalling orders to address specific grounds of appeal, ensuring accurate adjudication.

---

---

Issues:
1. Rectification in para-6 of the Tribunal order dated 05.03.2020 regarding adjustment on account of payment of I.T. Licence Maintenance cost.
2. Rectification in para-11 of the Tribunal order dated 05.03.2020 regarding adjustment on account of payment of interest on trade creditors.
3. Rectification in the order of Tribunal in ITA No. 4607/Mum/2019 for A.Y. 2013-14 regarding additional evidence filed by the assessee.

Issue 1: Rectification in para-6 of the Tribunal order dated 05.03.2020
The assessee filed a Miscellaneous Application seeking rectification in the Tribunal order concerning the adjustment on account of payment of I.T. Licence Maintenance cost for the Assessment Year 2012-13. The Tribunal had remitted the issue back to the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO)/Assessing Officer (AO) for reexamination based on the evidence provided by the assessee. The Authorized Representative (AR) argued that the Tribunal should have decided the issue instead of remitting it to the AO/TPO since all material was available. The Department opposed the rectification, stating that the issue required fresh examination based on the evidence furnished. The Tribunal rejected the first prayer for rectification, finding no apparent mistake in its decision.

Issue 2: Rectification in para-11 of the Tribunal order dated 05.03.2020
The second prayer for rectification was related to para-11 of the Tribunal order concerning the adjustment on account of payment of interest on trade creditors. The Tribunal had mentioned the filing of additional evidence by the assessee, specifically a circular, which the AR clarified was not being relied upon. The Tribunal accepted the second prayer for rectification, acknowledging the error in considering the circular as additional evidence when no reliance was placed on it. The order was recalled for the limited purpose of adjudicating specific grounds of appeal.

Issue 3: Rectification in the order of Tribunal in ITA No. 4607/Mum/2019 for A.Y. 2013-14
The assessee filed another Miscellaneous Application seeking rectification in the order of Tribunal in ITA No. 4607/Mum/2019 for the Assessment Year 2013-14. The issue pertained to the adjustment on account of payment for corporate guarantee fee. The Tribunal had mentioned the filing of additional evidence by the assessee, but the AR clarified that no reliance was placed on any additional evidence. Consequently, the Tribunal allowed the Miscellaneous Application, recalling the order for the limited purpose of adjudicating specific grounds of appeal.

In conclusion, the Appellate Tribunal ITAT Mumbai addressed various rectification requests in the mentioned judgments, focusing on adjustments related to different payments and the consideration of additional evidence. The Tribunal carefully analyzed the arguments presented by the parties and made decisions based on the merits of each issue, ultimately allowing some rectifications while rejecting others to ensure a fair and accurate adjudication process.

---