Tribunal grants waiver for free supplies in taxable services value dispute

The Tribunal granted a prima facie case for the waiver of pre-deposit amounts under sections 76, 77, and 78 of the Finance Act, 1994, in a case concerning the inclusion of free supplies of Diesel, Fuel, and Explosives in the taxable services value. The Tribunal found precedent supporting that such supplies should not be included in the taxable services value, leading to the stay of recovery until the appeal's disposal and joint disposal with another related case.

---

---

Issues involved: Determination of taxable services value including free supplies of explosives and fuel, waiver of pre-deposit amounts u/s 76, 77, and 78 of the Finance Act, 1994.

In the present case, the issue revolved around the inclusion of the value of Diesel, Fuel, and Explosives supplied by M/s. Singareni Colleries Company Limited (SCCL) to the applicant for services like site formation, clearance, excavation, and demolition. The Revenue contended that the value of these supplies was not included in the taxable services value, leading to suppression. The applicant had been paying service tax based on the services' value rendered. The Chartered Accountant cited a previous case where a waiver was granted in a similar situation.

The JCDR argued that the consideration for taxable services should encompass both cash and kind, referring to Section 67 of the Finance Act. He mentioned that the amount paid for explosives was deducted from the applicant's progressive account by SCCL. After considering the arguments and records, the Tribunal found the issue to be identical to a previous stay order. Citing precedent where free supplies were not included in taxable services value, the Tribunal granted a prima facie case for the waiver of pre-deposit amounts. Consequently, the recovery was stayed until the appeal's disposal, and the appeal was linked with another similar case for joint disposal.

---