Principal function test governs HSN classification of multifunctional digital copiers as computer peripherals when printing is dominant.

A multifunctional digital copier is classifiable under HSN 8471 as a computer peripheral when its principal function is printing and it is connectable to a computer. The classification turns on the HSN description of computer systems and peripherals and on the machine's principal purpose, not on the fact that it also performs scanning, copying, faxing or e-mail functions. A printer capable of receiving or delivering data in usable form through connection with a CPU falls within heading 8471, and a multifunction device is classified by its dominant function. Non-speaking advance rulings were not treated as displacing that approach, and the contrary view excluding all multifunctional digital copiers from HSN 8471 was rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether a multifunctional digital copier machine, whose principal function is printing and which is connectable with a computer, falls within HSN code 8471 as a computer peripheral under entry No. 3 of Schedule C, Part II of the West Bengal VAT Act, 2003.

Analysis: The classification turned on the HSN description of computer systems and peripherals and the functional character of the machine. A printer connectable to the central processing unit and capable of receiving or delivering data in usable form falls within HSN heading 8471. A machine used for more than one purpose is to be classified according to its principal purpose. Applying that approach, a multifunctional digital copier whose principal function is printing is treated as a computer peripheral, even though it also performs scanning, copying, faxing, or e-mail functions. The Tribunal also noted that non-speaking advance rulings did not displace this reasoning, while the impugned order erred in treating all multifunctional digital copiers as outside HSN 8471.

Conclusion: A multifunctional digital copier is classifiable under HSN code 8471 as a computer peripheral if its principal function is printing and the printer is connectable with a computer; the contrary view was incorrect.

---