Section 80L deduction for private trust upheld despite assessment as an association of persons

A private trust administered by a single trustee for named beneficiaries, with beneficiaries' shares not ascertainable, was held entitled to deduction under section 80L even though it was assessed as an association of persons under section 164(1). The Court followed its earlier ruling on a similar trust and rejected the Department's contention that AOP assessment displaced the deduction. It also accepted that the Tribunal could adopt a dual status for computation of total income and levy of tax. The questions were answered in favour of the assessee and against the Department.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee-trust, though assessed in the status of an association of persons under section 164(1), was entitled to deduction under section 80L and whether the Tribunal could adopt a dual status for computation of total income and levy of tax.

Analysis: The trusts were private trusts administered by a single trustee for the benefit of named beneficiaries, and the shares of the beneficiaries were not ascertainable. The Department sought to deny relief under section 80L on the footing that the assessee was assessable as an association of persons. The question was covered by the earlier decision of the Court in respect of a similar trust, where it was held that such a trust was entitled to the benefit of section 80L notwithstanding assessment under section 164(1).

Conclusion: The assessee was entitled to deduction under section 80L, and the questions were answered in the affirmative and against the Department.

---