Assessment notice must state the basis of satisfaction to satisfy natural justice and give a meaningful opportunity to respond.

A notice initiating assessment under section 46 of the West Bengal Value Added Tax Act, 2003 must disclose the specific basis of the authority's satisfaction that the return is incorrect or incomplete. The tribunal explained that a bare invocation of statutory power, without at least a brief indication of the enquiry result or other material relied on, deprives the dealer of a meaningful opportunity to answer the proposed action and breaches natural justice. On that basis, the Form 25 notice was held invalid and set aside for failing to state the reason for initiation of assessment proceedings.

---

---

Issues: Whether the notice in Form 25 initiating assessment under section 46 of the West Bengal Value Added Tax Act, 2003 was valid when it did not disclose the specific reason for forming the requisite satisfaction and thereby denied the dealer a meaningful opportunity to meet the case against it.

Analysis: Section 46(1) permits assessment to be initiated only after the authority, upon verification, enquiry, report or otherwise, is satisfied that the return is incorrect or incomplete. Section 66 enables requisition and inspection of accounts and documents, but the notice issued under section 46 must itself disclose, at least briefly, the basis on which the authority proposes to proceed. The requirement flows from the rule of natural justice, since notice is intended to inform the person concerned of the case to be met and to afford an effective opportunity of representation. A notice that merely invokes the statutory power without stating the particular ground or the result of the enquiry on which satisfaction is based is materially defective.

Conclusion: The notice was invalid and liable to be set aside because it did not specify the reason for initiation of assessment proceedings and therefore failed to provide a proper opportunity of hearing. The assessee succeeded.

Ratio Decidendi: A notice initiating assessment must itself disclose the specific basis of the authority's satisfaction so that the dealer can effectively answer the proposed action; a vague or reasonless notice under section 46 is vitiated for breach of natural justice.

---