Detention of goods under VAT law requires statutory reasons to believe, not conjecture or paper-reading errors.

Detention and seizure of goods under Section 48(2) of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008 are justified only when the officer has reasons to believe that the goods are not traceable to a bona fide dealer or are not properly accounted for in the dealer's records. Where the consignment is supported by the prescribed transport and transit documents and those records disclose no material discrepancy, seizure cannot rest on conjecture or an incorrect reading of the papers. On the stated facts, the documents showed proper support for the movement of goods, and the seizure action was therefore unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the detention and seizure of goods under Section 48 of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008 were sustainable when the goods were accompanied by the relevant transport documents and the record did not show that the goods were unaccounted for or not traceable to a bona fide dealer.

Analysis: The detention and seizure power under Section 48(2) can be exercised only where the officer has reasons to believe that the goods are not traceable to a bona fide dealer or that it is doubtful whether the goods are properly accounted for in the dealer's books or documents. The record showed that the consignment was supported by the prescribed transfer challan, statutory transport form, Mandi gate pass, 9R and goods receipt, and the entries in the documents did not disclose any material discrepancy. The inference that the goods were different, or that purchases from several sellers in a day made the transaction doubtful, was found to rest on incorrect reading of the documents and on conjectures rather than on legally relevant material. The assessment order also recorded that the goods dispatched were the same goods, reinforcing that the seizure action was unsupported by the statutory conditions.

Conclusion: The detention and seizure were held unsustainable and the writ petition was allowed by quashing the impugned detention memo, notice and seizure order.

---