Strict construction of taxing entries bars cess on sugar manufacture and alcohol from molasses under the vegetable products entry.

In a taxing statute, an entry imposing cess must be construed strictly, and liability cannot be extended by implication or broad purposive reading. The expression "vegetable" is to be understood in common parlance, not in its botanical sense, and "processing" applies only where the product retains its character as a vegetable product. On that basis, sugar manufacture is not treated as processing of vegetable products, and manufacture of alcohol from molasses, being derived from sugar manufacture, is also outside the entry. The cess therefore could not be levied on either activity under the relevant schedule entry.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether sugar manufacturing industry falls within Entry 15 of Schedule I to the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution Cess Act, 1977 as a processing of vegetable products industry; (ii) Whether manufacture of alcohol from molasses, a by-product of sugar manufacture, falls within Entry 15 of Schedule I to the said Act.

Issue (i): Whether sugar manufacturing industry falls within Entry 15 of Schedule I to the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution Cess Act, 1977 as a processing of vegetable products industry.

Analysis: The Cess Act is a fiscal enactment and must be strictly construed, so liability cannot be imposed by implication or on a broad purposive reading. The expression "vegetable" in a taxing context is to be understood in common parlance, not in its botanical sense. The word "processing" also indicates treatment of vegetable products that retain their character as such, whereas sugar manufacture results in a commodity which is not commonly understood as a vegetable product. Sugarcane is an agricultural product, but not a vegetable product in the sense relevant to the entry.

Conclusion: Sugar manufacturing industry does not fall within Entry 15 of Schedule I to the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution Cess Act, 1977.

Issue (ii): Whether manufacture of alcohol from molasses, a by-product of sugar manufacture, falls within Entry 15 of Schedule I to the said Act.

Analysis: Since sugar manufacture itself is outside Entry 15, the further manufacture of alcohol from molasses, which is derived from sugar manufacture, cannot be brought within the same entry. The process does not convert the activity into processing of vegetable products within the meaning of the fiscal entry.

Conclusion: Manufacture of alcohol from molasses does not fall within Entry 15 of Schedule I to the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution Cess Act, 1977.

Final Conclusion: The cess could not be levied on sugar manufacturing units or on alcohol manufacture from molasses under Entry 15, and the connected matters were disposed of in accordance with that distinction.

Ratio Decidendi: In a taxing statute, an entry imposing cess must be construed strictly in common parlance, and an industry can be taxed only if its end product clearly and directly falls within the statutory description.

---