Common-parlance classification of bamboo products determines exemption for processed articles, while split bamboo remains taxable as general goods.

Processed bamboo goods such as dhara, beti and chatai were treated as articles made of bamboo under item 1 of Schedule I because their common-parlance identity was that of manufactured products capable of independent use, and they were therefore exempt from sales tax. Unprocessed split bamboo, including split bamboo used as raw material in the paper industry, was held to be neither bamboo in the ordinary sense nor an article made of bamboo, so it did not qualify for the exemption and was taxable as general goods at the applicable general rate. The governing distinction was the degree of processing and the commercial character of the goods.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether dhara, beti, chatai and similar processed bamboo products are articles made of bamboo falling within item 1 of Schedule I to the West Bengal Sales Tax Act, 1994 and are exempt from sales tax. (ii) Whether unprocessed split bamboo and split bamboo used as raw material in paper industry are bamboo or articles made of bamboo, or general goods taxable at the general rate under Schedule VI to the West Bengal Sales Tax Act, 1994.

Issue (i): Whether dhara, beti, chatai and similar processed bamboo products are articles made of bamboo falling within item 1 of Schedule I to the West Bengal Sales Tax Act, 1994 and are exempt from sales tax.

Analysis: The goods described as dhara, beti and chatai were found, from the photographs and samples produced, to be already manufactured articles made out of bamboo. The earlier view on taraibeti was followed, and the same reasoning was applied to similar processed bamboo goods. The decisive factor was their character in common parlance as manufactured bamboo products capable of independent use, not mere bamboo as such.

Conclusion: Dhara, beti, chatai and similar processed bamboo products are articles made of bamboo under item 1 of Schedule I and are not taxable.

Issue (ii): Whether unprocessed split bamboo and split bamboo used as raw material in paper industry are bamboo or articles made of bamboo, or general goods taxable at the general rate under Schedule VI to the West Bengal Sales Tax Act, 1994.

Analysis: Bamboo was understood to mean whole bamboo or unsplit pieces cut from the ground. Unprocessed split bamboo was held to be neither bamboo nor an article made of bamboo. Split bamboo used merely as raw material in paper industry was also held not to acquire the character of exempt bamboo goods. Such goods therefore did not fall within the exempt entry and were treated as general goods.

Conclusion: Unprocessed split bamboo and split bamboo used as raw material in paper industry are general goods taxable at the general rate.

Final Conclusion: The applicants succeeded in relation to processed bamboo articles such as dhara, beti and chatai, but failed in relation to unprocessed split bamboo and split bamboo treated as raw material, and the assessment authorities were directed to determine refund wherever tax had been paid in excess.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods manufactured from bamboo are to be classified by their common-parlance identity and degree of processing: processed bamboo articles with independent utility are exempt bamboo articles, while unprocessed split bamboo remains outside that exemption and is taxable as general goods.

---