Classification of pump set accessories governed by specific tariff entry, not the general entry for electric machines.

Fan covers and terminal boxes specially manufactured for use in monoblock pump sets below 10 horse power were treated as accessories of the pump set, not as accessories of the electric motor. The court held that the motor formed an integral and inseparable part of the monoblock pump set in that context, so the goods contributed to the protection, convenience and safety of the pump set itself. A specific tariff entry covering pumping sets and their accessories therefore governed the classification, and the general entry for electrically worked machines and their parts and accessories did not apply. The goods were classified under Entry 89 of the First Schedule.

---

---

Issues: Whether fan covers and terminal boxes manufactured and supplied for use in monoblock pump sets below 10 horse power were taxable under Entry 89 of the First Schedule or under Entry 7, Part IV of the Second Schedule to the Madhya Pradesh Vanijya Kar Adhiniyam, 1994.

Analysis: The disputed items were found to be accessories. The decisive question was whether they were accessories of the electric motor or of the monoblock pump set. The motor was held to be an integral and inseparable part of the monoblock pump set, with no separate independent existence in that context. Since the items were specially manufactured for use in monoblock pump sets and contributed to their protection, convenience, and safety, they were treated as accessories of the pump set itself. A specific entry dealing with pumping sets and their accessories was held to govern the classification, and the general entry for machines worked by electricity and their parts and accessories could not apply.

Conclusion: The items were covered by Entry 89 of the First Schedule and not by Entry 7, Part IV of the Second Schedule. The classification made by the Commissioner was set aside and the writ petition was allowed.

---