Revision Application requires reevaluation of bank charges deduction & duty drawback amount recovery per Circular No. 33/2019-Customs

The Revision Application was disposed of with directions for a reevaluation of the deduction of bank charges and recovery of proportionate drawback amount. The matter was remanded back to the original authority for a fresh decision in accordance with Circular No. 33/2019-Customs, emphasizing the importance of considering bank charges in determining the realization of export proceeds for duty drawback purposes.

---

---

Issues:
1. Rejection of appeal against the Order-in-Original by Commissioner of Customs.
2. Failure to submit proof of export proceeds realization.
3. Recovery of availed drawback amount.
4. Appeal rejection by Commissioner (Appeals) as barred by limitation.
5. Grounds for rejection of appeal by Commissioner (Appeals).
6. Recovery of proportionate drawback amount.
7. Deduction of bank charges from export proceeds.
8. Validity of recovery of proportionate drawback amount.
9. Consideration of bank charges issue by lower authorities.
10. Compliance with Circular No. 33/2019-Customs.

Analysis:
The case involves a Revision Application filed against the rejection of an appeal by the Commissioner of Customs regarding the recovery of availed drawback amount. The Applicant had filed drawback claims for 176 Shipping Bills but failed to submit proof of export proceeds realization, leading to a demand for recovery of Rs. 88,16,720/- along with interest. The Commissioner (Appeals) rejected the appeal as barred by limitation, based on the Applicant's failure to prove realization of export proceeds within the stipulated time period.

During the personal hearing, the Applicant admitted the non-realization of export proceeds for 2 Shipping Bills within the specified time period, while arguing that the remaining amount included bank charges deducted by the Bank. The Government observed that the recovery of proportionate drawback amount was valid for the 2 Shipping Bills but required reevaluation for the remaining 174 Shipping Bills due to the deduction of bank charges. The Circular No. 33/2019-Customs clarified that duty drawback is not recoverable if export proceeds are short due to bank charges deducted by foreign banks.

Ultimately, the Government directed a relook into the deduction of bank charges and recovery of proportionate drawback amount, remanding the matter back to the original authority for a fresh decision on merits in line with the Circular dated 19.09.2019. The Revision Application was disposed of with these directions, emphasizing the need for a thorough reconsideration of the issue related to bank charges and recovery of proportionate drawback amount.

---